The hormone and dietary supplement melatonin is commonly used as a sleep aid — for one, because it’s a chemical our body naturally produces to help relax us.

But the same process that gives it relaxing and sleepy properties could be leading to extra sedation, anti-platelet effects and a harder-working liver.

“A lot of people struggle with getting to sleep or staying asleep,” said Brittany Nolton, clinical pharmacy specialist in ambulatory care with Allegheny Health Network. “But a lot of people also think these natural supplements are completely benign and there’s no way they’ll interact with what you’re already taking. There are a couple things to consider with melatonin.”

Because melatonin is sedating, when it's combined with drugs that are central nervous system depressants, that sedating effect can be heightened. The effect of sleepiness or sedation can be amplified, potentially leading to dizziness or grogginess that’s tough to shake off the next day.

Advertise with us

This means melatonin’s effects are heightened when combined with antidepressants such as escitalopram (Lexapro), fluoxetine (Prozac) and fluvoxamine (Luvox), as well as the ADHD medication viloxazine (Qelbree) and brexanolone (Zulresso), an infusion medication used to treat postpartum depression.

Some of these medicines increase the levels of an inhibitory chemical in the brain called Gamma-aminobutyric acid, or GABA, dampening signaling, which can feel like sedation. Alcohol also increases GABA, thus it can be contraindicated with melatonin.

“Too much of anything can always come with a concern of harm,” said Andreea Temelie, a clinical pharmacist specializing in outpatient adolescent psychiatry at UPMC Western Psychiatric Hospital. “It’s something we’ve been talking a lot about, that a natural or over-the-counter supplement doesn’t necessarily mean it’s safe.”

And many drugs are also processed through the same pathways in the liver, a main one being the CYP450 pathway, which can add stress to the liver if multiple of these drugs are taken for a long time. (Interestingly, many studies have also looked at melatonin as a treatment for liver scarring due to alcoholism).

In addition to feeling dizzy from sedation, melatonin lowers blood pressure and thins the blood — meaning people taking the blood thinner warfarin or blood pressure pills may experience this symptom more heavily.

Advertise with us

“This medication can alter blood pressure management,” said Nolton. “The overarching message is that these meds, although readily accessible, should always be double-checked with a pharmacist or health care provider to see if they interact with anything you’re already taking.”

A heightened effect could intensify melatonin’s other symptoms, such as vivid dreams, nightmares or restless leg syndrome.

Temelie agreed that transparency is probably the best policy, especially when adding a new over-the-counter supplement to your routine.

“Sometimes, medications you might not expect could affect melatonin,” she said. “It’s a good idea to check in with your team just in case.”