The gates of 15 city pools have opened, and summer has hit Pittsburgh with a bang — with sweltering heat waves early in the season.
But the temperature hasn’t been the only thing ratcheting up. So, too, has summertime misinformation.
Recently, some influencers on TikTok have been discouraging users from wearing sunscreen, claiming that it causes cancer. In one video posted in May, TikToker Keith Kimberlin holds a spray can of sunscreen and says, “These sunscreens on the market today are mostly toxic. These are actually more dangerous than you burning.” Kimberlin is a chiropractor.
The trend has received swift pushback from doctors and dermatologists who insist sunscreen has been extensively studied and is safe.
So where did this health misinformation like this come from, and what should we know about it?
“We’re in the heat of our summer, and this is just not good,” said Kristen Whitney, a dermatologist with Allegheny Health Network. “This is completely inaccurate and not based on any fact. Sunscreen doesn’t cause cancer.”
Read More
“Sunscreen causing cancer is not shown in any scientific study,” echoed Sonal Choudhary, a dermatologist and dermatopathologist with UPMC. “There is no clear evidence.”
The claim may have grown and morphed out of news from a few years ago. In 2021, Neutrogena and Aveeno voluntarily recalled a few of their sunscreen products due to testing that found the sunscreens were contaminated with the cancer-causing chemical benzene. CNN reported that a vast majority of sunscreens on the market tested negative for the chemical.
“This doesn’t mean all sunscreen is harmful or that all science in this field is discredited,” said Beth Hoffman, assistant professor at the University of Pittsburgh School of Public Health specializing in health misinformation in the media. “You often see on social media people taking advantage of the fact that most people don’t understand how the scientific process works. It’s used to exploit people’s real fears.”
Hoffman has seen similarities in rhetoric with the sunscreen debate and other topics, such as vaccines and vaping, that have fallen into mis- and disinformation loops. The language used is often rife with fearmongering to capture attention, such as sounding the alarm about “toxic chemicals,” buzzwords like “freedom,” declarative language to express certainty, and personal anecdotes to discredit the scientific process. For example, someone could have an allergic reaction to sunscreen and conclude sunscreen on the whole is unsafe.
Whitney has girls of her own, ages 8 and 11, who she educates about proper sourcing online.
“With social media now, that’s where people are getting their information,” she said. “Many young kids are accepting it at face value. I try with my own kids to tell them, ‘You really have to analyze where this information comes from when you see it on social media.’”
A companion to the erroneous “don’t use sunscreen” claims are influencers making DIY sunscreen, which dermatologists have also denounced.
Influencer and model Nara Smith posted a video of herself in June whisking various ingredients in a bowl in her kitchen and pouring an inexact measurement of zinc oxide powder into the mixture.
“We have had a lot of people making products and claiming it can fight UV damage,” said Choudhary.
“You cannot be your own chemist,” said Whitney. “Stick with making slime at home.”
One in five Americans will develop skin cancer — the most common form of cancer — in their lifetime, according to the American Academy of Dermatology. Although melanoma is rare, it’s the most deadly form of skin cancer, expected to kill about 8,000 people this year.
Pennsylvania has a rate of 21.3 melanoma cases per 100,000, just under the national rate of 22.5 per 100,000, per data from cancer.gov. Melanoma cases have been decreasing in the commonwealth since 2014.
Having five or more sunburns can double one’s risk for skin cancer, Whitney said, but by using sunscreen and other protective measures such as sunglasses, headwear and staying in the shade, one can reduce their risk by nearly half.
Sunscreen and UV light are among the most studied subjects out there, said Whitney, having been regulated by the FDA since the 1970s. New technology has brought us UV-protective clothing as well, which Whitney said can be great for kids.
Still, the recent sunscreen misinformation was unsurprising.
“We hear things like this all the time,” said Choudhary. She’s “passively active” on social media in an attempt to stay abreast of trends, so she can combat them in the clinic. About a week ago, she saw a patient who questioned whether cold days were less harmful because when they got sunburns on those days, they tended to hurt less. Choudhary reminded the patient that even during cloudy, windy and snowy days, the UV radiation from the sun can still be very strong.
“I can see where they’re coming from,” she said regarding the TikTok trend, “but that does not make it right. They’re not correct. They’re trying to rationalize something that doesn’t add up.”
The sunscreen misinformation currently circulating does not appear in isolation: Whitney has seen falsehoods about other health and wellness topics on social media too.
“A couple years back, younger girls were getting counterfeit Botox, learning how to do their own Botox and fillers, or getting Botox outside the U.S.,” she said. “It’s an unending battle to stay on top of this.”
This misinformation spreading on social media is particularly dangerous because of how many people it can reach and how the pandemic left trust in science fractured.
“People are using their personal anecdotes, like reacting badly to a sunscreen, and putting it out as scientific fact,” Hoffman said. “This is taking advantage of the fact that trust in medicine and public health has been pretty low. It’s using any change in science or recommendations as ‘evidence’ that public health recommendations cannot be trusted.”
The trend reveals a growing need for providers to have conversations with patients about health misinformation they might be seeing online, and to refresh training in media literacy.
Choudhary stresses that trust and delivery matter when providers are talking with patients about what they’re reading online.
“How you’re delivering these messages is a very powerful tool in preventing this type of messaging from propagating,” she said. “People look up to these influencers because they relate to them. If you shut people out, you lose the relatability and the communication with the patient. Our job is to be the sounding board and give them feedback.”
If younger patients can’t appreciate sunscreen for protecting against the danger of the sun’s radiation, they can look to it for its anti-aging potential, said Whitney.
“Eighty percent of skin aging is caused by the sun,” she said. “You can still enjoy being outside, you just have to be smart about it. Your 30-, 40- and 80-year-old self will thank you.”
Tips for staying safe in the sun
- When choosing a brand that works for you, opt for either physical or chemical sunscreens, said Whitney. Physical or mineral sunscreens come in liquid form and produce a protective barrier on the surface of the skin, containing the UV blockers zinc oxide or titanium. Chemical sunscreens in spray form contain other UV-blocking chemicals and absorb into the skin.
- The most important thing is to pick a sunscreen you will use, said Choudhary. And the American Academy of Dermatology Association recommends sunscreen with SPF 30 or higher.
- When swimming, liquid sunscreen will need to be reapplied. Many spray sunscreens stick to the skin even when exposed to water, but liquid will wash off. Johns Hopkins Medicine suggests reapplying sunscreen every two hours. “Reapplication is something nobody seems to do,” said Choudhary. “If you’re outside and you applied sunscreen five hours ago, that sunscreen is gone.”
- Avoid being out in direct sun during peak hours, typically between 10 a.m. and 4 p.m.
Hanna Webster: hwebster@post-gazette.com





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.