As states across the U.S. — 25 to date — continue to enact legislation restricting access to gender-affirming care, Pittsburgh emerges as a bit of a beacon.
Tens of thousands of LGBTQ+ residents in the city access medical care every year, including a percentage who take hormones to better align with their gender. Numerous Pittsburgh clinics offer gender-affirming care — a form of health care that provides both medical and non-medical support for transgender and nonbinary people.
And while nearby states, West Virginia included, have imposed severe restrictions, Pittsburgh declared itself a sanctuary city for those needing such care.
For people working in this space, Pittsburgh, all things considered, is above the curve.
“It’s pretty easy to find a provider to prescribe [hormones], if you know where to look,” said Charlie Borowicz, the program manager for transgender health at Allegheny Health Network’s Center for Inclusion Health.
One of the biggest hurdles? Insurance.
“There are not as many barriers as there used to be but, sometimes, insurance only wants to cover one route of administration,” said Borowicz.
Organizations including the American Medical Association, the American Academy of Pediatrics, the World Health Organization and the Endocrine Society endorse gender-affirming care, citing its long history and life-saving potential.
Hormone therapy has been around for decades for both transgender and cisgender people, cisgender referring to those whose sex aligns with that assigned at birth. Cis women, for instance, have been taking estradiol and progestin, forms of estrogen and progesterone that the body naturally produces, to treat symptoms of menopause for nearly 100 years.
“Trans medicine is not a new practice,” said G. Samantha Rosenthal, visiting associate professor of American history at Washington and Lee University in Lexington, Va., specializing in gender and women’s history. “It’s not experimental. There’s been a field of medicine aboveground since the ’70s. … The medical knowledge is actually quite established and well-documented.”
Pittsburgh has been building its options for gender-affirming care and hormone therapy over the past decade. Allies for Health and Wellbeing, an inclusive clinic in East Liberty, opened in 2016 and grew out of the Pittsburgh AIDS Task Force. It offers gender-affirming care, including hormone therapy, as well as gynecological and HIV care.
“As an organization, Allies for Health and Wellbeing is proud to offer gender-affirming care, since this care is essential to the health and wellbeing of transgender individuals,” said Allies spokesperson May Beth Wyko via email. “We applaud the City of Pittsburgh for taking the progressive step forward of protecting the rights of people who are seeking gender-affirming care and those — like us — who provide that care.”
Marvin McGowan, a physician at Central Outreach Wellness Center on the North Shore, has been working with transgender patients and providing hormone therapy for about eight years, and he’s seen the benefit it can have to a person’s wellbeing.
The biggest hurdles he observes with hormone therapy are related to insurance coverage — an issue that’s not unique to Pittsburgh.
“I do feel Pittsburgh is a lot better [than other cities],” said McGowan. “But we have a lack of access in small towns around the area. Telemedicine and satellite clinics are attempting to address this.”

Modern-day hormone therapy began during the Great Depression to treat menopausal women, with drugs first derived from the urine of pregnant women, then of pregnant horses, until synthetic forms became available.
Clinics that offered hormone therapy to transgender people started popping up as early as the ’60s in America, and institutions began research on intersex people, which, per GLAAD, “refers to someone with one or more innate sex characteristics, including genitals, internal reproductive organs, and chromosomes, that fall outside of traditional conceptions of male or female bodies.”
Visibility of transgender people also increased during this time. Actress Christine Jorgenson was thrust into the mainstream when her transition was publicized in the New York Daily News in 1952.
Johns Hopkins University opened a Gender Identity Clinic in 1966, the first clinic of its kind in the nation, which provided hormone therapy and gender-affirming surgery.
“In the ’70s, transexual medicine went pretty mainstream,” said Rosenthal. “Surprisingly, there was a lot of support. The tenor was one of fascination, and not of fear or controversy like today.”
But in 1979, the Johns Hopkins clinic shut down, due to ostensible evidence that gender-affirming surgeries were not improving the quality of life of transgender patients. A 2022 paper by Johns Hopkins medical student Walker McGrath, published in the journal Annals of Internal Medicine, found through archival research that a lack of evidence wasn’t the cause of the abrupt shutdown: Pressure and pushback from higher-ups led to its closure.
“By the early ’90s, only two or three clinics were still operating,” said Rosenthal. “It was the Dark Ages for several decades, where trans people had to get hormones illegally or from private clinicians.”
Clinics began to open again around when Time magazine dedicated a cover to Laverne Cox, a trans woman known for her role in “Orange is the New Black,” in 2014; it bore the headline, “The Transgender Tipping Point.”
McGowan, a gay man, said he’s seen fluctuations in the closeness of the Pittsburgh LGBTQ+ community over many decades. He saw it come together in the ’80s to find a cure for AIDS, he said, and he’s recently noticed many young “movers and shakers” revitalizing a fractured sense of community by working to connect queer and trans people to resources.
Charlie Borowicz knows this firsthand. Borowicz, who is trans and uses they/them pronouns, helps connect queer patients with services throughout AHN’s network.
Hormones can be taken orally, as with an estradiol pills, or can be injected. Borowicz said injection is typically tougher to get covered by insurance.
Borowicz, who also takes hormones, said supply is a concern. Sometimes it’s a shortage of testosterone; other times, it’s the needles, which can vary in size and be more difficult to find.
Those barriers can lead to risky behaviors.
“If access is limited or inconsistent, you may have people who are acting out of desperation, who are purchasing black-market hormones,” said Borowicz. “Gender-affirming care is essential to trans people. It is medically necessary but also necessary for people who need it to live a full, authentic life.”
Consequences from recent restrictions are already rippling outward. People are visiting the Center for Inclusion Health from states where access has been curbed, Borowicz said, such as Ohio and West Virginia.
Julie Beaulieu, a gender studies professor at the University of Pittsburgh, said the country’s recent target of gender-affirming care misses the mark.
“The majority of people taking hormones are cisgender people,” said Beaulieu, who uses both she/her and they/them pronouns. “It doesn’t benefit cis people any more than trans people to have this binary of ‘who is allowed to take hormones.’”
Although the city boasts multiple clinics offering hormone therapy, it’s not void of the financial barriers to access seen across the country. Surgeries, for instance, cost thousands if insurance doesn’t cover them, impacting low-income queer people disproportionately.
“It’s still the case that if you have the money, you’re opting to get surgery elsewhere,” said Beaulieu. Saving for surgery, transportation costs and childcare can all hinder someone from doing so.
And McGowan thinks rampant misperceptions about hormone therapy are adding fuel to the fire.
“All these bills are all political,” he said. “They have nothing to do with health. The [World Professional Association for Transgender Health] guidelines have been around since 1979. Now that people are asking for access to care, they’re being denied care.”
An even more inclusive Pittsburgh of the future might consider moving away from the “distress model,” which Beaulieu described as the policy which requires transgender people to be diagnosed with gender dysphoria, in some states for many years, before being able to access gender-affirming care.
Central Outreach said this is not a requirement for its patients seeking hormone therapy; at AHN, insurance requires the diagnosis for billing purposes.
For cis people who want plastic surgery to feel more confident, or for postmenopausal women who take hormones to feel more comfortable, the same isn’t true.
“Why do you have to be in distress in order to be given care?,” asked Beaulieu. “We still believe that some people really need it and some don’t. It retains this idea of a trans life as an unhappy or disordered experience.”
Hanna Webster: hwebster@post-gazette.com






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.