This article is based on the most recent episode of our parenting podcast, 412 Kids. Look for new episodes on Wednesdays.
Before Post-Gazette food editor Gretchen McKay made a living out of food, she made food — baby food — for her lively brood of children, all five of them.
Makers of at-home baby food have a range of motivations, from frugality to a desire for local, farm-fresh foods, but for McKay, the process was born out of necessity.
Her husband’s job moved the couple and their 6-week-old baby, Danny, to Hong Kong, where, 37 years ago, store-bought baby food options were limited.
“Back when I started making baby foods, I think only hippies did it,” she said. “I don’t think I even had a food processor. I think I just had a fork.”
In 2024 the resources in the U.S. are seemingly endless, with $100 to $200 food processors marketed specifically for baby food making while the pre-made, jarred baby food on retailers’ shelves cater to a wide variety of dietary preferences.
Read More
But with grocery store prices about 25% higher than before the COVID-19 pandemic, it’s arguably more important than ever to trim down the food shopping bill, and skipping convenience and/or preprepared foods, including baby food, is one of the most obvious ways to do that.
“It’s so easy, that’s the thing,” McKay said. “People just overthink things a lot of times. I’m sure it’s scary if you’re a first-time mom and not an everyday cook. But just start with something easy, like a banana or sweet potato.”
Just microwave or bake a sweet potato until soft, she said. Scoop it out of its skin, and mash it with a fork, potato masher, blender, or similar device, then combine with water or breast milk until smooth.
The same process applies to apples, which can be cooked down in a pan with a little bit of water, and then mashed.
While simple, those processes do imply shouldering some decision-making that is unnecessary when buying jarred baby food, such as how smooth (or chunky) the food should be to prevent choking.
The first step, according to Sarah Rossman, UPMC Children’s Hospital occupational therapist on the feeding team, is to make sure the baby is physiologically ready for solid foods.
“When we think about feeding development, we have to think about development of the whole child,” she said. “We see that feeding development goes hand in hand with gross motor development.”
Look for good head and trunk control while the infant is sitting, she said, making sure they aren’t wobbling or falling over. With more control in the trunk, the hands are free to focus on exploring first foods, and strong neck control allows them to direct efforts toward the jaw for biting and chewing.
Those skills typically develop in the 4 to 6 month range, which is why the American Academy of Pediatrics identifies this time period as appropriate for starting solid foods. There are, however, a few ways to prepare that potato.
Families can pursue pureed foods, meaning classic baby foods, or baby-led weaning, where little ones are offered small, safe bites of table foods. In many cases, parents — accidentally or intentionally — employ some combination of the two approaches.
Again following gross motor milestones, Rossman advises parents to look for advancements in chewing development around the 8-to-10-month period, when crawling develops, and again around 12 months, during cruising and walking.
For those purchasing jarred baby food, those periods of development may trigger changes in buying habits, from stage one foods, to stage two, then three — signaling a progression in texture — which are often printed on baby food jar labels. But for those feeding at home, there’s less emphasis on “stages,” to the relief of some.
“When it comes to stage three foods, we at the feeding and swallowing clinic, as a whole, we hate them,” Rossman said. “They’re a confusing texture for kids.”
She likens their texture, which is often a thick puree with random larger chunks of the food, to cereal with milk or a broth-y soup. For more advanced eaters, it takes no additional thought to stash chunks in the cheeks while swallowing the liquid, then chewing and swallowing the solid. But for new eaters, “it’s really difficult,” Rossman said.
When preparing foods at home, however, progression toward chunkier, more adult-like foods comes simply by mashing or blending less, yielding a feeding-friendly consistent texture.
Then, there’s the issue of which foods to introduce and how.
While sweet potatoes, apples and bananas are classic first foods, there’s no guideline that makes that so.
“I would say those are chosen because they’re sweet, and they’re easy to prepare,” said Elizabeth Sinclair, medical director of the Feeding and Swallowing Center at UPMC Children’s. “But sometimes I wait on things like apples and pears, things that are overly sweet, or I’ll add something to it — like apples with cumin or cinnamon — so they’re getting not just the sweetness, but a more diverse flavor profile.”
According to Sinclair, the parental drive to expose kids to a wide variety of flavors does have some limited scientific backing, as it’s been shown to result in less picky eating, less distress around meals, improved progression in overall feeding and greater tolerance of textures.
By making baby food at home, a variety of tastes and textures is easily achieved with culinary herbs and spices, which “very rarely” produce allergic reactions, Sinclair said.
When it comes to the “Big Nine” allergens — cow’s milk, eggs, tree nuts, peanuts, shellfish, wheat, soy, fish and sesame — introduction should be a bit more intentional, Sinclair said, spending three to five days with each new high-allergen food to monitor for any reactions.
In large part, this method relies on the so-called LEAP trial. Published in 2015, it showed early and consistent introduction of peanuts, by 4 to 6 months of age, to kids at high risk of developing a food allergy, implied an 81% relative reduction in peanut allergy at 5 years of age.
A follow-up to the LEAP trial published at the end of May showed early, consistent introduction, through age 5, implies protection against peanut allergy until adolescence.
“For the most part, people spread that knowledge learned from peanut allergies to others of the big food allergens,” Sinclair said.
But there’s always an exception. Caregivers of kids with a confirmed egg allergy or severe eczema should consult with their pediatric practitioners to determine whether allergy testing should occur before consuming high-allergen foods, especially peanuts.
Regardless of the food, feeding should be a multi-sensory experience, as kids rely on the tactile sensations of their hands to inform what might be good to eat.
“If you think about those traditional first food pictures, where babies have food all over their hands, all over their faces, that’s what we love to see,” Rossman said. “That’s what they should be doing. We want them to get messy like that.”
Those experiences don’t discriminate between store-bought, jarred baby food or homemade, which can be made fresh or frozen for later use.
But the word of the day, when it comes to food and babies up until 1 year of age, is experimentation.
“It’s about skill-building and exposure. It’s not about nutrition,” Sinclair said. “They’re getting their nutrition from breast milk or formula. The rest are bonus calories. They’re not contributing to your baby’s overall growth nutritionally, but they’re contributing to their development and sensory progression,” which is another area where homemade baby food shines.
Not every lot of apples or sweet potatoes tastes the same, and when sent through the blender, or ground beneath a fork, not every batch has the same texture.
Those inconsistencies prepare babies well for the reality of eating whole, unprocessed foods — and all of their known nutritional benefits — as toddlers, children and older humans. And when introduced during the 6-to-12-month age range — a scientifically demonstrated “sensitive period” in which learning can take place more easily — babies are more willing to accept those differences and perceive them as “normal,” which is yet another argument for including a wide variety of foods, along with herbs and spices.
In the famous, somewhat condescending words of Ina Garten, “store-bought is fine,” though in this case, there’s no ivory tower: Here, the definition of success is happy, healthy kids, whether Gerber cooked or mom did.
For those inclined toward DIY baby food, however, it’s not as intimidating a task as it might seem, and if you get stuck, feel free to email your friendly neighborhood Post-Gazette food editor, who, as a grandmother, has begun the baby food-making phase all over again.
“I just like knowing what’s going into my child. I like having control. And I like that it is fresh, it doesn’t have preservatives, and there isn’t salt or sugar they don’t need,” McKay said.
“It’s fun. It’s a fun thing to do, and it makes you feel good to know you’re feeding your child really good food.”
RECIPES

Homemade Applesauce
2 pounds apples, washed, peeled, cored and chopped
Water
Cinnamon or cumin to taste (optional)
Add chopped apples to a large pot and fill with just enough water to cover.
Bring water to boil, then lower heat to medium, cover and simmer for about 5-6 minutes, or until fruit is easily pierced with a fork
Drain, reserving some of the liquid.
Puree until smooth in a food processor, food mill, blender or with an immersion blender, adding cooking liquid as needed for desired consistency.
Cool to room temperature, and serve. Can be spooned into clean ice cube trays and placed in freezer overnight to set; transfer cubes to a resealable plastic bag for storage up to 3 months.
For stage 2: Flavor applesauce with a sprinkle or two of ground cinnamon, nutmeg or ginger.

Pureed Carrots
1 pound fresh carrots
¼ to ½ cup formula, water or breast milk, to thin
Parsley, thyme or paprika to taste (optional)
Peel carrots and cut into small, even-sized chunks.
Fill a saucepot with about 1 inch of water. Add carrots to a steamer basket and place inside pot. Bring water to a low boil, then cover pot with a lid and steam carrots until fork-tender, about 15 to 20 minutes. (Alternatively, microwave for 10 or so minutes, until carrots are very tender.)
Drain carrots, then using a blender, food mill or immersion blender, puree carrots until mixture is smooth.
Cool to room temperature, then serve.
For stage 2: Flavor carrot puree with a pinch of ground ginger, cardamom or a bit of butter. Or, cook carrots in chicken stock and add a pinch of a Chinese five-spice powder, or pair with apple or pear puree.

Chicken and Pear Puree
1 pound chicken breast
2 pounds ripe pear, peeled, cored and chopped
Cook chicken: Place chicken breasts in a pot in a single layer. Cover with water, and add a bay leaf or parsley, if desired. Bring to a boil, then reduce heat to low. Cover and simmer for 10 to 15 minutes, or until the thickest part of the meat registers 165 degrees on an instant thermometer. Remove to plate to cool, then blend with water, broth or breast milk until it has a paste-like consistency.
Cook pears: Add chopped pears to a large pot and fill with just enough water to cover. Bring water to boil, then lower heat to medium, cover and simmer for about 5-6 minutes, or until fruit is easily pierced with a fork. Drain, reserving some of the liquid.
Puree cooked pears until smooth in a food processor, food mill, blender or with an immersion blender, adding cooking liquid as needed for desired consistency.
Place pureed pears and chicken in a large bowl and mix to combine well.
— Recipes: Gretchen McKay
Abby Mackey is a registered nurse and can be reached at amackey@post-gazette.com and IG @abbymackeywrites






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.