When Jack Mahoney began his elementary school career, he gained a shadow: His little sister, Maggie, who spent nearly every day pretending to get ready for school and complete homework assignments.

Also like her big brother, Maggie’s kindergarten journey began with an informal visit to her Mt. Lebanon school building where she met her teachers and saw her future classroom. It not only made the people and place familiar before that fall, but also provided familiarity prior to another pre-school event, her “kindergarten screening,” a one-on-one assessment to gauge each incoming student’s abilities.

“We just told her, ‘We’re going to see your new school and your teacher. It’s kind of like an open house,’” her mother, Bridget Mahoney, said. “She was very excited. She loved the idea of school, so it was very easy to get her to go,” as is the case for many children.

For others, kindergarten — and kindergarten assessments — can be a nerve-wracking time for kids, requiring careful presentation and preparation to build a nourishing mental foundation for the concept of “testing.”

Advertise with us

But regardless of attitude, it’s a transition — a new phase of life — that relies, in large part, on experiences with caregivers, previous chances to socialize and exposure to learning opportunities, all of which is aided by proper tools from school districts from the beginning of their academic careers.

“If they've had the opportunity to build skills, like knowing how to talk to adults and knowing how to interact with their peers in a positive way, and they develop that intrinsic self-confidence because they've had opportunities in early learning to practice it, then those children are more ready to be in that kindergarten school setting,” said Valerie Williams, Trying Together’s kindergarten transition program director.

To help children and families through the transition to kindergarten, Trying Together — a Squirrel Hill-based organization that supports high-quality care and education for young children — made several policy recommendations in a 2024 paper, including that local kindergarten transition teams should be required in all school districts.

The teams, officials said, should be made up of pre-K and kindergarten teachers, school administrators, child care providers and families to help support planning and to enhance the early learning continuum.

As for school districts, the organization suggested that officials involve parents and guardians in the transition process and support local pre-K and child care providers, though equitable access to those skill-building programs varies drastically across the state.

Advertise with us

During the 2021-22 school year, 78% of 3-year-olds and 65% of 4-year-olds in Pennsylvania did not have access to a pre-K program, the organization found.

Knowing the range of experiences had by children entering kindergarten, districts across the region are also working to make the assessment process as comfortable as possible, including at 5,500 student-strong Mt. Lebanon, where Jason Ramsey, principal at Foster Elementary, manages the district’s kindergarten registration process.

That’s why Jack, Maggie and other district kindergarteners enter the building and meet their teachers before the screening, an assessment officials have worked to ensure is “on the shorter side,” allowing the district to get a “quick snapshot” of students’ skills, said Ramsey.

The process, which at most is 30 minutes, measures basic skills such as if a student knows their parent’s phone numbers, their address, first names, numbers, letters, shapes and more. They are assessed on their ability to put things together and book handling, and it also looks at gross motor skills such as standing on one foot, walking backwards and going up and down the stairs.

Once the screening is over, parents are given a toolkit with activities and resources they can work on with their child over the summer.

Advertise with us

“Every student for the last 10 years has been screened and I would say in terms of anxiety it’s very, very minimal,” said Ramsey.

Similar assessments take place at the Upper St. Clair School District, giving teachers and staff a chance to “learn a little more about students and what their experience in schooling has been,” said Lauren Madia, the district’s director of pupil services.

Through the assessment process — which takes place over the first two days of school — the district of almost 4,000 students learns if the child has been to preschool and, if so, how they did during that process, as well as personal care skills, such as tying a shoe and other basics.

But like Mt. Lebanon, none of that happens until after an initial meeting, their “Spring Into K” event.

“When they come back in a few months, they're very excited to get back into that space,” said Madia. “Usually by that time they can see this is where my desk is going to be, this is where my cubby is going to be. So things are sort of fresh for the start of the school year. It's really intended to be as supportive of a transition as we can possibly make it.”

Advertise with us

In the neighboring Bethel Park School District, assessments are treated as a community event. During the event, the district of almost 4,000 students sets up stations where kids can pick up summer bags and meet their principals. Middle and high schoolers working as volunteers then take the children to a communal space to meet with kindergarten teachers and other incoming students where they wait to take their assessments.

“We have created a really welcoming atmosphere for our screening day to welcome families and students to Bethel Park,” said Elizabeth Wells, the district’s coordinator of curriculum and instruction.

For the majority, those walk-throughs and celebrations are enough to settle minor bouts of anxiety, the kind that protects us when encountering something new.

For other children, additional tension tamers are necessary.

“I would say this is more about preparing your children for life rather than preparing them for this assessment,” said Abigail Schlesinger, University of Pittsburgh Medical Center child and adolescent psychiatrist and associate professor of psychiatry at the University of Pittsburgh School of Medicine. “What they know about it comes from what we, as parents, discuss with them about it.”

Advertise with us

Notice that she said “assessment.”

“I hesitate to use the word ‘testing’ for this,” she said. “As I tell parents, check your own pulse. If the word ‘testing’ makes you anxious, you might want to start with a different word because, really, this first assessment is a chance for the school to get to know you, your strengths and the areas where you might need more help. In fact, every test is designed to that. It’s how we present it.”

If the anxiety’s source is more about separation than the test … err, assessment … consider focusing on the transition from being with parents to being with teachers, Schlesinger suggests, such as offering a favorite stuffed animal a squeeze before allowing mom or dad to babysit them during the screening or eating a favorite snack together before entering the building.

And if it all becomes too much despite the preparation, Schlesinger advises parents to focus only on calming their child, a necessary state before using coping skills or communicating their needs.

Hugs, a walk outside, getting down on their level and breathing together are all good practices, while repressing the urge to ask many questions or over-explain.

Advertise with us

“We’re in a weird over-testing period, PSSAs and all of these other things,” said Schlesinger. “Yes, I think we need to dial it down about kindergarten assessment and realize it’s just one point in time, and think more about our longitudinal strengths and our weaknesses. And recognize that some kids are not going to be great test takers, and that is OK.”

And few kids test perfectly, just like Maggie.

She wrote her name and knew all of her letters, but not necessarily their order.

Mahoney didn’t take that as a cue to repeat the alphabet song all summer long, however. Her family just viewed it as a “benchmark” and the screening as a preview of the new facet of their daughter’s life.

“To have that one-on-one before school starts I think is incredibly beneficial, because the teacher isn’t really seen as stranger, and you’re already creating a bond of trust between the teacher and the child,” Mahoney said. “It is relieving that you can meet them, too, and tell your kid, ‘This person is safe and will be your teacher for the next year.’”