The holiday season can be a great opportunity for family and friends to spend time together, but in recent years these gatherings can be hampered with arguments about screen time.
A 2022 study conducted by Pew Research Center, which surveyed 1,316 teenagers, found that more than half said they used YouTube and TikTok daily, with a fifth of all teens saying they used YouTube “almost constantly.” More than half of those surveyed said social media would be difficult to give up.
And kids are using screens at ever-younger ages: Kathy Servian, a behavioral health therapist with West Virginia University Carruth Center and the School of law, said it’s known that children under 2 are on screens, although that’s not recommended by pediatricians.
Part of what makes navigating conversations about excessive screen time difficult are fundamental variations in how different generations use technology, and what they use it for, said Ana Radovic, an assistant professor of pediatrics at the University of Pittsburgh and a pediatrician specializing in adolescent medicine.
“Each year that goes by, [these phone habits] become more acceptable,” said Jon Elhai, a professor at the University of Toledo who studies internet addiction and cyberpsychology. “A lot of my college students that take classes with me aren’t paying attention to me. They’re on their phones.”
This integration of smartphones into social structures and daily life means approaching kids with an open mind and a vow to be curious about their phone usage is especially important. Here are some expert-backed suggestions for enjoying Thanksgiving dinner and beyond with device-dependent younger family members.
Discuss before the hubbub
Both Radovic and Servian stressed the importance of having a conversation about screen time and establishing expectations before the festivities begin. Calling out your kid at the dinner table on Thanksgiving might not go over well.
“If you approach them in a negative way, they’re just going to shut off,” said Radovic.
Servian suggested setting up a plan and approaching them a day or so before. “It’s super important to let them know ahead of time, so it’s not a surprise,” she said.
Make the discussion collaborative
Kids aren’t the only ones influenced by the addictive quality of social media.
“You’re wanting people to respond to you, and when they do, you feel pleasant, you feel satisfied,” said Elhai. “Some of this is natural, but social media companies have enhanced these addictive tendencies. It’s not a coincidence that when you go to YouTube, you see ‘shorts’ and they keep playing on an endless loop.”
That’s why Radovic suggested starting a conversation by bringing up your own experiences with screen time, if you struggle to moderate your use. You could ask your teen to help you set a timer app or acknowledge that sometimes it’s hard to log off Instagram at night.
“Young people are developing their own autonomy, and taking a hard-line approach goes against that,” said Radovic. “It’s better if they feel involved in the process.”
Explain your reasoning, set goals
Starting with an end goal can help inform children about why you’re having a conversation about screen time.
For instance, if your child only sees the family coming in for the holidays once a year and the goal is to promote closeness, say something like:
My goal for Thanksgiving Day is that you have some time to ask your uncle about his health, and how he’s doing since the surgery. I think he’d leave a little bit happier if you two had a 15-minute conversation. What do you think?
The goal can also be more general, such as wanting to have a screen-free dinner once everyone is seated at the table. This, along with clearly explaining when it’s appropriate to use devices, can get kids on board — instead of them feeling chastised or confused about a new rule.
Lead by example
“The rules for your kids should apply to you too,” said Servian. “You can demonstrate to kids that they can have valuable face-to-face interactions without their devices.”
Every family is different, Radovic noted, so it’s important that screen-time rules are individualized and reflect a family’s values.
Suggest alternatives
Asking what they might like to do can further promote the feeling that they have some control and agency. Parents could frame the question as creating an activity similar to a game they play on their phone, such as Scrabble for fans of the online Words with Friends.
“Just because they’re on their screen doesn’t mean they wouldn’t want to do something else,” said Radovic.
Especially for younger kids who might turn toward a tablet or a smartphone game for playtime, parents can redirect kids to an activity that does not involve devices, such as helping grandma make cookies, grabbing the masher to make potatoes or playing a game outside.
“Those experiences, where they can have positive interactions without it, are going to be helpful in letting them know they don’t need [their device], even if they think they do,” said Servian.
Normalize discomfort, to a point
A tricky factor for moderating phone use at family gatherings is that kids don’t always know how to talk to adults, and vice versa — a child might not know how to relate to, say, that uncle they only see once a year. Parents might offer help, such as:
We haven’t seen family in a while. It’s OK to not know what to say to grown-ups. I know your uncle loves the Steelers. Maybe ask him if he’s gone to a game recently.
“Being able to sit with being uncomfortable is important,” said Servian.
This, of course, depends entirely on the child feeling safe around family members. LGBTQ+ kids especially may use their devices to feel connected with others if they do not feel accepted by their family.
Servian stressed that she would never want a kid to be in a situation where they feel threatened or scared. It’s good to recognize why a young person might be using their phones, and ask with curiosity about that. Radovic said having supportive adults around or a person kids feel they can turn to is a big factor in promoting trust and safety.
When to seek help
If an hour or two without technology causes behavioral issues such as verbal or physical aggression, it’s time to talk to a professional, Servian said.
Experts helping to curb use in adults often employ general principles of cognitive behavioral therapy, said Elhai, especially as he’s found that those who spend excessive time on the internet often struggle with their mental health.
“If we treat the anxiety and depression, people are not going to feel as much of a need to gravitate toward the internet to cope,” he said.
Hanna Webster: hwebster@post-gazette.com






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.