When it comes to stuffy, hacking kids, who are accumulating stacks of school make-up work by the day, there’s only so much parents are willing to tolerate.
For colds that have gone on too long — or seem like they have — moms and dads march their kids off to the pediatrician or urgent care office, convinced there must be some prescription medication to stop the Kleenex avalanche.
“You can sense frustration,” said Bryce Harvey, a pediatrician with West Virginia University Medicine Children’s Hospital. “They think, ‘I’m here because I’m expecting an antibiotic, because I suspect bacterial sinusitis, because it was on Google.’”
Those Google searches are well meaning, but often misleading.
Sinusitis, or a sinus infection, results from a viral illness (like a cold or flu) or seasonal allergies — all of which are present and unpleasantly accounted for this time of year.
When fluid builds up in the sinuses of the face, often in the maxillary sinuses beneath the cheekbones, a swampy breeding ground is made for bacteria sniffed up from the nasal passages. The result can be a bacterial infection, which could be treated with antibiotics.

What Google may not have made clear, however, is doctors can often only make a diagnosis of sinusitis after kids (or adults, whose criteria are similar) have been suffering from telltale symptoms for 10 — 10 — days. In general, those symptoms include runny nose, sore throat, headache, cough, fever, facial pressure, etc., but the diagnosis is trickier in younger kids whose presentation is often less robust.
Add in the fact that medical providers have no definitive test for sinusitis — only patient report — and there’s plenty of frustration to go around.
Nader Shaikh, UPMC Children’s Hospital of Pittsburgh pediatrician, decided that approach should change, by proposing a possible diagnostic test for sinusitis in a study published in the Journal of the American Medical Association, or JAMA, in July.

“It’s not only gray for the parents. It’s gray for the doctors,” he said. “For an ear infection, we can look inside the ear. For pneumonia, we can listen to the lungs. But for sinusitis, we have nothing to go on from a physical exam. That was very unsatisfying for me.”
He and his fellow researchers followed about 500 children from six centers across the U.S. who met criteria for sinusitis perfectly: appropriate presentation of symptoms that had gone on for at least 10 days and not even a whisper of improvement.
Since that criteria would typically result in a prescription for antibiotics, the researchers followed suit, treating all 500-some children. But they also swabbed the insides of the participants’ noses, much like a COVID-19 test, and let that bacteria grow in a lab, looking for the three most common bacterial causes of sinusitis.
Aside from “unsatisfying” diagnostic criteria, Shaikh was further motivated to study sinusitis in children because there’s some evidence that only 50% of the 5 million U.S. kids prescribed antibiotics for sinusitis each year will see symptom improvement that can be attributed to that treatment.
The results of Shaikh’s study told a similar story.
Children who did not test positive for one of those three most common bacterial causes of sinusitis made up 28% of those enrolled, and saw significantly less improvement than the “colonized” group. That conclusion lends support for this kind of testing to identify which patients are most likely to benefit from antibiotics, which is also a way to prevent potentially unnecessary antibiotic use, a contributor to antibiotic-resistant bacteria.
Harvey points out, however, that identifying the “right” bacterial type may only be one explanation for when antibiotics seem to not kick sinus infections.

“You always have to remember the viral and allergic risk factors to getting that bacterial infection,” he said. “Some of what families are seeing may still be some of that initial virus,” knowing that some viral symptoms can last up to 14 days, “or maybe it’s a new one that occurred after, or with, the first.”
Shaikh’s results also have to overcome questions about whether to treat sinusitis at all.
The U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention’s sinusitis webpage includes a prominent blue box that reads, “Antibiotics are not needed for many sinus infections, but your doctor can decide if you need an antibiotic.”
Most human bodies are capable of clearing sinus infections with no help. The risks of serious sinusitis-related complications — infections that spread to the eye, bone or cavities of the skull — are low, at about 1 in 1,000 cases. And treatment with antibiotics has been shown to shorten the course of symptoms by only about two days, with an average of three to four days before they’re able to help patients feel better.
But that isn’t necessarily an excuse to skip care when sinusitis is suspected. The CDC recommends treatment — with or without three days of “watchful waiting” — in pediatric cases of sinusitis. And an assessment allows providers to rule out other possible culprits of discomfort, such as ear infections or pneumonia.
“Treatment or not are probably both reasonable, but most parents, when their child has been sick for a while, they don’t want to prolong it by even two more days,” Shaikh said.
And for Harvey, the one in 1,000 is still too many: “Could those things happen? Yeah. Are they likely to happen? No. But those are things you want to jump on and treat.”
It’s important to note what is not included as a sign of sinusitis: the color of nasal discharge.
It’s a gut instinct on the part of many to assume that yellow or green snot is indicative of serious infection, and it’s understandable. If green or yellow discharge comes from a wound, that is an urgent — if not emergent — situation.
But with snot, it’s not.
“It’s OK. It means nothing. Just don’t look,” Shaikh said with a laugh.
He did look at snot color, however, on the way to describing the value of bacterial testing. He and his colleagues weren’t the first to discuss the color wheel of congestion, but they were the first to test it as they did.
The intranasal hues result when different kinds of illness-fighting cells accumulate, and the thickness can ebb and flow based on hydration and the stage of the illness. But in the study, there was no difference in the efficacy of antibiotics depending on the reported color of nasal discharge among the study’s participants.
Knowing what sinusitis is and what it is snot can certainly help manage expectations of parents, which helps their medical care providers in turn. And Shaikh’s longterm goal of an in-office test for sinusitis — similar to how strep throat is diagnosed — could be the golden ticket to smoother provider-patient interactions this time of year, since few can argue about the objectivity of lab testing, providers included.
“Anytime you’re able to demystify anything, it’s a great thing,” Harvey said. “When we know what we’re treating and that our treatments are effective, that’s always ideal.”
Abby Mackey, a registered nurse, can be reached at amackey@post-gazette.com and IG @abbymackeywrites





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.