One-fifth of women across the nation have reported mistreatment during maternity care, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention reported Tuesday.
The results come from a national survey conducted in April of 2,402 women who had recently given birth. Mistreatment was reported across races and insurance status, although women of color were more likely to experience discrimination, as well as those without insurance or with public insurance.
The most common forms of mistreatment reported were violation of privacy, verbal abuse, ignoring requests, the threat of withholding treatment and unwanted treatment. Women of color who reported discrimination mentioned comments about their age, weight and income.
“Every mom deserves respectful, fair and equal care during their pregnancy,” said Wanda Barfield, director of CDC’s Division of Reproductive Health during a Tuesday media briefing on the report.
Mistreatment in prenatal and natal care can lead to consequences for mother and baby, including unaddressed health risks such as high blood pressure or preeclampsia, and even death. Maternal mortality statistics are high in the U.S. compared to other countries, especially for Black women. Per a 2021 CDC report, the rate of maternal death in Black women was double the overall rate.
The death of Olympian Tori Bowie, who died from birth complications in May, thrust the issue back into the public eye. Tennis star Serena Williams, back in 2018, penned an opinion piece for CNN about her near-death in the wake of delivering her daughter, writing that, “what followed just 24 hours after giving birth were six days of uncertainty.”
Read More
“Too many women die during and after pregnancy in this country,” said CDC chief medical officer Debra Houry during the briefing. “And more than 80% of these deaths are preventable. … The health of moms reflects the health of our nation.”
About half of those surveyed said they held back expressing concerns to their providers out of fear of “being difficult,” feeling embarrassed, not wanting to “make a big deal” or not feeling confident. This can discourage moms from seeking further care, which could lead to complications down the road.
Drs. Houry and Barfield suggested solutions to mistreatment and high rates of maternal death: diversifying the health care workforce, requiring bias training for staff, and employing doulas and midwives to advocate for the birther’s needs.
For Emily McGahey, a midwife and clinical director of The Midwife Center in the Strip District, these results aren’t new. Indeed, a 2002 survey from the group Listen to Mothers found that birthers reported higher satisfaction with doulas and midwife care than with nursing staff. A 2008 survey from the same group reported that Black women were more likely to report a traumatic birth than those of other races.
“For me, as a midwife, this is not surprising,” said Ms. McGahey. “Women really have always had this exact same issue around mistreatment and pregnancy.”
The Midwife Center completed 400 deliveries last year.
The solution, to Ms. McGahey, lies in collaboration. She said The Midwife Center is lucky that the larger hospital systems within Pittsburgh have been welcoming of their midwives and says they are fully integrated into the hospitals and care teams of mothers. “We’re a good model, but we know we can do better,” she said.
In an email, Allegheny Health Network’s chief clinical DEI officer, Dr. Margaret Larkins-Pettigrew, touched on how the hospital system is using studies on maternal mistreatment and mortality to foster solutions.
“Highmark Health and Allegheny Health Network acknowledge the need for Black voices to be heard especially during their pregnancy journey,” said Dr. Margaret Larkins-Pettigrew, who is an OB-GYN. “Embracing the data supports the need for cultural humility, training on obstetric racism, utilizing methods to reduce preterm deliveries and ensuring postpartum support for Black mothers and babies.”
Ms. McGahey also recognized the contribution of internal biases and racism in these interactions, whether the providers and staff know it or not.
“It could be that just the ways we’ve always done things might be how we’re causing harm for folks at risk of poorer outcomes,” she said. “We need to think about how we listen to women.”
Hanna Webster: hwebster@post-gazette.com






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.