Teachers are remembered for life-changing impressions and quirky habits. High school students taught by former Chartiers-Houston School District history teacher Lorien Moyer might populate the latter category with memories of her in-classroom mini-fridge, and the cans of Diet Dr Pepper and Diet Cherry Coke she’d crack open every afternoon around 1.
“It was my afternoon little pick-me-up,” she said. “I didn’t want coffee in the afternoon, but I wanted that little bit of caffeine.”
But that energy boost came with about 185 milligrams of aspartame, an artificial sweetener recently caught in the World Health Organization’s crosshairs.
Two arms of the WHO — the International Agency for Research on Cancer and Joint Expert Committee on Food Additives offered a set of nearly conflicting decisions. The IARC called aspartame “possibly carcinogenic,” while the JECFA said the additive is safe up to 40 milligrams per kilogram of bodyweight, which amounts to nine to 14 cans of aspartame-sweetened soda per day for a 154-pound person.
There’s plenty of nuance to those conclusions. But when an average person hears “cancer” and any food product in the same sentence, self-evaluation follows, and dietitians are ready to assist.
“I don’t think the WHO's decision is earth-shattering, but I do think it’s a wake-up call to take a look at this,” said Judith Siebart, registered dietitian and professor at West Virginia University’s School of Medicine. “I’m going to buy into it, but I’m also going to need a long-term plan.”
Evolving evidence
Siebart didn’t flinch at the WHO's decision. To her, these ruminations come with the territory.

“As a dietician, as an adult, as a free-thinking human, things change,” she said. “When you look at other sciences — astronomy or whatever — they’ve been around for thousands of years. Nutrition is a relatively new science, and aspartame has only been on the market since 1981. It takes a while to cut through all the static, and find out what’s going on with it.”
Siebart says she would follow — and preach — the WHO’s guidance even if they’d reached a more extreme conclusion simply because she can’t perform that kind of research single-handedly. But given the middle-of-the-road decision, moderation is key, she says.
“I do think there are individuals who just drink way too many diet beverages, and it would behoove them to start cutting back, regardless of what the IARC says,” she said.
And she acknowledges the WHO’s decision will cause some to abandon aspartame entirely, regardless of the evidence.
In either case, she’ll draw on the skills she’s honed in one of her secondary gigs, as a smoking cessation counselor.
“I see very similar behaviors with some diet beverage drinkers and smokers,” she said. “In certain people, it lights up the reward pathway of the brain.”
Steps toward satisfaction
When Moyer became pregnant with her first child about 10 years ago, she chose to stop drinking diet soda.
The migraines she battled since her late teenage years nearly disappeared. She wasn’t sure why, and readopted her pick-me-up habit after her child was born.
With her second pregnancy, she again dropped artificially sweetened sodas from her diet, and when she began cracking cans of diet-whatever about a month after her son was born, she could no longer ignore the pattern.
“My migraines came back furiously: three, four, five a week,” she said. “I think I suspected aspartame was the problem for a while, but was in denial.”
When she returned to the classroom about five months after her baby was born, her “debilitating” headaches had to go. She began weaning herself off of diet soda — assuming that was the culprit — and waited for an appointment with her neurologist, who advised her to continue kicking the habit.
While Moyer, now 41, of Mt. Lebanon, didn’t choose to abandon aspartame because of cancer-risk rumors, she knows how “challenging” it can be to replace the ritual around those beverages, which is why she took a gradual approach: Her 1 p.m. can turned into a half-can, which then became every other day.
“I think I wasted a good bit during that transition because I wanted to drink the whole thing, but I knew that if I started drinking it, I wouldn’t have stopped,” she said. “So I’d dump it out.”
Though she’d never been a seltzer water drinker before, cans of fruit-flavored varieties — what her kids call “spicy waters” — became her go-to.
“I kind of trained myself to drink them,” she said. “Now, that’s what I crave. Kind of like tricking my brain, right? Same shape, same kind of can, same weight.”

Recreating rewards
Moyer didn’t consult with a dietitian to transition away from diet beverages, but she followed through exactly how one would have prescribed.
“The habit isn’t out of thirst many times,” Siebart said. “It’s the flavor, the hit of caffeine, the ritual of cracking open a cold can, the carbonation — all of that works together to make us want to drink another.”
Said another way, drinking a can (or bottle, or glass) of diet soda is a multi-sensory experience.
Siebart’s best advice is to “slow things down,” give yourself a chance to recognize exactly which aspects appeal to you, and replace those as adequately as you can, without resorting to sugar-sweetened beverages whose undesirable outcomes — obesity, diabetes, etc. — are well-documented.
And if following the WHO's guidance, choosing non-aspartame zero-calorie sweeteners isn’t an option either.
On May 15, the WHO released a new guideline recommending against the use of all non-sugar sweeteners — not just aspartame — to control weight or avoid disease.
“Replacing free sugars with non-sugar sweeteners does not help with weight control in the long term. People need to consider other ways to reduce free sugars intake, such as consuming food with naturally occurring sugars, like fruit, or unsweetened food and beverages,” said Francesco Branca, WHO director for nutrition and food safety, according to the release. “Non-sugar sweeteners are not essential dietary factors and have no nutritional value. People should reduce the sweetness of the diet altogether, starting early in life, to improve their health.”
Of note, this guidance does not apply to diabetics, whose reliance on artificial sweeteners is life-sustaining.
“Let’s face it: Humans need to be hydrated. So, why don’t we start to investigate ways to keep us adequately hydrated? Here’s a novel concept: water,” she said with a laugh. “But that doesn’t light up the reward pathway of our brains. So, let’s make it interesting.”
Moving past diet soda
It’s not just what you drink, but how you drink it.
If you think the cost of soda has increased, it has. At around $9 for a 12-pack, Coca-Cola’s prices increased about 11%, and Pepsi’s increased about 14%, by the end of 2022, Reuters reported earlier this year.
“If you’re not investing a lot of money in diet soda, use that money toward experimenting with other beverages and ways of drinking it,” Seibart said.
Think about what makes sipping enticing for you: water bottles with lids that pop or screw off, or use straws.
Or like Moyer, maybe replace a can with a can.
New habits
“Ritual” can be subtle. Associating reward or pleasure with the experience of drinking a diet beverage could simply be the act of cracking open a can or twisting off a bottle cap, or maybe it’s the carbonated fizz that follows.
If that’s the case, Siebart recommends mimicking the experience with canned or bottled carbonated water instead.
For some, flavor is the allure of a diet beverage.
Add mint, basil, muddled or whole berries, or lemon, orange and lime slices to water, Siebert suggests. Or try freezing fruit into ice cubes. All of those options offer visual, gustatory and tactile experiences that help achieve satisfaction.
For those in need of more robust flavors, splashes of fruit juice — yes, that means adding some natural sugar — can be added to water or frozen into ice cubes.
Being intentional with food creates connection with it, and can also help to create a new habit, Siebart says.
For those it appeals to, she recommends brewing tea as a nightly ritual. Consider adding lemon, orange or another fruit or herb for some additional interest.
Set it in the refrigerator and, each morning, a custom sweetener-free beverage is waiting for you.
And don’t underestimate temperature’s impact on the sensory experience, regardless of how (artificially) sweetened beverages are replaced.
Sensitivity to temperature plays a part but, sometimes, it’s just preference. Prepare your beverages accordingly, Siebart says.
Curbing cravings
Despite dazzling jewel tones from muddled berries, popping ice cubes with mint leaves suspended inside, and slices of lemon dangling off the end of your glass, a diet soda craving may strike nonetheless.
That’s when Siebart recommends a “delay and distract” strategy.
“When the brain fires up a craving for a diet beverage, and you delay that gratification, it won’t constantly fire that signal,” she said. “It dissipates over time. If you get enough traction, you get new synapses in your brain. A new habit develops, and you can be completely free of diet beverages,” like Moyer is, seven years after cutting ties.
“I’m glad I’m not hurting myself, if there is some chance that aspartame was causing me any issues, combined with my family history,” she said. “Should I develop cancer, am I going to think it’s because I drank all of those diet pops? No.
“But whether it’s sweets, or pop or smoking, I feel for people. It’s really hard to give up something you enjoy.”
Abby Mackey: abbyrose.mackey@gmail.com and IG @abbymackeywrites






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.