Media outlets buzzed at the end of June about the World Health Organization’s upcoming decision on whether or not aspartame — an artificial sweetener found in diet sodas, sugar-free gum, gelatins and more — is capable of causing cancer.
On July 13, the news broke — one day ahead of schedule — that two arms of the WHO had levied their opinions.
Typical of WHO decisions on carcinogenicity, they require plenty of explanation.
For those awaiting this ruling, the focus was on how the IARC (International Agency for Research on Cancer), the WHO’s cancer-focused division, would categorize the substance within its four-tier system.
The organization placed aspartame in Group 2B — also described as “possibly carcinogenic” — alongside some head-turning inclusions such as pickled vegetables, Ginkgo biloba extract and aloe vera whole leaf extract.
This is the same type of decision that put bacon, ham and other processed meats on the hot plate in 2015 when they were classified in Group 1, right with cigarette smoke, asbestos and diesel engine exhaust.
If those groupings — which are flanked by Group 2A’s “probably carcinogenic” and Group 3’s “not classifiable” — seem counterintuitive, it’s because the meaning of the categories isn’t what most people expect.
“There are challenges with the ways that things get classified with IARC and WHO because it’s a hazard-based approach versus a risk-based approach,” said Josh Lambert, professor of food science at Penn State.
As explained in the IARC release issued on July 13: “IARC classifications reflect the strength of the scientific evidence as to whether an agent can cause cancer in humans, but they do not reflect the risk of developing cancer at a given exposure level.”
Rephrased for non-scientists: The categories tell people how likely it is that something contains cancer-causing agents, not how much of it might cause cancer or how likely it is to cause cancer in people like you.
Or, it’s like putting exposure to a match and a forest fire in the same category because they both pollute the air.
“The problem with people misunderstanding the categories is that they will potentially make large changes in their diets or their behaviors expecting there to be some concomitant large change in their health or in their risk of developing a particular disease, and that won’t happen,” Lambert said.
Aspartame earned its “possibly carcinogenic” descriptor after IARC found “limited evidence” in six studies that potentially raised questions about its safety, particularly about a type of liver cancer. Adding to the confusion, however, is another arm of the WHO, JECFA (Joint Expert Committee for Food Additives), that looked at the same body of evidence, and came to a different-sounding conclusion in the very same release.
“JECFA also considered the evidence on cancer risk, in animal and human studies, and concluded that the evidence of an association between aspartame consumption and cancer in humans is not convincing,” said Dr. Moez Sanaa, WHO’s head of Standards and Scientific Advice of Food and Nutrition Unit, via the organization’s release. “We need better studies with longer follow-up and repeated dietary questionnaires in existing cohorts …”
JECFA is an international scientific committee administered by both the Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations and the WHO, and their role is different.
Rather than evaluating “hazard,” the group draws more consumer-oriented conclusions, such as levels of exposure and risk across a full spectrum of threats, not just cancer, and subsequent guidelines.
The aspartame guidelines doled out at the end of last week happen to be the same ones JECFA established in 1981 because, per the release, they had “no sufficient reason to change”: 40 milligrams per kilogram of body weight. Or, a 154-pound person would need to drink nine to 14 cans of diet soda per day (assuming a range of 200 to 300 milligrams of aspartame per can) to exceed the recommended amount.
In the 24 hours that followed the WHO’s set of almost-conflicting aspartame comments, manufacturers, lobby groups and governments worldwide scrambled to communicate their reactions.
The U.S. Food and Drug Administration’s response includes, “The FDA disagrees with IARC’s conclusion that these studies support classifying aspartame as a possible carcinogen to humans. FDA scientists reviewed the scientific information included in IARC’s review in 2021 when it was first made available and identified significant shortcomings in the studies on which IARC relied.”
The American Beverage Association — a lobby group representing The Coca-Cola Company, PepsiCo, Inc. and others, all of whom are aspartame beverage manufacturers — released a statement from their interim president and CEO, Kevin Keane, that began: “We are disappointed the IARC report created confusion and unnecessarily alarmed people about the safety of aspartame.”
In an interview with the Post-Gazette, Danielle Wilkoff, principal scientist at ToxStrategies and consultant to American Beverage and other organizations, said, “The FDA really helped to clarify this for the consumer. They really talked about how that classification is just a category. It doesn’t mean there’s a link between aspartame exposure and cancer. There wasn’t sufficient evidence, confidence or strength in the evidence to say there’s a link.”
Government bodies from the United Kingdom, Australia, South Korea, Japan, Brazil and Ireland all followed suit, reassuring its citizens that their long-held beliefs about the safety of aspartame remain.
As the WHO’s decision was pending, however, senior vice president of influential nonprofit activist organization the Environmental Working Group, Homer Swei, said in a late June release, “For years, we’ve known that artificial sweeteners, like aspartame, are harmful to human health … We suspected aspartame might be a carcinogen as well, but this determination unequivocally solidifies that concern.”
At some point, the WHO will release their full report, which is expected to explain more about why IARC and JECFA reached the conclusions they did. For now, however, the flurry of information only complicates the one question many consumers likely have: Can I continue to eat and drink my favorite aspartame-sweetened foods and drinks?
“The data I found on the relationship between aspartame and cancer, it doesn’t seem like there is any,” Lambert, who has no lobby group ties, said. But he also cautioned that continued investigation could change those conclusions, which is simply the nature of good science.
“There just isn’t enough data, especially around things like diet and nutrition to say, ‘If you eat this food additive once a day for 15 years that you’ll get cancer when you’re 75,’ and I think that’s frustrating to people,” he said. “What we think today is based on the experiments done to this point, but someone might do a really whizzbang, groundbreaking experiment in two weeks that tells us we were really wrong.
“There’s risk involved in everything.”
Abby Mackey: abbyrose.mackey@gmail.com and IG @abbymackeywrites






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.