You don’t feel like exercising. You crave carbs and sweets. All you want is to stay in bed and curse the gloomy sky for yet another bleak, bone-chilling day. Yes, it’s winter. But if you find yourself markedly more sad or less motivated than usual, you may have a condition called Seasonal Affective Disorder.
Seasonal Affective Disorder, or SAD, is an aptly-named condition affecting around 10 million Americans and 3% to 5% of people across the globe. People who have it fit the criteria for major depressive disorder during that season when the clocks turn back and darkness prevails. SAD is more prevalent in women, too — some studies say three times as many women than men are afflicted.
Another subset of people would not qualify as having major depressive disorder, but are still greatly affected by the lack of light in winter: these people are considered to have subsyndromal-SAD, affecting 10% to 15% of the population.
And while the experts say there are factors that make some people predisposed to SAD, like genes that control serotonin release, high levels of environmental stress, and even how sensitive your retinas are to light, the basis of SAD is truly circadian: there is something about not getting as much light that plunges some people into a temporary depression.
With the winter solstice on Wednesday bringing the shortest amount of daylight of the year, Pittsburgh now has sunlight from around 7:30 a.m. to 5 p.m. At the time of the summer solstice, Tuesday, June 21, 2022, there were almost six more hours of daylight.
The term Seasonal Affective Disorder was coined in 1984, when psychiatrist and physician Norman Rosenthal and his colleagues began an experiment in Maryland examining a group of patients who came in complaining they were particularly depressed in winter. Twenty-nine patients were randomly assigned to receive two kinds of light therapy at different illumination settings. The results, Rosenthal said, were “astonishing.”
Read More
His team at the National Institutes of Health and other institutions across the country began the study in summertime and said participants were doing well. Then as sunlight receded, their mental health began to decline. “Indeed, they became depressed right on schedule,” Rosenthal said. And when they started the light therapy, he said participants were “transformed. I’ve never seen anything like it.”
Almost 40 years after that first experiment, scientists have learned a lot more about how to treat SAD. And luckily, experts believe that although it is very real and debilitating, SAD is a treatable condition, and manageable if tackled ahead of the winter season. Here is some of what works and a little of what doesn’t:
Light therapy
Light therapy uses powerful light boxes to mimic outdoor light and help our circadian rhythms recalibrate to bright light. Paul Desan, an associate professor of psychiatry at Yale School of Medicine and a physician who studies and treats Seasonal Affective Disorder, said 30 minutes of light therapy before 8 a.m. at 10,000 lux for 7 days a week is a good starting prescription for someone with the condition.
Desan suggests a lightbox that has a surface of one square foot, or you can buy multiple. Set it up on the counter while you’re eating breakfast, reading the paper or otherwise engaging in your morning routine.
Rosenthal’s 1984 study conducted light therapy at 100 and 2,500 lux, but the literature has now largely agreed that 10,000 lux is the standard—for context, a typical 100-watt light bulb emits around 1,600 lumens. Lumens measures the total amount of light, whereas lux considers a specific point. A 10,000 lux lightbox would emit far stronger light than an average light bulb; Desan said 10,000 lux is like being outdoors in the middle of the summer.
Lightboxes are not regulated by the Food and Drug Administration, so it’s important to ensure you’ve bought one that works correctly. Desan’s team at Yale obtained around 25 lightboxes online and measured their output, and only some were legitimate. “I think we have a public health problem where a lot of people feel worse in the winter, and they can’t get good information,” he said.
Proper and consistent use is the most important facet of light therapy—but if you use it correctly, research shows it could make a difference.
Maintain your exercise routine
As the temperature drops and the amount of daily sunlight decreases, it can be harder to get motivated to exercise. Luckily, Desan said you need not ramp up your exercise routine in a drastic way in the winter, only maintain what already works.
“An important thing to understand about SAD is that people were doing fine in the summer ... it’s not that there’s something wrong with their lifestyle that’s making them depressed,” said Desan. “If they really have SAD, exercise isn’t going to fix it alone.”
If in the summer you work out twice a week, aim to maintain that regularity. Routines, and getting out in nature when possible, help provide structure and presence when days feel dark and aimless.
Get enough sleep
Sticking to a routine and maintaining a healthy amount of sleep can help reduce stress. Dan Shade, a sleep medicine specialist and the director of Allegheny Health Network’s Sleep Disorders Center, suggested going to bed at the same time and limiting screen time before bed, as the blue light can also interfere with our circadian rhythms.
“While a one-hour change in time might not seem significant, even slight changes made to our bodies’ natural circadian rhythms increase the risk for serious health problems such as insomnia and depression, as well as poor immunity,” Shade said in a Nov. 3 news release from AHN about adjusting to the time change.
Plan trips to sunny places
Having something to look forward to helps our brains. A handful of research studies have shown that the anticipation of a vacation boosts mood and overall happiness, and that planning for the future can make us more optimistic—perks if that vacation happens to be in a sunny place where we can soak up some lovely, warm sunshine.
And planning ahead more generally can prepare a person who knows they are susceptible to the winter blues. Understanding the nature of your illness, its ebbs and flows, and planning accordingly to flood your house with light, start light therapy early or prioritize whatever exercise routine already works for you can make the SAD onset less dramatic.
Talk to a professional and explore medication if needed
If you truly have Seasonal Affective Disorder, your symptoms will fall under the category of major depressive disorder, and additional medical help may be needed. In some cases, antidepressants can help to lift the dark cloud (metaphorically). Talking to a professional can ensure you are getting the help you need.
What doesn’t work, said Desan and Rosenthal, is to tell yourself, or to tell a struggling friend, that it’s “all in your head.”
“Telling a friend to ‘just snap out of it,’ or saying, ‘I also don’t like the winter blues, but you can move past it,’ is a very unempathetic approach,” said Rosenthal.
“It’s not your imagination. The light/dark cycle really does affect how you feel,” Desan said.
Hanna Webster: hwebster@post-gazette.com






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.