Today’s world of baby products is like a new parent’s equivalent of Willy Wonka’s chocolate factory. A machine that can make a warm bottle of baby formula at the tap of a smartphone? Check. A “robotic night nurse” that promises to add one to two hours to baby’s sleep every night? Check. A “smart sock” with “predictive sleep technology” to tell a new parent when their baby is ready for a nap? Check.
But for parents without an unlimited reservoir of sleep or cash, decisions can be hard. What works? What do they need? What’s worth the money?
“The most common question is, what do I need to have in my house,” said Joseph Aracri, system chair of pediatrics for Allegheny Health Network, of parents trying to navigate the world of baby products.
The first concern when considering a baby product, say pediatricians, is safety, particularly if it involves infant sleep. “No app, no camera, no device will take the place of a safe sleep environment,” said Aracri.
That concern was echoed by Stephen Barbera, a pediatrician at UPMC’s Children’s Community Pediatrics, who remembered the popularity of Fisher Price’s Rock ’n Play inclined sleeper when one of his children was younger. Tragically, that device was recalled in 2019 after it was linked to at least 30 infant deaths.
“My general rule of thumb for parents is, generally speaking, I’d love to say that new products are better but overall it’s not really true,” said Barbera. “My bottom line when a parent is evaluating a product is that if it seems too good to be true, it is.”
Of the sleep products on the market today, he warns against using weighted blankets for babies, noting that their safety record in unknown. He also has concerns about the DockATot Deluxe+, which was the subject of a warning last month from the U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission. The warning said there were reports of infant deaths associated with the product, which it said had been marketed “as a sleep product for babies even though it is not safe for sleep.”
The DockATot no longer markets itself as a sleeping device, but Barbera is concerned that parents may use it as one, or that a baby may fall asleep in one while lounging.
Similarly, Aracri worries that parents may use monitors that track a baby’s breathing to take risks that they may not have taken without a monitor, such as putting babies to sleep on their stomachs. Even if used properly, he said, the monitoring devices could increase parental anxiety, particularly if there are repeated false alarms.
“The American Academy of Pediatrics does not recommend these devices for anything,” he said. “There is nothing that is FDA approved that will save your child’s life or is useful for monitoring.”
The pediatricians also wonder about the impact of devices that track data, such as how much a baby sleeps, how much milk a mother produces or even apps that record how much a baby poops or pees.
“These are humans, not widgets,” said Aracri. “Some of these tracking apps create more anxiety.”
When Ashley Davis, of North Huntingdon, was shopping for baby products for her daughter, Quinn, now 3, she considered getting a high-tech monitoring device. In addition to the cost though, she decided that there were other downsides.
“Ultimately we decided not to get one – I think that it would just make me paranoid,” she said recently while having lunch with her daughter and her mother at Ross Park Mall. “I had a friend that had one and I think it stressed her out too much.”
Even devices that promise to help with infant sleep in a safe way, like the $1,695 Snoo Smart Sleeper Bassinet, which uses an advanced algorithm to soothe babies when they cry, could have drawbacks, said Barbera.
“What is the impact on a device that prevents us as parents from parenting our child throughout the night when they cry?” he said. “There is oftentimes a reason they are upset. Being present to soothe them is extremely important for long-term attachment to your child.”
Product reviewing sites such as Consumer Reports and Wirecutter can help consumers understand the pros and cons of various products, and the organization Safe Kids maintains a list of product recalls on its website, safekids.org
All that said, there are a few products recommended by pediatricians. Forehead thermometers, which allow parents to take their child’s temperature more easily, are good innovations, they say, noting that parents of young babies should still use rectal thermometers.
Baby devices that provide “creature comforts” like wipe warmers, sound machines and yes – even the fancy smartphone-controlled Baby Brezza formula maker if the parents can afford it – can also make life easier. Certain advances in car seats have made them much easier to install, said Barbera, and similarly, strollers with off-road capabilities can greatly improve walks on trails or even bumpy sidewalks.
And when parents have questions, they should check with their pediatricians. “Having a baby, it’s a very scary, exciting, emotional time and you want to do what’s best for your child,” said Aracri. “But you end up getting suckered in to these devices.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.