They fit in a purse, are ready in 15 minutes and are available over the counter. So could COVID-19 rapid tests be the missing ingredient for a COVID-free Thanksgiving?

Probably not, say local experts.

While rapid tests have their advantages, clearing an entire family for Thanksgiving dinner isn’t one of them, said Alan Wells, medical director of UPMC clinical laboratories.

“We at UPMC have various different rapid tests in different settings for different situations,” said Dr. Wells, who is also executive vice chair of pathology at the University of Pittsburgh. “We are not encouraging the rapid tests for saying you’re free to go to a party.”

Advertise with us

Strategies such as vaccination and being willing to stay home from an event if someone has symptoms are much more effective than relying on rapid tests, he said.

“Rapid tests shouldn’t replace common sense,” said Brian Lamb, an internal medicine doctor at AHN Primary Care Morningside. “If you wake up Thanksgiving morning and feel sick, honestly it’s better to just call off than worry about a test.”

The rapid tests aren’t as sensitive as PCR tests, said Dr. Wells, and are more likely to provide a false negative result — meaning that someone who actually has COVID-19 might test negative.

But also problematic, he said, is the possibility of a false positive, especially for people without symptoms. Given the current prevalence of COVID-19 in the Pittsburgh region, Dr. Wells estimates that, depending on where they live, people who have no symptoms and no known exposure have a 0.5% to 3% chance of actually having COVID. That percentage isn’t very different from the chance of getting a false positive on a rapid test, he said, meaning that taking a rapid test while asymptomatic isn’t likely to provide valuable information. Further, a false positive could result in the whole family having to quarantine while they wait to confirm it with a PCR test.

The odds of getting an accurate positive result on a rapid at-home test go up if a person has symptoms or has a known COVID exposure, but in those two situations, the person should just stay home from an event like Thanksgiving dinner anyway, said Dr. Wells.

Advertise with us

Dr. Wells is traveling to New Jersey for Thanksgiving to attend a three-generation gathering where everyone is vaccinated “up to snuff” in accordance with public health guidelines. “We are not taking rapid tests,” he said. “No one has any signs or symptoms and if anyone has signs or symptoms we would stay away even if it’s a cold. The second thing is because people are up-to-date in their vaccine status appropriate for them, even if there is an infection, the outcome will be minimal.”

Dr. Lamb is taking a similar approach to his own family Thanksgiving. “My family is vaccinated and as long as we’re feeling good, we’re not going to take the extra step of doing the test,” he said. “There’s always going to be that slight risk but that’s why we encouraged people to get the vaccine.”

There are also the added factors that at-home rapid tests are currently expensive and hard to find. The tests run about $25 for two tests at area drugstores or about $14 for two tests online at Walmart or Amazon. But they are often sold out. One patients called Dr. Lamb’s office recently, he said, looking for help in finding a rapid test after he had tried three local drug stores with no luck.

Even PCR test appointments have been hard to come by for some of his patients lately, said Dr. Lamb, with people booking up appointments necessary for Thanksgiving travel.

Some public health departments are trying to increase the availability of rapid tests. Erie County is holding a special free rapid testing clinic Wednesday afternoon at the Presque Isle Downs and Casino in advance of Thanksgiving.

Advertise with us

“By providing access to rapid testing prior to the holiday, we are hopeful more people can attend gatherings with friends and family knowing they will not spread COVID-19,” Erie County executive Kathy Dahlkemper said in a news release. “We want everyone to have a safe and happy holiday season, and reducing the spread of this virus will be a part of that this year.”

In Ohio, free at-home tests are available at many public libraries and county health departments.

Rapid tests do have their uses — they can identify a positive result faster than a PCR test, meaning that people could take action to quarantine more quickly. And if COVID-19 antiviral pills are approved, that could translate to faster treatment.

There are also more accurate rapid tests now that use rapid nucleic acid amplification, but they are expensive and generally used by businesses, airports and health care facilities. “Your turkey will be cheaper than these tests,” Dr. Wells said.

If families do want to do rapid antigen tests in advance of their Thanksgiving holidays, the experts recommended doing so as close to the dinner as possible.

Advertise with us

“Basically, it’s a snapshot in time,” Dr. Wells said. “Just because you are negative today doesn’t mean you are negative tomorrow.”

And while the doctors urge staying home from a Thanksgiving dinner if symptoms of COVID-19 arise, that doesn’t necessarily mean you need to cancel if you have allergies or a lingering cough from a non-COVID illness, Dr. Lamb said.

“The best thing to do is to use your common sense,” he said. “If this is how you usually feel after a cold or allergies that’s one thing. If something seems strange, that’s when you want to remember that we are still in the middle of a pandemic.”

Anya Sostek: asostek@post-gazette.com.