A.J. Murga encourages her two young children to say please and thank you, but it wasn’t until last Thanksgiving that she thought to take a closer look at those concepts.
In part, that was because her daughter had turned 3 — an age where the concept of “gratitude” might provoke thought, not just passive absorption — but also because it was an extraordinary year. Ms. Murga was pregnant with the family’s second child. They had just moved into a new home in Squirrel Hill. A pandemic raged.
They cut turkey feather shapes out of construction paper. Every day or so, they talked about something they were grateful for. They wrote down a word or two on a feather and taped it to the wall, eventually making a big turkey that was finished by Thanksgiving Day.
“There was a lot of change. It was an unusual year, and to be grateful and thankful is kind of an anchor,” Ms. Murga said. “It was definitely time to start that conversation around the holidays.”
For many Americans, Thanksgiving is a season to discuss gratitude, but there’s an increasing body of evidence to prove how valuable those thoughts can be all year round. Better sleep, lower stress, improved cardiovascular measures (like lower blood pressure), and even improved outcomes after a heart attack all have links to a consistent focus on gratitude.
The science also indicates that stressful situations increase our capacity for gratitude. Said another way, the tragedy and grief humankind experienced over the past 20 months could make this Thanksgiving season the perfect time to kick off an attitude of gratitude.
Glenn Fox, a neuroscientist, gratitude researcher and University of Southern California professor, looked at this phenomenon in a 2015 study. His team showed 23 20-somethings a documentary about the Holocaust. They then listened to scenarios intended to make them feel as if they were experiencing a moment of grace, such as, “You have been sick for weeks. A prisoner who is a doctor finds medicine and saves your life.” Their brain activity was measured using fMRI.
The study suggested that exposure to a negative experience primed people to be appreciative. Although Mr. Fox cautioned that it would be inappropriate to draw too many comparisons between the experiences of Holocaust survivors and the current pandemic, he said he sees some.
The parallels, he said, “extend to our ability to notice there are things to be grateful for even when we’re up against it, even when we’re facing immense suffering. The amount of gratitude we may feel for ordinary things can certainly be amplified by a stressful situation.”
Here are some ways to harness the power of gratitude.
Write it down
Frederic Terral, 50, of Asheville, N.C., struggled with depression, anxiety, panic attacks and unrelenting self-criticism for years until it all became too much in 2014.
He threw himself into learning how to think differently. Tony Robbins, Eckhart Tolle, Oprah, Brené Brown and studies coming out of some of the world’s foremost positive psychology research centers became his casual reading until it inspired change.
“For me, it was this revelation of, ‘Wait a minute, I can try to focus on the good in my life versus what I don’t have?’” he said. “Most of my life was spent on celebrating my failures and not even recognizing my successes.
“It didn’t take long to grab a little journal,” since writing down thankful thoughts amplifies the benefits.
He bought a well-known gratitude journal with prompts to jot down three thankful thoughts each day, but he struggled. The book was bulky and difficult to take with him. And, for him, it felt more effective to focus on one thought.
After a year of working toward a custom gratitude journaling practice, he decided to create Pockitudes, a “gratitude journal” — though he doesn’t love that term — that focuses on one thankful thought and prompts to consider it further.
“The moment I got this revelation, it was like, ‘Yeah, there’s so much to be grateful for. Just the concept of I am breathing,’” he said. “The challenge was to remember to do that.”
Allow time
Consistency is a key element to reap the benefits of gratitude. Mr. Fox says to think of it like doing a pushup: You have to work the muscles to get stronger. But press pause on the “I don’t have time” excuse: As little as one gratitude session per week can produce benefits.
“Overall, you are trying to shift the window of things for which you’re grateful,” Mr. Fox said.
Maybe a broader concept, like “family,” is what you appreciate at first. But after working the gratitude muscle for a while, more subtle joys will reveal themselves, like how a loved one has an infectious laugh or the smell of your mom’s perfect apple pie.
Schedule it
Reflecting on thankful thoughts doesn’t need to happen often, but how will you remember to keep it consistent?
Calendar invites to yourself and phone alarms will work, but choosing an event does the trick, too.
One of Mr. Fox’s favorite hacks is to associate thoughts of gratitude with mealtime. Various religious practices include blessings at meals or saying grace — and that can work — but Mr. Fox said it need not be a prayer.
“Every time I sit down to eat, I think of everything it took to make the meal,” he said. “I can visualize the farmer who raised and harvested the grain and lettuce. I can think about everything it took for me to have the meal.”
Go outside
Mr. Fox might have an easier time visualizing farmers and ranchers because, in addition to his academic pursuits, he’s the chief scientific officer and head of program design, strategy and outreach for the C4 Foundation, a working ranch in Coronado, Calif., that serves as a refuge for active duty Navy SEALs and their families.
Among that crowd, tough times are used as a reference point for blessings every day, not just during the pandemic.
“There’s no one in the SEAL community who hasn’t been touched by some form of tragedy,” said Jennifer Cooper, director of programs for the C4 Foundation and SEAL wife of 24 years. “It’s that idea of never forget.”
When the rigors of training and deployment take their toll, SEAL families who visit the ranch settle into the ranch lifestyle very quickly, which sounds a lot like pandemic-stressed Americans flocking to state and national parks and buying up canoes and camping equipment.
“I think that’s because we’re animals,” Mr. Fox said. “We crave fresh air. I think it shows people’s natural response toward resilience as well as saying, ‘Look, at least if we’re going to deal with this thing, let’s put it on our terms a little bit. Let’s go outside.’”
Highlight the normal
Consistently stressful times highlight simpler, more “normal” events, which is automatically a more mindful, grateful state of noticing.
“I think the shift for people, if they want to maintain the benefits of gratitude, is really reframing,” Mr. Fox said. Within his family that idea is reinforced with the mantra “normal days are great days.”
The same idea is celebrated at Ms. Murga’s home.
This Thanksgiving, her family will celebrate “normal” by welcoming grandparents to dinner, where they can marvel at their granddaughter’s newest thanksgiving project and, hopefully, have some important conversations about feeling thankful.
Instead of turkey feathers, she traced leaves this year, which she’ll affix to sticks and display as a centerpiece. On them, she writes sentiments that reflect her evolving sense of the world. Rather than last year’s thanks for concrete goods like toys and food, her very first leaf read “love.” That is likely to be preserved in a frame for years to come because it was the first word she wrote, besides her name.
A “gratitude practice” is as simple as that, Mr. Terral said, although he encourages people to try it at least once a week. He intends to explain that at the holiday table this Thursday.
“What I’m going to say at the table is, ‘This is the day we’re all grateful, but make this the beginning of a new habit,” he said. “Remember this feeling right now where there is love. That’s the focus, and imagine the ripple effect that could have.”
For more information on C4 Foundation and Mr. Fox’s work, visit: www.C4foundation.org and Twitter @glennrfox.
For more information on Pockitudes, visit: www.pockitudes.com.
Abby Mackey: amackey@post-gazette.com, Twitter @AnthroAbbyRN and IG @abbymackeywrites.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.