The first time Lisa Jakub started to cry during yoga class, she was embarrassed.
“I was like, ‘Crying in public — this is not something I love doing. What’s wrong with me? I need to get myself together,’” she recalls. Then her “wonderful” instructors helped her understand that crying is a perfectly natural response — and that the yoga studio should be a safe space in which people are comfortable processing feelings, including the really difficult ones.
When Ms. Jakub underwent her own yoga teacher training, it included lessons about how to empower students to work through their emotions. Now, when someone starts to cry during a class, she thinks: “Oh, good, the yoga is working.” Instead of drawing attention to the tear-shedder, Ms. Jakub, who frequently works with combat veterans, makes eye contact and offers a meaningful nod. She then checks in with them after class.
Other yoga instructors said that they, too, often witness students weeping on the mat. “They kind of burst into crying,” says Dr. Loren Fishman, an expert in integrative medicine who is a physician, medical researcher and longtime yogi (he studied the practice for three years in India). “I saw one person who just had tears running down her cheek. They break down and cry for maybe a minute, and then it’s over.” While the experts we talked to agree that crying during yoga is perfectly normal, they offer different theories about what prompts the behavior.
Dr. Fishman, who is the medical director of Manhattan Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation in New York City and author of numerous books about yoga, says that yoga offers “freedom from a number of emotional restraints.” The stretch receptors in the muscles connect directly to relaxation centers in the brain, he says. “Profound, even momentary relaxation can release very strong emotions that are usually inaccessible.”
Dr. Fishman himself has experienced bouts of tears while stretching, and he’s also found himself “laughing unexpectedly” at the physical release. Crying during yoga, he believes, isn’t caused by joy or pain, but by “tremendous relief.”
Adam Gallenberg, a sports psychologist with Premier Sport Psychology in Edina, Minn., points out that people often turn to exercise when they are feeling stressed. “So, if they’re using it as a way to cope with all the stressors in their lives, they’re very likely to have their mind go to these things while they’re exercising, and really experience the emotional reaction tied to those stressors.”
Mr. Gallenberg believes that “physical vulnerability leads to emotional vulnerability” and that the more we suppress certain emotions — such as shame, frustration or inferiority — the more likely they are to surface when we’re in a physically vulnerable state. “In yoga, we put our body in certain poses that we might refrain from doing in our daily lives,” he says, “like opening up our chest or standing up tall,” or stretching in a specific way. (Hip-opening poses are anecdotally known to trigger crying, perhaps because of all the tension stored in our hip muscles.)
Oriana Aragón, a social psychologist who studies emotional expressions at Clemson University, suspects that people who cry during physical activity are deeply immersed in the moment — and, for that fleeting period of time, not obsessing about the future or regurgitating the past. “They’re consuming the moment, and everything else washes away,” she says. It’s “very primal.” Sometimes, people might be overwhelmed by a feeling of awe or achievement, such as when they’ve just completed a marathon. Ms. Aragón remembers crying after finishing a half-marathon and feeling proud of herself. “It could be release, it could be achievement, but it’s definitely about stopping in that moment,” she says.
So, what should you do if tears do start to fall while you’re on your mat? Mr. Gallenberg’s advice is to go with it. “It’s really uncomfortable, and we grow up in a society where we’re told not to feel angry, or to hide our tears,” he says. “But often, those tears are not a bad thing. If anything, it can just be a reminder that, ‘Hey, we’re all human beings, and it’s OK to have our body show what we’ve been internalizing.‘”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.