Nearly a decade ago, as Tracey Vogel settled into her role as an anesthesiologist working exclusively with pregnant patients at West Penn Hospital, she started to notice some unusual cases. Some women who seemed completely calm and put together would tense up as they went into the operating room, heart rates soaring from 90 to 150. Others would panic after receiving spinal anesthesia, distressed that they couldn’t get up or move their legs to escape.
“What am I seeing in front of me?” she wondered. “I started with that, and started to ask more questions.”
It wasn’t until Dr. Vogel received training about five years ago as a sexual assault counselor that she started to put the pieces together. What she was witnessing was women affected by prior trauma that was re-surfacing as they gave birth, whether from a previous sexual assault, birth experience or other form of trauma. To treat patients in these situations, Dr. Vogel has opened a trauma-informed care clinic for obstetric patients through Allegheny Health Network’s Women’s Behavioral Health program, one of the first such clinics in the country — if not the first.
In addition to treating patients with a trauma history, the clinic will also include trauma-informed training for AHN caregivers, screening protocols at initial OB visits and customized birth plans. The clinic is based out of West Penn Hospital but is available across the network via virtual appointments.
Research shows that patients with pre-existing trauma are more likely to suffer from postpartum depression after giving birth and more likely to have trouble bonding with their babies.
“If we as providers fail to recognize and intervene, they are prone to retraumatization at the time of childbirth,” said Dr. Vogel. “If that occurs, what happens and what are the real dangers? They are huge and devastating.”
Read More
Aubrey Johnson, of Peters, is one of those patients who came to Dr. Vogel after an initial trauma. When she had her son, Hendrik, three years ago, she had a severe and debilitating vaginal tear, with enough blood loss to require a transfusion. After the birth, she developed postpartum depression that eventually spiraled into postpartum psychosis, requiring a hospital stay. With treatment from the Alexis Joy D’Achille Center for Perinatal Mental Health at AHN, she recovered. But when she found out that she was pregnant again in July 2020, she was terrified that any of the physical or mental experiences from her first birth would re-occur.
Her therapist at the Alexis Joy Center suggested that she contact Dr. Vogel to help prepare her for the upcoming birth. The two worked together on changes that could be made to help Ms. Johnson have a better experience: should she have a cesarean section instead? Should her medication levels be different? If something unexpected happened, how should they handle it?
Ms. Johnson ended up being induced on April 20 for a vaginal birth, with Dr. Vogel by her side as her anesthesiologist and her advocate. She had an extremely low dose of medicine for her epidural, keeping her feeling more in control, and her blood was tested aggressively to make sure her iron levels were sufficient. “My two deliveries were night and day experiences,” said Ms. Johnson. “The birth, it was wonderful.”
Ms. Johnson, who owns the Pilates studio Moxie in Downtown and Mt. Lebanon, still felt herself slipping into postpartum depression after her second child’s birth, but it was much more mild and didn’t turn into something worse.
“I felt less scared about it because I knew I had the support system in place,” she said.
Dr. Vogel’s care is different for each of her patients because they have their own unique traumas, she said. A sexual assault victim might be re-traumatized giving birth by being naked, frog-legged or having her arms restrained. Other violence survivors might be triggered by certain smells or the sight of blood.
“It’s hard to overstate how vulnerable that position is for any woman, but particularly a woman who has survived sexual trauma,” she said. “If they are not expecting it and not ready, they can have a variety of stress responses, none of which are healthy.”
Dr. Vogel advocates for interventions such as keeping patients warmer during the procedure, keeping them clothed as much as possible, and giving them low doses of anti-anxiety or anti-nausea medication. She also tries to keep the mood as calm and reassuring as possible. “If it’s not an emergency for mom or baby, we can take our time,” she said.
She strives to make the birth experience better to improve what happens for mother and baby after they go home. Dr. Vogel cited a study from the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention released earlier this year that attributed 9 percent of maternal mortality in the year following childbirth to mental health causes. “That puts it on par with all the maternal deaths due to hypertension, and we’re doing so many things to prevent those,” she said, “but we’re not doing the same for mental health issues.”
Ms. Johnson, now nearly seven months postpartum with her daughter, Theresa, can’t imagine what it would have been like to go through her birth without all the support that she received.
“It’s crazy to me that women have been giving birth since the beginning of time and you know, at least within our society now, it just seems to be becoming OK to talk about the darker sides of birth,” she said. “It should just be a mainstream thing for women to talk about it without feeling like there’s something wrong with you or you’re a bad mom.”
For more information, call 412-578-3048 or email tracey.vogel@ahn.org or liana.verzella@ahn.org.
Anya Sostek: asostek@post-gazette.com.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.