Nicole Billitto’s grade school memories are often linked to sound.
She remembers things like laughing children, breathless from a game of freeze tag, and clattering hand instruments in music class. But the sound of sticks of chalk scraping against a blackboard, sheets of paper gliding against one another on their way into an envelope and fingernails tapping impatiently on desks stand out more because of the relaxed, tingly sensation they’d give her.
“Now that I’m saying it out loud, it sounds kinda weird,” said Ms. Billitto, 36, of Mount Washington.
Weird or not, she’s hardly alone. Starting about a decade ago, droves of people seeking that sensation started turning to YouTube videos, Reddit threads and a few Facebook pages dedicated to the newly identified reaction. A look at Google Trends shows a steady increase in popularity through early February 2019, when a Michelob Ultra Super Bowl commercial brought ASMR into the mainstream.
With videos now available on more platforms, like TikTok and Instagram, and a growing body of scientific research, it’s far easier for fans to seek their unique brand of relaxation. Autonomous sensory meridian response (ASMR) is the pleasant sensory experience they’re feeling wherein the body is flooded with a tingling sensation in response to subtle triggers like watching someone play with kinetic sand, hearing whispered voices or being lightly touched.
“It’s an overwhelming sense of relaxation, almost like my body turns to Jell-O, like limp,” Ms. Billitto said.
The limited research
Not everyone experiences this reaction, and quantifying who does is complicated. Maybe a smooth-talking salesperson sends pleasant shivers down your spine. Or you become extra relaxed during a haircut, hearing scissors snip or feeling the comb occasionally (and unpredictably) drag across your skin.
Scientists suspect plenty of people experience sensations like these but don’t think enough of them to search for a label.
The biggest culprit for ASMR confusion is frisson — the technical term for, “that gave me goosebumps,” in response to a piece of music or art.
The two are actually different.
“For ASMR, it seems like there’s a reliable response to the same triggers that people have, which isn’t necessarily the case for frisson,” said Matthew Page, chief neuropsychologist at Allegheny Health Network’s Behavioral Health Institute. Frisson is also usually characterized as a feeling of exhilaration, not relaxation.
Though aware of her quirky reactions to everyday sounds, Ms. Billitto didn’t give them a second thought until two or three years ago when a friend mentioned videos on platforms like YouTube and TikTok.
Now, like millions of others, she watches those videos to intentionally trigger her ASMR and relax.
It started with a whisper
Type “ASMR” into the YouTube search bar, and a virtual buffet of sights and sounds will load.
Gorgeous women dressed as doctors guide the viewer through mock eye exams. Earthy women draped in crystals perform energy healing rituals. The occasional male ASMRtist uses lids, cellophane and video game cases to create an encyclopedia of sounds by tapping, crinkling and scratching.
Scroll down through the search results, and you’ll likely run into a hugely popular channel called “Lily Whispers ASMR.”
With over 310,000 YouTube subscribers and a catalogue of over 800 videos, “Lilliana Dee” — the name she uses for privacy — is one of the self-described “grandmothers” of the online ASMR community.
And she’s a Pittsburgher.
The 27-year-old Pittsburgh CAPA-grad, who asked that her real name not be used in this article, stumbled across her first ASMR video in 2013, about four years after the online autonomous sensory meridian response community gained some traction.
She felt the tingles, though she prefers the term “warm shiver,” and immediately understood the appeal.
Already operating her own YouTube channel dedicated to makeup and hair tutorials, she found launching an ASMR channel in the summer of 2013 was a natural transition. Her videos still consisted of makeup and hair advice but all oriented toward eliciting shivery comfort.
She whispered the how-tos, intentionally rushing or slowing down her speech or enunciating each syllable. She spun the lids of makeup and hair products on and off, poured liquids into new containers and crinkled foil, all while playing the role of hairstylist or a friend.
As the autonomous sensory meridian response culture evolved, she purchased higher-end, ASMR-suited microphones. They pick up “all the little lip sounds” and “crispiness” in her voice.
“That’s what a lot of people like to hear in ASMR because it makes it all the more tingly,” she said. “Podcast microphones,” for example, “don’t catch the P’s and B’s and pops and crackles in their voices. They want it to be seamless. ASMR is the opposite.”
Though she prides herself in being “real” even on camera, Lilliana’s niche is a “big sister role” — often chatting like you’re there with her as she simulates beauty regimes.
The human evolution theory
ASMRtists who assume the roles of hairstylists, doctors and masseuses aren’t just playing make-believe: They’re potentially tapping into a leftover of human evolution, at least according to one theory.
Across non-human primates, “allogrooming” — combing through hair to remove parasites and flaky skin — strengthens social support and tolerance and creates closeness based on touch.
“Like, it’s activating being groomed or being taken care of, which is fascinating and it makes total sense when you think about those types of triggers,” Mr. Page said of the theory.
Evolutionary detritus or not, some find it off-putting.
“I view it as a fetish,” said Miriam Averell, 48, of Brookline. She is particularly turned off by ones with role-play. “When it becomes craved, that’s when it’s weird to me.”
She only watches ASMR videos, usually by accident, when they show up on her TikTok home page. The only type she enjoys involve the rapid and impossibly-perfect stacking of foods into a refrigerator. The visual perfection satisfies her.
But auditory triggers do the opposite.
“I hate that, when they’re whispering and enunciating every syllable and it’s very perfect, I don’t like that at all,” she said “It’s a whole experience, and I just find it incredibly cringy.”
Bubble bath, candles
Lilliana Dee was a student at Penn State when she discovered ASMR and founded her YouTube channel. Around the same time, she struggled with anxiety and depression severe enough to force a one-semester break from classes.
When she sought professional help, self-care and relaxation techniques were a part of the advice she received. Lately, those strategies include bubble baths with essential oils, walks with her dog, candles and, like she’s done for nearly a decade, viewing ASMR videos, though not her own, to help keep her stress level low.
Though she acknowledges the relaxation benefits — even using such videos for in-the-moment relief during panic attacks in the past — she’s a staunch mental health advocate, vocal about the importance of professional care.
“I constantly tell my subscribers, the same way you’d go to see a doctor if your leg was broken, if your heart or mind isn’t where it needs to be, I’m a big proponent of talk therapy and medication,” she said. “I don’t think that ASMR is just slapping a Band-Aid on mental health issues. I don’t think it’s a substitute for any type of mental health treatment.”
Mr. Page backs those sentiments.
Though not someone who experiences “tingles” himself, he becomes more “in-tune” with the sounds of his own environment and more calm and focused after viewing autonomous sensory meridian response videos, which he did more for research than as a personal practice.
“It’s certainly possible that it could have some sort of adjunctive role, especially because, if it is promoting mindfulness, there’s a lot of research on the benefits of that,” Mr. Page said, careful to note that professionals are best suited to address mental health concerns.
Ms. Billitto would add “sleep aid” to that list.
As a Lawrenceville bar owner, her work day ends at around 4 a.m. When she gets home, she pops in her ear buds and turns on an ASMR video, which helps her drift off as quickly as possible.
“I’ve heard people make fun of it,” she said. “‘What’s this weird thing?’ But there are people who fall asleep with noise machines. It’s the same thing, to me.”
Abby Mackey: amackey@post-gazette.com, Twitter @AnthroAbbyRN and IG @abbymackeywrites.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.