HARRISBURG — Citing government overreach and intrusions into citizen privacy, the Republican-controlled General Assembly on Thursday passed a ban on many uses of “vaccine passports” and a halt to the secretary of health’s ability to issue masking, social-distancing and travel-limiting orders to people who are not sick.
The final approval in the Senate by a party-line vote of 29-21 included one independent senator siding with 28 Republicans, and all Democrats voting “no.”
The bill already has been approved in a similar party-line vote by the House. It will head to the desk of Democratic Gov. Tom Wolf, who plans to veto it.
Sen. Kristin Phillips-Hill, R-York, told fellow lawmakers that after a travel-restricting order by then-Health Secretary Dr. Rachel Levine last year, front-line workers in her district going to and from hospitals were pulled over by police. Levine orders also created problems for Pennsylvania residents who routinely cross the state border into Maryland, Phillips-Hill said.
“An unelected bureaucrat cannot wield power” that creates chaos, Phillips-Hill said. “This law needs to be reformed.”
Another prime sponsor, Republican Sen. Judy Ward of Blair County, said the bill was about “placing checks and balances on unrestrained authority” and saying “no more” to government overreach.
Read More
Sen. Jay Costa, D-Forest Hills, the Democratic leader, said that while Levine was not elected, “she was confirmed by this chamber.” Costa said Republicans were doing “end runs” around the secretary of health solely because they did not like her decisions.
“Stripping powers away from a secretary of this commonwealth is a pretty significant step,” Costa said.
Sen. Art Haywood, D-Montgomery, said the vaccine passport-limiting side of the bill basically tells school districts and publicly funded colleges and universities they cannot require COVID-19 immunizations.
“This legislation, in the end, will promote the community spread of COVID-19,” he said.
A spokeswoman for Wolf, Lyndsay Kensinger, said the bill is “dangerous and would undermine any attempt to protect public health in any circumstance.”



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.