The fight over vaccinating Philadelphia’s suburban counties intensified Monday, as southeastern Pennsylvania politicians demanded that the state send more vaccine doses and the state Health Department indicated it had no plans to boost the region’s share.
The state has consistently doled out “far smaller amounts” of vaccine than requested by the four counties, the counties’ leaders said Monday as a backlash to a Sunday Zoom call the Department of Health held with the region’s officials grew.
The confusion worsened as the Department of Health conveyed shifting messages Monday afternoon. A Health Department spokesperson said in a news release that suggestions that the collar counties had not received their fair share of vaccine doses were “false accusations.” But when pressed for details at a news briefing a few minutes later, the spokesperson said the state was not denying there was an undersupply.
And despite a pledge by acting Health Secretary Alison Beam to gradually increase vaccine supply to shorted counties, it was not clear on Monday whether the Department of Health even knew which counties statewide needed such fixes. The state hasn’t completed an analysis that would identify which counties are receiving less than they should under the state’s allocation formula, spokesperson Barry Ciccocioppo said. The Department of Health could not name any counties that needed the help they had pledged to provide.
The political fight over a public health issue affecting hundreds of thousands saw frustrations bubble over after weeks of queries about vaccine supplies — and, said local officials, weeks without answers or concrete solutions.
No one has as many COVID-19 shots as they want — federal supply remains limited. But an Inquirer data analysis revealed last week that the Philadelphia-area counties had received fewer doses per capita than other parts of the state. Even when the early weeks of the rollout — which Beam said skewed the data — are disregarded, an analysis of February alone shows not only that the Southeast ranks last in doses received per capita among all the state’s regions, but also that the disparity in allocations grew last month.
In a rare joint statement Monday, the commissioners of Bucks, Montgomery, Chester, and Delaware Counties called on Beam to act and said that the state had not been transparent about how many total doses have gone to the counties or whether it would correct any shortfalls.
The Department of Health did not dispute The Inquirer’s original data analysis on Monday. But it said case counts, virus deaths, shots going to nursing homes and elsewhere from the federal government, and other factors should be taken into account.
The state did not intentionally undersupply any counties, Ciccocioppo said. He noted the collar counties all are doing better than or meeting the state’s average vaccine administration rate and urged a focus on how many people have been vaccinated rather than where shots are being delivered.
“We will continue to roll out more vaccine as we get it through all of the counties and we are always evaluating the effectiveness of the strategy,” Ciccocioppo told reporters.
As officials and lawmakers clamored for the state to act, the county leaders planned to send a letter to the health department reiterating their demands. U.S. Rep. Mary Gay Scanlon said she also sent a letter Monday and would continue pushing the state to make up for shortages.
“They remain not transparent,” said Scanlon (D., Delaware and Philadelphia). “We still really did not get answers. We heard ‘Yes, we’re going to try to bring the area up to the vaccine levels we’re seeing elsewhere in the state,’ but no details on how that was going to happen.”
Shifting messages
The state’s data presentation on Sunday caused confusion and left those on the call with questions, sowing doubt about the state’s conclusions, many said.
Even as Beam promised the state would help pull up any counties with shortages, the Department of Health and the governor’s office asserted that there was not a systemic problem in the region. Beam presented a chart showing a major undersupply in Bucks and Delaware Counties but called the data “theoretical.”
Lawmakers cited that data after the call, saying the state needed to send more doses to the region: “From their own data, their ‘theoretical’ chart, it showed that portions of the Southeast had been shortchanged,” said Monica Taylor, vice chair of Delaware County Council.
In addition, Bucks and Delaware Counties both disputed the state’s reasoning for why their supplies were lower at points in the rollout. Lawmakers said they were not given enough time to ask questions on the Zoom call.
“This was the chance, we thought, in this call to have everything remedied,” said Bucks County Commissioner Diane Ellis-Marseglia. “And to hang up from the call and not being able to ask all our questions just left everybody demoralized.”
The Health Department also changed its message about the vaccination strategy. Monday’s emphasis on the overall percentage of residents getting vaccinated — which includes people being vaccinated outside their home counties — is a significant departure from its allocation philosophy, which indicates areas hit hardest by the pandemic should be given more shots.
Some lawmakers questioned using the vaccine administration rate as a benchmark, as well as other state data.
“We have no way to assess how the data presented to us today was calculated, and how those calculations have been used to determine the number of doses that have been allocated to our four counties,” the county commissioners said in their joint letter.
Beam said on the call that part of the department’s goal was to help “explain to folks what has happened and where we’re going.”
“This is not an easy rollout by any means,” she said. “And so part of today was not just looking at raw data — which, I hope you guys understand that there’s full transparency there — but also allowing us to explain what has happened over the last 12 weeks instead of just looking at numbers and making cold calculations and saying ‘inequity.’ ”
Demands for action
In Delaware County, which has received the least amount of vaccine per capita of the four counties, representatives were particularly vexed.
The health secretary said Delaware County had not gotten as many doses at the start of the rollout because it didn’t have ultracold storage for the Pfizer vaccine, but Scanlon, Taylor, and State Rep. Mike Zabel all said the county did, in fact, have the refrigeration capacity.
Not only that, said Taylor, but the Crozer Keystone health network received Pfizer doses in December. And Pfizer was not the only vaccine in the game: Statewide, more Moderna first doses have been allocated than Pfizer first doses every week since the second week of the rollout, an Inquirer data analysis found.
And in Bucks County, where state officials said there had been a data reporting issue, Marseglia, the county commissioner, said the problem was with the state’s software. Bucks County has been reporting its data every day, but the state has not been counting it, she said, saying it was “almost insulting” to hear that cited as an explanation on the call.
As the Department of Health told reporters there had never been an intentional undersupply, directed focus to vaccine administration rates, and reiterated talking points, representatives said they and their constituents were just looking for action.
“You know what, I really don’t care so much why, I just want to know: How is it going to be made better?” Scanlon said.
Taylor said Delaware County seniors are frustrated and want to know when more shots are coming.
“The chart shows we are lagging significantly behind where we should be,” Taylor said. “Now, what is the plan to make up for that deficit and keep us at that higher level where we should be?”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.