WASHINGTON — The U.S. Supreme Court questioned on Tuesday the legality of the Affordable Care Act’s government mandate to require people to buy health insurance or pay a tax penalty — even if that tax penalty is currently $0 — though it seemed skeptical that the fate of the entire 10-year-old landmark health law should rest on that single provision.
It was the high court’s latest review of the law that has expanded healthcare coverage to nearly 1.2 million Pennsylvanians through growing Medicaid enrollment and offering insurance plans on state-run healthcare exchanges. The 2010 law also established widely popular protections for people with pre-existing health conditions and allowed young people to stay on their parents’ health insurance plan until age 26.
The case was among the first to be heard by the cemented 6-3 conservative majority, with Justice Amy Coney Barrett joining the bench Oct. 27 to replace the late Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg.
The possibility the law could be struck down by a justice appointed by President Donald Trump and confirmed by Senate Republicans one week before Election Day was a scenario that Democrats, including Sen. Bob Casey, D-Pa., used as campaign messaging in the 2020 elections. The law, passed by Democrats in Congress and signed by former President Barack Obama, has been a target of unsuccessful conservative repeal efforts for years.
But during Tuesday’s oral arguments, two conservative members — Chief Justice John Roberts and Justice Brett Kavanaugh, who was appointed by Mr. Trump in 2018 — suggested they believed it was possible to consider the mandate as separate from the rest of the law.
“It does seem fairly clear that the proper remedy would be to sever the mandate provision and leave the rest of the law in place,” Justice Kavanaugh said. “I tend to agree with you this is a very straightforward case for severability under our precedence.”
Read More
Chief Justice Roberts pointed out that Congress did not repeal the entire Affordable Care Act when it zeroed out the individual mandate as part of 2017 GOP tax legislation. And earlier legislative attempts to repeal the entire law failed narrowly in Republican-led Senate in July 2017.
The individual mandate, perhaps the most controversial component of the law, was upheld in 2012 by a 5-4 Supreme Court decision in which Chief Justice Roberts sided with the court’s four liberal justices. That ruling left the individual mandate in place, the chief justice reasoned, because Congress has the authority to tax and spend.
Yet because Republicans, as part of their 2017 tax cut legislation, zeroed out the individual mandate’s penalty, a group of 20 Republican-led states argued it became unconstitutional because the government no longer collected revenue as a tax. The states once again sought that the entire law be struck down.
In December 2018, a federal judge in Texas issued a surprise ruling that wiped the entire law from the books. One year later, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 5th Circuit, based in New Orleans, ruled the individual mandate unconstitutional but sent the case back to the trial court for more analysis on whether the entire law should be scrapped.
In March, the Supreme Court agreed to hear the case.
In defense of the law, 21 states, all but one led by Democrats, have jumped into the case. Six additional states — including Pennsylvania and two Republican-led states — filed an amicus brief in May in defense of the law, arguing, in part, the debate over the individual mandate should be considered to be separate from the rest of the law.
As of this week, 331,825 Pennsylvanians have purchased insurance plans on the state-run exchanges, and more than 857,000 are enrolled through Medicaid expansion, according to state data. Healthcare officials estimate 5.2 million people in the state have a pre-existing condition protected by the law.
Justice Barrett has previously criticized Chief Justice Roberts’ 2012 ruling that upheld the individual mandate as Constitutional. The chief justice “pushed the Affordable Care Act beyond its plausible meaning to save the statute,” she wrote in a 2017 law review article.
On Tuesday, Justice Barrett, questioning Michael J. Mongan, the solicitor general of California, who represented a coalition of liberal-leaning states defending the law, asked about whether there was still some kind of burden on states and individuals even with no financial penalty collected by tax authorities.
She echoed hypotheticals described by Justice Clarence Thomas, who compared the individual mandate to a federal mask mandate amid the COVID-19 pandemic and Justice Kavanaugh, who raised the scenario of requiring people to fly an American flag in front of their homes.
Mr. Mongan argued Congress rendered the law “inoperable” and toothless without a penalty — yet he added that, if the court disagreed, the remedy would be to invalidate the mandate and not the broader law.
“What would be deeply problematic,” he said, “is if plaintiffs were allowed to leverage this single inoperative provision to tear down hundreds of other provisions.”
The arguments, which spanned about two hours, will inform the court’s decision expected sometime in May or June.
During the second hour of arguments, Mr. Casey joined Kathleen Sebelius — former secretary of the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services who was the defendant in the 2012 Supreme Court case — on a media call to rail against efforts to dismantle the law.
In recent years, Mr. Casey said, mothers of children with disabilities had been forced “to suit up for battle to preserve something that our country already provided.”
“That is the definition of injustice — perverse, disgusting injustice,” Mr. Casey said.
Mr. Trump and Republicans have promised to protect people with pre-existing conditions in the event the Affordable Care Act is struck down. Yet Mr. Trump’s only move has been to sign executive orders in September that promise to protect them.
“I can guarantee that no executive order does that,” Ms. Sebelius said. “You need a law that says to insurance companies that you may not discriminate any longer against people with pre-existing conditions. That’s where we’ve been for 10 years, and that’s what’s on the chopping block today before the Supreme Court.”
Ms. Sebelius added she expects the President-Elect Joe Biden’s administration to move quickly to preserve protections in the law.
“I think, in a very real way, the Affordable Care Act was on the ballot in 2020,” Ms. Sebelius said, praising Mr. Biden’s projected victory in Pennsylvania as a result of voters’ health care concerns.
Daniel Moore: dmoore@post-gazette.com, Twitter @PGdanielmoore



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.