CLARKSBURG, W.Va. —- It’s clear that veterans and military service are an important part of the fabric of this city.
It’s not just Clarksburg’s annual Veterans Day that dates back nearly a century to when it was still known as Armistice Day, or the fact that the city is named after Revolutionary War General George Rogers Clark. It also has three war memorials (including a controversial statue of Confederate General Stonewall Jackson) in front of the Harrison County Courthouse that sits in the center of town.
And while most cities its size (about 16,000 residents) have long lost one or both of their veterans organizations, Clarksburg still has both active VFW and American Legion posts.
The crown jewel for this community of veterans is the Louis A. Johnson Veterans Affairs Medical Center. Originally built in 1950 and named after President Harry Truman’s defense secretary, it sits on 16 acres on a ridge just outside of town next to the city’s Veterans Memorial Park.
On any given day the parking lot at the VA hospital is full to overflowing, its hallways teeming with patients and visitors coming and going, a fact that has led to multiple expansions over the years.
It is one of the county’s largest employers, with about 700 full- and part-time employees. “Everyone here knows someone who works at the VA,” said local attorney David Glover.
Read More
But the faith and pride the community has in the hospital was shaken to the core on Aug. 20. On that day, an investigation into a horrific series of homicides that the VA and federal investigators had managed to keep a lid on for 14 months, became public.

One of the victims’ adult children — frustrated by the slow pace of the investigation — filed a federal document that described how FBI and the VA Office of Inspector General investigators told her they believed that 10 or 11 Johnson patients were killed by massive and improper injections of insulin. Attorneys now believe those cases may have occurred in 2017 and 2018, though the VA would not confirm it.
Investigators already had identified a “person of interest” they believed was responsible for the deaths, though the person was not named and no one has yet been charged.
The revelation was devastating to the community.
“We are just a very patriotic community,” said Clarksburg Mayor Ryan Kennedy, 42, himself an Army veteran. “We have a very high percentage of veterans in this community. This has created a black cloud” over Clarksburg it has created a lot of issues with trust” between the community and hospital.
“When everybody knows everybody in a small community, people talk. And unfortunately, this is what everybody is talking about.”
Still a busy place
Though the hospital was busy on Friday, and patients continued to come and go, that did not mean those patients and their families dismissed the homicides that occurred there.
“We were just talking about it as we pulled in here,” said Marie Frymier, who came to the Johnson VA Friday morning with her husband, Kline, a Navy veteran who was coming for on optometry checkup from their home in Cox’s Mill, a town 90 minutes and two counties away from Clarksburg.
The homicides “makes you concerned,” she said. “... that you’re going to be next,” Mr. Kline added.
He said he was glad he was just coming for an outpatient checkup, rather than an overnight, in-patient medical procedure, since the victims were in-patients when they were killed.
In town, after nearly three weeks of heavy media coverage, nearly every resident had at least heard about the homicide investigation, and many said it had become a regular part of daily conversation.
“I know at church we’ve asked for prayers, for all the people involved — the victims’ families, the investigators, even the person who did it; that person really needs” prayers, said Lu Ann Pumphrey, a cook for local schools who lives just outside Clarksburg in the nearby town of Sun Valley and worries because she has a friend living in the nursing home on the Johnson VA campus.
Foremost among what people are talking about is who is the “person of interest”?
Melanie Proctor has heard that talk.
She is the adult daughter of Felix “Kirk” McDermott, 81, formerly of Ruffs Dale, Westmoreland County. She filed the federal “Basis of Claim” — a preliminary document before filing a federal wrongful death lawsuit against the VA — on August 20 that set off the firestorm in town.
“Everyone thinks they know” who the person of interest is, said Ms. Proctor, a tax professional who lives in Ellenboro, about 40 miles west of Clarksburg.
Her father, a retired Army sergeant, died April 9, 2018 after going into the hospital four days earlier after he aspirated some food while he was a resident at the state nursing home that is attached to the Johnson VA.

In a pattern that was repeated with the only other identified victim, George Nelson Shaw, 82, of Wallace, who died April 10, 2018, Mr. McDermott had been improving and was expected to be sent back to the nursing home when his blood sugar unexpectedly crashed early in the morning on April 9, just hours before he died.
After both men’s bodies were exhumed, autopsies found four different locations on their bodies where insulin was injected before they died. That caused their deaths to be reclassified as homicides and apparently led investigators to their person of interest.
“There’s going to be no doubt that there’s been a huge system failure here,” said Tony O’Dell, a Charleston, W.Va. attorney who represents Ms. Proctor. “These [deaths after sudden episodes of hypoglycemia] are sentinel events that are to be reported up the chain of command and root-cause analysis that should have been done.”
A review of the hospital’s policies and procedures, done approximately every three years and unrelated to the homicides, was completed by the Office of Inspector General in October 2018.
In that report, the OIG arrived on campus unannounced, which it always does for such a review, the week of May 7, 2018, a little less than a month after Mr. Shaw and Mr. McDermott died. The team spent several days there reviewing the Johnson VA’s “quality of care delivered in the in-patient and out-patient settings” for the time period between September 2015 and May 7, 2018.
The death of George Nelson Shaw Sr.
As part of a regular part of such a report by the OIG titled “Indicators for Possible Lapses in Care,” investigators found that the Johnson VA “has not consistently applied criteria according to [Veterans Health Administration] policy to identify sentinel events.” The review team also found that Johnson VA staff did not follow its own policy to disclose information to patients’ representatives when a sentinel event occurred.
A “sentinel event”, according to the OIG, is “an incident or condition that results in patient death, permanent harm, severe temporary harm, or intervention required to sustain life.”
The review team found that while the Johnson VA staff said they had no sentinel events in fiscal year 2017, a review of the Johnson VA’s own “root-cause analysis” records found six incidents that appeared to be sentinel events. Among these events, the report said, were a suicide, a malfunction of laser equipment during surgery, and “administration of a wrong medication.” Johnson VA spokesman Wesley Walls said none of these events, however, were related to the homicide investigation.
After a review, the Johnson VA staff agreed that one of the six cases the review team identified did qualify as a sentinel event, though the report does not say which one that was.
In its conclusion, the OIG wrote, “the presence of risk factors — lack of identification, tracking, and reporting of sentinel events and disclosure of adverse events — may contribute to future issues of noncompliance and/or lapses in patient safety unless corrective processes are implemented and continuously monitored.”
Mr. O’Dell said that it is “my understanding that when they go back and look, they will include these [homicide cases] and consider them sentinel events.”
‘A serial killer’
Around town, while many were trying to guess who the person of interest is, one name has been repeated by most, the name of a former employee. Reached at home by phone, that former employee would not comment.
Ms. Proctor said whoever is ultimately charged in the case “in my mind [the person of interest] is a serial killer.”
“When you have ten cases and possibly by the same person involved with each case, to me that’s the definition of a serial killer,” she said.
The fact that investigators long ago identified a person of interest — Ms. Proctor was first told that in late August, 2018 — but no one has yet been arrested, has frustrated many.
“I just had that conversation [about no one being arrested] with the victim advocate with the OIG this morning,” Ms. Proctor said Friday in an interview in Ellenboro. “She said they’re just getting their ducks in a row.”
Mr. Glover, the Clarksburg attorney who represents Mr. Shaw’s family, said though pressure has built on the VA and the FBI to resolve the case now that it is public, it could take longer since “there are even more people coming forward with concerns about [how their relative died at the VA] and there could be more autopsies to perform” before the case wraps up.
The longer the case drags on, with no resolution and no arrest completed, the worse it is for the Johnson VA, many believe.
“My Dad really liked it there” when he had been treated at the Johnson VA, said Ms. Proctor.
“And that’s the sad part. A lot of those old guys relied on that VA,” she said. “But now they’re scared to go there.”
Sean D. Hamill: shamill@post-gazette.com or 412-263-2579 or Twitter: @SeanDHamill



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.