Awaiting one of her regular exercise workouts on the University of Pittsburgh’s upper campus, 70-year-old Julie Murphy winced when describing forgetful moments that have begun plaguing her in a way that never occurred decades ago.
Sometimes it’s forgetting the name of someone she has just met. Sometimes there’s a slip-up with worse repercussions for the resident of Pittsburgh’s Park Place neighborhood.
“I made my first mistake on my checking account last year,” thinking she had made a payment that she hadn’t, Ms. Murphy said.
“In the past I was always on top of everything,” she said, snapping fingers twice for emphasis while recounting the administrative work she did for nonprofit groups. “I eat lunch with a bunch of people my age now and we all talk about the little tiny things like [forgetting names or tasks] that we’re noticing.”
Occasional forgetfulness and other types of mental slowdown, such as increased difficulty with multi-tasking, are considered normal, age-related cognitive decline for most people in their 60s and older. It may or may not be a precursor of worse mental problems, including Alzheimer’s disease or other dementia.
But such decline may also be preventable — or at least postponable. A growing number of researchers are examining changes in lifestyle — whether focused on exercise at Pitt or on diet, stress reduction and more elsewhere — that could aid mental functioning. And if they can identify just how those behaviors benefit the brain, their research can be of still greater use in helping develop effective drugs against Alzheimer’s, a goal that has proved frustratingly elusive thus far.
Read More
“There’s a lot of excitement and interest in exercise as one of the most promising lifestyle behaviors, one that we have the most evidence suggesting you can improve brain function and reduce the risk of dementia,” Pitt psychology professor Kirk Erickson said. “That being said, there still remains a lot of skepticism.”
Mr. Erickson, director of Pitt’s Brain Aging and Cognitive Health Lab, is heading one of the largest studies ever devoted to exercise and mental function. The National Institute on Aging awarded a $21.8 million grant in 2016 to cover five years of research at Pitt, the University of Kansas and Northeastern University for what is called the IGNITE study.
Ms. Murphy is among 639 people ages 65 to 80 — mostly sedentary prior to the study — to be placed at the three sites in different exercise groups for 12 months each. They do either regular stretching exercises or 150 minutes or 225 minutes of brisk weekly walking, some of it supervised and some on their own. At the beginning and end of the study, they undergo an extensive battery of tests spanning cognitive abilities, MRI brain scans, genetics bloodwork, cardiovascular functioning and more.
The goal is to build upon prior, smaller studies — including one published by Mr. Erickson in 2011 — that point to exercise benefits for the brain. His earlier Pitt research found that just by walking 30 to 45 minutes three times a week for a year, participants 60 to 80 years old avoided the natural shrinkage of the hippocampus, which is central to the brain’s memory function, and actually increased it by 2%.
“You might think that 2% is not that much, but 12 months of walking essentially reversed the age clock by about one to two years — to me, that’s pretty remarkable,” Mr. Erickson said.
Among shortcomings of that and other exercise studies, Mr. Erickson allowed, is that they have generally been done on a small scale; they haven’t identified differences in effect between categories and volume of exercise; and they have done little to measure how and why different types of people are impacted.
In essence, everyone knows it’s good to exercise for a broad range of benefits, but too little is known about the particulars on the mental side.
“We want to have physicians or other health professionals be able to recommend physical activity to improve brain function or prevent deficits, but we need a better prescription than just ‘Get out and get more physical activity,’” Mr. Erickson said. “It would be like a physician saying ‘Take this medication,’ but then not giving you instructions as to how much to take.”
The sad fact is that older adults typically won’t seek out much physical activity without a specific instruction or obligation or to do so.
“I needed a commitment to exercise, other than just to myself,” admitted Dan Dwulit, 67, of Robinson, who had been doing little of it on his own before joining the study last fall and adhering to a five-day-a-week schedule ever since.
John Jakicic, a Pitt professor of health and physical activity who is a co-investigator in the study, said probably fewer than 20% of older adults exercise regularly — even so much as moderate-to-brisk walking. A major IGNITE goal is to determine just how little activity can still generate improvement.
“We’re not trying to find the maximum amount people need to do, but the minimum necessary to start to see some benefit,” Mr. Jakicic said. “Most people want to do the least they can do and get some benefit. ... People see exercise as hard — it’s hard to find time and they want to prioritize other things.”
The IGNITE study is midway toward completion, but even when results are analyzed and published several years from now they won’t say anything definitive about preventing dementia. That would require a longer research trial than is enabled by the NIA’s five-year limit to its grants, Mr. Erickson said. He plans to apply for additional NIA funding in the fall to continue studying the participants longer term.
Regardless, any findings that show improved cognitive function are viewed as an important step in the search for meaningful Alzheimer’s treatment and prevention. The four drugs approved for Alzheimer’s treatment have only modest, temporary effects, at best, and a string of major drug trials aimed at preventing the disease has ended unsuccessfully.
“Recent years have been very disappointing for companies, researchers and patients/caregivers,” observed Dr. R. Scott Turner, neurologist and director of the Memory Disorders Program at Georgetown University.
That is part of the reason why the surge in interest in lifestyle interventions could make a difference. The NIA is also funding large trials examining the value of the Mediterranean diet and stress reduction techniques such as yoga and meditation, and combinations of different approaches. One large study known as EXERT is examining the impact of exercise on those already in the early stages of Alzheimer’s.
Weighing what has the most likely value in all such approaches, Molly Wagster, the chief of NIA’s Behavioral and Systems Neuroscience Branch, said, “The jury is still out. Even if [there are] great results from the exercise trial, we still want to look at these other intervention opportunities, because maybe everyone’s not able to exercise because of physical limitations.”
One of the largest research studies ever funded by the Alzheimer’s Association, the $35 million POINTER study, is just getting underway to examine a wide range of interventions simultaneously. The two-year study of 2,500 older adults will determine the effect of a combination of exercise, nutritional counseling and modification, cognitive and social stimulation and improved self-management of medical conditions. It is modeled after a similar study in Finland that found positive results for cognitive abilities.
Successful findings won’t mean a cure for a disease that the Alzheimer’s Association projects to grow from 5.8 million U.S. cases to 14 million by 2050, but it could put a large dent in the numbers.
“Based on our models, if we are able to delay the onset by just five years, 5.7 million people won’t develop the disease” who otherwise might have it in 2050, said Heather Snyder, the association’s senior director of medical and scientific organizations.
Julie Murphy’s mother had dementia, a memory she bears in mind while exercising at a level since March — as a result of the IGNITE study — that she never did before. She doesn’t know if it will prevent her from developing dementia, but she knows she feels better from it.
“I really believe exercise is good for you, that it does help your brain,” the slender woman in black-and-purple sneakers said before her latest workout. “My mind is sharper, and I’m more energetic after I exercise.”
And if it helps her remember a name or to write a check, so much the better.
Gary Rotstein: grotstein@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1255.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.