Whenever the incidence of old-people diseases rise in younger adults, the prime suspect is poor lifestyle, as is the case with ever younger people being diagnosed with heart disease, Type 2 diabetes and obesity.
The same could hold true for colorectal cancer in the 45-49 age group, which has experienced a 51 percent increase in diagnoses, from 1994 to 2014, and an 11 percent increase in mortality, from 2005 to 2015. Consider that colorectal cancer rates are declining in people 55 and older, largely due to screening regimens.
While physicians say the reasons for that boost in colorectal cancer among younger adults are unclear, multiple health studies blame smoking, alcohol, red and processed meats among other processed foods, along with too little exercise and dietary fiber as risk factors for colorectal cancer in adults of all ages.
A May study published in the Protein Cell journal, for example, said the cancer is rising in countries that have adopted the Western lifestyle. “In conclusion,” it states, “a balanced diet with an increased abundance of fiber should be adopted to reduce the risk and prevent colorectal cancer.”
Rising colorectal cancer rates among younger adults led the American Cancer Society last Wednesday to issue a new “qualified” guideline — as opposed to a strong recommendation — that people age 45 to 49 and older should undergo colorectal screening. The previous guideline for people at average risk for the cancer was age 50 and older.
Screening options include a colonoscopy, high sensitivity guaiac-based fecal occult blood test, the multi-target stool DNA test, CT colonography or the flexible sigmoidoscopy, each with its own recommended intervals for retesting.
Read More
That new guideline is controversial in Pittsburgh and beyond.
After the announcement Wednesday, Robert E. Schoen, UPMC chief of the division of gastroenterology, hepatology and nutrition, stated several reasons why he opposed the new guideline, including the need to better understand reasons for the increase, that the lower guideline is based on computer modeling rather than clinical trials, and raising awareness that 47 percent of people 50 and older are not compliant with screening guidelines should be the focus.
“We should be devoting resources to getting those people screened before adding lower risk groups for testing,” he said, explaining that he didn’t want to be too strident in his opposition to the guideline.
On the other hand, Manish Dhawan, chief of the Division of Gastroenterology at Allegheny Health Network, said he supports the idea of lowering the guideline to 45 while also recognizing that adding 22 million more patients will increase health care costs and heighten stress on existing medical resources.
“I feel that early screening may offer advantages in that one can find precancerous lesions during a colonoscopy but there is a risk and cost associated with screening strategies,” he said. “So one has to balance the risks and benefits, and it should be a discussion that patients have with their physicians.”
Raising awareness among at-risk groups is key.
“Only 60 percent of patients who are eligible for colon cancer screening actually get it down,” he said. “If people under age 50 exhibit symptoms such as bleeding from the digestive system in the form of frank blood or black stools (melena), or if they develop iron deficiency anemia, then appropriate endoscopic evaluation should be performed.”
Those who smoke, have diabetes or are obese may be at high risk and should discuss screening with their physicians. “One cannot emphasize enough that there is evidence of decreasing rates of colon cancer in older patients who have had regular screenings.”
The Cancer Society reports that colorectal cancer is the fourth most commonly diagnosed cancer among adults in the United States, with one of every 140,000 Americans expected to be diagnosed with the cancer this year. It’s the second leading cause of cancer death, with more than 50,000 deaths annually, with the highest incidence and mortality rates in African-Americans, Native Americans and Alaska Natives.
For that reason, those ethnic groups are advised to undergo screening even earlier than the guideline recommends.
Dr. Dhawan said the youngest patient he diagnosed was a 32-year-old father who was already at an advanced stage. The man, who was married with twin children, died from the cancer.
Some people may have a genetic predisposition or a family history of such cancers, which the person can’t change. But lifestyle can be modified to reduce one’s risk.
“Studies have looked at the beneficial effects of high fiber. When broken down to short-chain fatty acids, it promotes colon health,” Dr. Dhawan said. “The lack of fiber can lead to abnormal changes in the large intestines including polyps.”
Once a patient has had polyps, he said, the evidence isn’t as clear that lifestyle modifications help, as occurs with diabetes, acid reflux, sleep apnea and cardiovascular diseases.
“Healthy lifestyle should be the first goal of any preventive strategy,” Dr. Dhawan said. “There’s always a chance that cancer development is related to unhealthy lifestyle.”
David Templeton: dtempleton@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1578. Twitter: @templetoons.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.