The three Pittsburgh-area women who sued a Cleveland hospital last week for accidentally destroying eggs they had frozen before they underwent cancer treatment traveled to Cleveland for that procedure because it has only been routinely used in Pittsburgh for the past three years.

Though it is rapidly being used more and more here and across the country — for young cancer patients in particular — the process of freezing human eggs for possible conception in the future has only been considered non-experimental since 2012.

An exception to this has been University Hospital in Cleveland — the hospital where the three women had their eggs removed and frozen — which was an early adopter in the field and has been using the process for patients more regularly since 2011.

“I was told that they had a particular expertise in freezing eggs” as opposed to embryos, which have been routinely frozen for decades now, said Sarah Deer, 30. She was one of the three women who sued the hospital. Embryos are eggs that are fertilized with sperm.

Advertise with us

It was because of that hospital’s expertise that doctors in Pittsburgh referred all three women to University Hospital in Cleveland in 2015 and 2016.

That was about the time when the three fertility clinics in Pittsburgh that now freeze eggs — at Allegheny General Hospital, Magee-Womens Hospital of UPMC and an independent clinic, Reproductive Health Services in Penn Hills — all began routinely recovering and freezing eggs for women. UPMC began doing it experimentally in 2011.

“This is a newer process for us,” said Lori Homa, director of the Division of Reproductive Endocrinology and Infertility at Allegheny Health Network, which removes and freezes eggs at AGH. “It is much more difficult to freeze and thaw an egg than an embryo.”

Though the freezing of embryos has been done routinely for more than two decades, the process of freezing eggs — known as “oocyte cryopreservation” — and then thawing them later for fertilization before insemination and the birth of a child was not done successfully using the current technique until 1999.

That technique, known as “vitrification,” took more than a decade to refine, but it was the step that allowed researchers to solve the riddle that had prevented them from routinely freezing eggs.

Advertise with us

“Eggs are more sensitive because an egg is a single cell with a lot of water in it,” said Dr. Homa. “That means when you freeze it, it is more likely to form crystals and crack.”

Vitrification is a process that induces osmosis to remove most of the water from the egg cell, preventing it from forming crystals and cracking.

In addition, embryos, which are allowed to grow for five days before they are frozen, are hardier than the eggs they start out as, said Fabiola Balmir, an reproductive endocrinologist at AHN.

When they are fertilized, the eggs form embryos that are “much more complex … and much more robust” than an egg, Dr. Balmir said during a tour of AHN’s egg recovery lab and storage facility at AGH.

Instead of the one cell that an egg represents, a 5-day-old embryo will have become a blastocyst with 120 or more cells. By then, it already will have formed an outer ring of cells, which will later become the placenta, and an inner cell mass, which will become the baby.

Advertise with us

Once vitrification became standardized in 2012, fertility clinics like AHN’s, RHS’s and UPMC’s, which all had been freezing embryos for more than a decade, began learning the process of freezing eggs.

The reasons women remove eggs and freeze them fall into two main categories: One is medical; the other is for “social” reasons, such as a woman in her 20s or 30s who does not yet have a partner or does not yet want to conceive wants to ensure that some of her eggs will be available for some time in the future. A woman’s egg production begins to fall off rapidly after age 35.

“We’ve done some preservation for those without partners in recent years, maybe five to 10 a year,” said Judith Albert, medical director at RHS.

Those social reasons can include concerns about delaying a family while a woman pursues a career, which was why Apple and Facebook in 2014 began offering it as a benefit to female employees, and why in 2016 the U.S. military did, too.

On the medical side, younger women facing treatment for cancer — such as the three women who sued University Hospital — now have the option of freezing their eggs and are a rapidly growing group using this process.

Advertise with us

“It’s a big group,” Dr. Homa said, “and we’d like it to be bigger.”

Neither AHN nor RHS had good numbers available on how many eggs and embryos they have recovered and stored over the years.

University Hospital lost more than 4,000 eggs and embryos from 950 families on March 3 when the freezer tank in which they were preserved malfunctioned and temperatures rose high enough to kill them. Compounding the problem, staff had improperly filled the tank with liquid nitrogen manually from the top, and someone at the hospital had turned off an alarm system that would have remotely alerted staff at home that there was a problem. But staff did not hear an alarm until they got to work the next day, March 4.

Dr. Albert said that if those, in fact, are what caused the problem, “It’s proof that protocols are only as good as the people who implement them.”

She said RHS has recovered mostly embryos about 200 times a year since the facility opened in 2000, so thousands if not tens of thousands of embryos and eggs have been in storage with a third-party, ReproTech, off-site that has an expertise in long-term storage.

Advertise with us

RHS does store eggs and embryos on-site temporarily until they can be transferred to ReproTech, but until then, she said: “We have policies and procedures, and we think we follow them to the letter.”

AHN estimates that it has a couple thousand eggs and embryos stored long-term on-site in three liquid nitrogen-filled tanks that it keeps in its IVF (In Vitro Fertilization) Lab at AGH.

It believes it has a system in place that can avoid the problems that University Hospital faced.

First, it does not have a manual off switch for its alarm system. And it does not rely on a manual system to refill the tanks with liquid nitrogen because those systems can fail. It always manually fills the tanks with liquid nitrogen with the manufacturer’s prescribed method.

“We think that cuts down on the possibility of a problem,” Dr. Balmir said.

Advertise with us

UPMC would not make someone available to talk or answer detailed questions about its operation, except to provide an emailed statement that UPMC is “revisiting our safety protocols” to ensure that its storage facilities are safe.

Both RHS and AHN said that since the incident in Cleveland they have checked on their own procedures to ensure that they are following proper protocols or, in the case of RHS, that RHS’s contractor, Reprotech, is following them.

And all three facilities say they have been watching carefully what is happening in Cleveland to see if there are lessons for them in what went wrong there.

“It’s devastating for these people and it’s very scary” what happened in Cleveland, Dr. Albert said. “If indeed it is determined to be human error and they didn’t follow policies and procedures, that’s a learning experience for sure.”

Sean D. Hamill: shamill@post-gazette.com or 412-263-2579 or Twitter: @SeanDHamill.