Sarah Deer, 30, Rachel Mehl, 40, and Danelle Yerkey, 37, met over the last year in a young cancer survivors’ group when all three Pittsburgh-area women were in recovery from breast cancer.
That bond led them to become friends.
But last month they shared another unsought bond when they discovered they were all victims of a catastrophic series of events that led to the destruction of their frozen eggs that University Hospital in Cleveland had recovered from them in advance of their cancer treatment.
“It’s a sisterhood that no one wants to be part of,” Ms. Deer said Tuesday.
All three are suing the hospital for the destruction of eggs in Cuyahoga County (Ohio) Court of Common Pleas alleging negligence, recklessness and breach of contract. They are seeking both compensatory and punitive damages and attorneys’ fees.
The women were among 950 families whose more than 4,000 eggs and embryos were destroyed March 3 when the freezer tank they were preserved in at University Hospital malfunctioned and temperatures rose high enough to kill them. Compounding the problem, someone at the hospital had turned off an alarm system that would have remotely alerted staff at home that there was a problem. Staff did not hear an alarm until they got to work the next day, March 4.
Including the three women, 27 families have filed lawsuits so far against the hospital, and more are expected.
Ms. Deer and her friends are being represented by attorney Gloria Allred, a Los Angeles-based attorney best known for representing celebrities in high-profile cases, but also known in particular for representing women’s causes.
Ms. Deer, a middle school teacher in the North Hills, said the three women all agreed to ask Ms. Allred to represent them because “she’s a champion for women’s rights” and “she gets things done.”
Ms. Allred said that she decided to take their case because she found their stories to be “heroic” because all three of them told her their main goal was to ensure what happened to them never happened to anyone else again.
“All of them said they wanted to have a voice and have some measure of justice, and all of them wanted to fight for change,” she said.
Ms. Deer said wanting their case to result in changes to prevent the careless destruction of preserved eggs in the future, only made sense.
“When you experience something so personal like this, the weight of the grief moves you to compassion for other people,” she said.
Ms. Allred was also struck by their stories of risking their own lives to have a chance at having a family.
All three women had chosen to delay starting their cancer treatment so that they could go through the weeks-long process of getting hormone injections — which stimulate the production of eggs — and the harvesting of the eggs at University Hospital. They ended up going there because of recommendations from their doctors in Pittsburgh that University Hospital had a particular expertise in preserving eggs, rather than embryos, which are fertilized eggs.
Cancer treatment, including chemotherapy and radiation, often prevents women from producing eggs after the treatment, and it is common for fertility specialists to recommend harvesting and preserving eggs beforehand. Many are able to have children later through in vitro fertilization.
Ms. Yerkey, a wedding photographer from Clairton, said in her prepared statements at a news conference all three women appeared at Monday in Cleveland that she took a blood test this past week that confirmed she would not be able to produce eggs anymore after undergoing 16 rounds of chemotherapy, 25 rounds of radiation and a double mastectomy.
With the destruction of the 24 viable eggs that were harvested at University Hospital three years ago, she said: “My hopes and dreams have been shattered. I have no idea how I will go on. Everything has been stolen from me. My spirit is crushed.”
Ms. Mehl, of Crafton, who is dealing with a recurrence of her cancer, said that the idea of delaying cancer treatment, even if it meant risking her life, for her, was an attempt to gain some semblance of control over her life.
“Making the choice to have my eggs frozen felt empowering,” she said in her prepared remarks Monday. “It offered a light at the end of a very dark tunnel. Things may be terrible now, I thought, but at least one day I’ll still be able to have the family I’ve always dream of. But now that light has been extinguished.”
Ms. Deer said Monday, in a decidedly Pittsburgh reference, that the day she found out that doctors were able to retrieve 29 eggs, her now-husband quipped that she had “a ‘Fleury’ of eggs” because 29 was former Penguins goalie Marc-Andre Fleury’s jersey number.
“We were overjoyed,” she said.
But now, she said, she has to contemplate another life-threatening option: Should she go off her medication that lowers the risk of a cancer recurrence and go through the hormone injections that can help feed her type of cancer to give her the possibility of producing more eggs?
Asked in an interview Tuesday how that decision is going, Ms. Deer said her “team” of her husband, oncologist and fertility doctor are still debating that.
“We’re still trying to figure out what will be best,” she said.
Sean D. Hamill: shamill@post-gazette.com or 412-263-2579 or Twitter: @SeanDHamill



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.