A committee of experts from the National Academies of Sciences, Engineering and Medicine Tuesday reported a mix of conclusions after investigating research on the health effects of e-cigarettes, finding that while e-cigarettes in general may have health risks, they are probably much less harmful than regular tobacco cigarettes.
Commissioned by the U.S. Food & Drug Administration, the committee found about 800 studies to review and cited gaps in knowledge about e-cigarettes and health.
In an online discussion of the report, committee chairman David Eaton, dean of the graduate school of the University of Washington, said they assessed the quality of research along with results, which fell at different levels of strength. Many human health risks could only be measured at the short term, he said.
“We recognized devices have changed characteristics over 10 years,” including what makes up the liquid and aerosols of e-cigarettes.
They found the exposure to nicotine and potentially toxic substances is lower in e-cigarettes and there’s evidence that e-cigarettes can be less addictive than regular cigarettes, depending on the substances contained in the liquid used in the devices.
“Exposure occurs, but is highly variable,” Mr. Eaton said.
Since e-cigarettes have been around for only about 12 years, the study found there was no long-term evidence that using e-cigarettes increases the risk that youth and young adult users will become users of regular cigarettes. It did note evidence that young users of vaping devices have gone on to try conventional cigarettes at least once.
In the end, the committee said they could not say that e-cigarettes are either beneficial or harmful. They ranked the quality of evidence in the research from “conclusive” (controlled studies of high quality, with no contradictory findings), down to “substantial” (several findings from observational studies with few or no credible opposing findings) on down to areas where evidence was unavailable.
They noted “conclusive evidence” that substituting e-cigarettes for regular cigarettes reduces users’ exposure to toxic and cancer-causing substances from smoking. The committee said the risk of young vapers going on to use regular cigarettes was supported by “substantial evidence.”
Committee member Adam Leventhal, health behavior researcher at the University of South California, said follow-up studies are needed to see if experimentation as a youth leads to long-term smoking.
“There’s a complex relationship between e-cigarettes and combustible tobacco use,” he said. “We found e-cigarette use increases the risk of ever using [regular cigarettes].”
A longtime critic of research that labels e-cigarettes and vaping a gateway to tobacco smoking for young people, Bill Godshall, executive director of Smokefree Pennsylvania, attacked the committee’s report, saying, “This is a repeat of all the junk science that’s been done already.”
A proponent of vaping as a path to quit tobacco smoking, Mr. Godshall said, “There are a thousand times more people who have quit smoking using vaping products than people going from vapers to cigarettes.”
He added that studies have not asked young people if they had smoked before vaping, only if they had smoked a cigarette at least once after previously vaping.
He suggested the findings might have been different if there was a harm-reduction expert on the committee. He also said randomized, controlled trials, while accepted as the highest quality in testing medical treatments, can’t reproduce the experience of vaping.
“There are over 3 million e-cigarette products registered with the FDA,” he said.
“The average vaper has switched from dozens of vaper products since they’ve quit smoking,” he said. Surveys show the success of vaping, he said, adding that surveys show most teens aren’t vaping with nicotine.
The NAS committee also found “conclusive” evidence that:
• E-cigarette use increases concentrations of particulates and nicotine in indoor air.
• E-cigarettes can explode and cause projectile injuries, exposure to e-liquids can cause injury and sickness, and drinking the liquids can be fatal.
Allegheny County Health Director Karen Hacker, after a look at the report’s summary, said the county considered much of the same evidence before its move last year to restrict vaping in indoor public places and discourage vaping by young people.
“We said all along we’d like to see better studies about what harm reduction would be… The concerns we have are also identified: the addiction potential, the adolescent concerns — the evidence that after vaping they do go on to cigarettes. That could be a concern. There’s a lack of longitudinal studies.”
The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention has reported smoking in the U.S. declined to a rate of 15.5 percent in 2016. The county has seen a similar drop in smoking among adults, Dr. Hacker said.
“From a public health standpoint, if your focus is strictly on smoking, identifying better harm reduction strategies is important. On the flip side, if there’s something that drives people to cigarettes, there’s a potential for nicotine addiction. Not to mention the toxicity of nicotine and risk of explosion.”
As steps forward in the wake of the report, Mr. Eaton called for a better understanding of the e-cigarette devices and how they work; observational studies of how youth use e-cigarettes and move on to regular smoking and randomized, controlled trials of e-cigarettes in helping people stop smoking.
“The committee’s work provides a template to future evaluations of evidence,” he said. “There’s a lot left to be learned, but we don’t think it’s an intractable problem.”
Jill Daly: jdaly@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1596.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.