One can cause a heart attack, stroke and kidney failure. The other is addictive.

So Toradol and Vicodin — two powerful pain relievers of concern in the federal lawsuit filed by 1,800 former professional football players against the NFL — are drugs you don’t want to play with, in any sense of the term.

Toradol, the brand name of a non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drug known as “ketorolac tromethamine,” is administered intramuscularly to treat pain after surgery, with oral doses also available. Football players typically received injections.

The Food and Drug Administration also includes off-label uses for “regional anesthesia,” headache and eye pain that’s treated with the drug in the form of eye drops. But Toradol is intended for use in the short term, for no more than five days.

Advertise with us

Non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs, or NSAIDs that include Ibuprofen, raise the risk of kidney damage or renal failure, the latter especially occurring when taken prior to strenuous physical activity, said David Gortler, a pharmacist, pharmacologist and FDA expert with the consulting group, FormerFDA.com.

Extended use of Toradol also can cause serious side effects and cardiovascular problems including heart attacks, with other side effects including stroke and internal bleeding.

“It can be very effective but should only be used acutely for temporary relief of pain — situational relief — but shouldn’t be injected every day of the week. That concept is a bad idea,” said Mr. Gortler, who holds two doctoral degrees. “When you are in pain, your body is trying to communicate something to you: Stop using that leg or joint and give it time to repair the injury and get better.”

It was never meant to be administered in anticipation of pain, he said. And using a drug to block pain from a current muscle, joint, tendon or bone injury can lead to more severe damage with potential long-term disability.

“These poor football players will be hobbling around [like elderly people] when they are 45 years old if they continue abusing the drugs,” Mr. Gortler said. “The right thing to do is let the player rest. All these drugs just block pain and don’t relieve the underlying damage that’s causing the pain.”

Advertise with us

Vicodin was a combination medication of Tylenol (acetaminophen) and hydrocodone, an opioid. In recent years, Vicodin has been replaced by Norco, which has less Tylenol. The combination of Tylenol and Norco work synergistically to reduce pain.

Because Vicodin was a controlled substance, the physician prescribing and dispensing it had to be a U.S. Drug Enforcement Agency registrant. Used for moderate to severe pain, the drug was designed solely to mask pain in the the brain, with side effects including drowsiness, nausea and mental confusion.

As with Toradol, It was intended to be used only after pain occurred from injury, surgery or medical conditions. Its most concerning side effect with long-term use, Mr. Gortler said, is addiction.

David Templeton: dtempleton@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1578.