For a bingo game, it was restrained.
No one leapt from their seats. They were chained to the table legs. Winners didn't throw up their hands. They were cuffed.
And while a dozen players sat at tables, four worked their cards while seated in cages the size of bathroom stalls.
The setting was the State Correctional Institution Greene’s new Diversionary Treatment Unit, or DTU, a 24-man block that houses the worst-behaved of the mentally ill prisoners at the highest-level penitentiary in Pennsylvania.
The treatment of mentally ill convicts in prisons, and then the follow-up when they are released, devours increasing amounts of attention and money in the state and many counties.
Housing inmates in the intensively staffed DTU, where they spend at least three hours per day out of their cells, rather than in 23-hour-a-day solitary confinement, is “a bit more costly, but the good far outweighs it," said Superintendent Robert Gilmore, as he watched the bingo game. "Our goal is to get these folks back out into general population. … How do you put a cost on that?"
Read More
The number of state prisoners classified as seriously mentally ill has quadrupled since 2013. It now exceeds 4,000, or nearly 9 percent of the total inmate population — including more than one in four female inmates. Discipline of those inmates is the subject of a year-old settlement agreement in a federal court case.
The vast majority will leave prison one day and face few open doors on the outside. State-funded programs, tapped by Allegheny, Beaver and Greene counties, among others, aim to start addressing the scarcity of housing options for released, mentally ill felons.
For Caroline DeNome, 56, who receives rental assistance through TRAILS Ministries of Beaver County, stable housing is integral to her plans for turning her life around after 25 months in a string of prisons and halfway houses for violating her probation in a forgery and theft by deception case. She battles depression and anxiety along with a history of drug use.
“I don’t ever want to live like I lived before,” she said. “I don’t ever want to go back to that way of life.”
Therapy and discipline
SCI Greene is a 44-acre, 33-building town where all residents are criminals and one in three is mentally ill.
The prison’s 1,750 inmates include 270 who are on the so-called D Roster, meaning they have serious mental illnesses. Another 320 on the C Roster also get psychiatric services.
John Donato, a psychological services specialist at the prison, formerly worked at the Somerset State Hospital, a psychiatric facility that closed in 1996. He attributed some of the increase in prison mental health rosters to the closure of hospitals, adding that the state ”is taking major steps in providing services for these people.”
Most of the seriously mentally ill inmates at SCI Greene live in one building, amid walls they painted. Captain America and Alice in Wonderland are among the themes. As such labor-intensive units have proliferated, the department has boosted psychological staffing from 199 employees statewide in 2012 to 287 now.
Sue Cowan, a former elementary school teacher who manages SCI Greene’s main mental health unit, said her clientele range from thieves to murderers. They get therapy plus classes in Spanish, art, gym, sign language, fatherhood skills and yoga, plus weekly “pet therapy” with puppies training to be service dogs.
“You still have to have discipline,” she added, “or you have chaos.”
“We have some very disruptive individuals here” in the prison system, said Corrections Secretary John Wetzel. He added that solitary confinement wasn’t helping seriously mentally ill inmates. "We had to change the experience so as not to make the individual worse.”
Now, when a mentally ill inmate acts out, the psych staff helps to decide on discipline that ranges from a two-hour “timeout” in an empty cell to a 15-day stint in the DTU.
Over the summer, the prison transformed one wing of its disciplinary building into the DTU. Unlike the noisy, smelly wings where prisoners endure solitary confinement, the DTU during bingo hour seemed clean and orderly.
“We want them [in DTU] for as short a time as possible,” said Mr. Gilmore. Once the inmate is stabilized, perhaps through medicine and therapy, he is returned to Ms. Cowan’s building. If the inmate doesn’t adapt, he is transferred out of SCI Greene to prisons with more intensive mental health units.
Too much time alone
SCI Greene’s DTU is one result of the state’s settlement with the Disability Rights Network. According to the network’s 2013 lawsuit, mentally ill prisoners had made up one-third of the inmates in solitary confinement. Seven of the lawsuit’s 12 plaintiffs tried or threatened suicide.
The settlement protects D Roster inmates from 23-hour-a-day solitary confinement, requires regular mental health evaluations for any prisoner in long-term solitary confinement and demands better record-keeping, planning and training.
Kathryn A. Burns, a public health doctor chosen to monitor the settlement, wrote in a Jan. 25 report that the state's effort was "impressive," confirming that there are now no D Roster inmates in 23-hour-a-day solitary in the state.

PG graphic: Numbers rise
(Click image for larger version)
Some prisoners accuse prison officials of selectively shifting them from the D Roster to the less-protected C Roster. Mr. Wetzel said that the department today isn’t shifting inmates off of the protected D Roster “even if they’re stable.”
Dr. Burns, though, wrote that "these changes [are] occurring -- and the documentation of the rationale to support the change was lacking."
Ronald Banks, 51, who is serving life at SCI Greene for third-degree murder, wrote in letters to the Post-Gazette that he was switched in 2008 from the D Roster to the C Roster. Disciplinary action has landed him in solitary confinement, which, he wrote, “has led to me hearing imaginary voices that encourage me to physically harm myself; triggered physically self-destructive behavior with sharp objects; caused me to have blackout spells, hallucinations, paranoia.”
Banks wrote that his time in the hole led to “a suicide attempt by self-mutilation ... and hanging up by bed sheet around [my] neck from a cell vent.”
“Once you start from the proposition that [solitary confinement] is cruel or inhumane, the question is, what do you do?” asked Jules Lobel, a University of Pittsburgh law school professor and president of the New York City-based Center for Constitutional Rights. He represented California inmates — accused gang members placed indefinitely in solitary confinement — in a lawsuit settled in September. “I think we're going to see the ending of prolonged solitary confinement within five years.”
President Barack Obama last month banned solitary confinement of juveniles in federal prisons and reduced its use for mentally ill inmates.
At SCI Greene, there are still 240 inmates (though none from D Roster) in solitary confinement. Though some are among the prison’s 525 inmates serving life or death sentences, others will be free someday.
Mr. Skakalski noted that in years past, mentally ill inmates “would max out of their sentence, sometimes straight from solitary confinement right on to the street. Then they’d re-offend, and they’re right back in solitary confinement again.”
Re-entering society
In August 2011, police arrested Mary Mertes for assaulting a woman and stabbing a man outside a Greene County bar.
After nine months in the county jail, her troubles were far from over. Homeless, she stayed on friends’ and relatives’ couches and occasionally slept in her car.
Last spring, Greene County Human Services placed her in a studio apartment, subsidizing her rent with funding from the Pennsylvania Commission on Crime and Delinquency. In all, the two-year, $50,000-a-year grant from PCCD will enable the county to provide housing assistance to as many as seven clients — all ex-offenders with mental illness, substance abuse problems or both — at a time.
“It’s literally taken me off the streets and given me a second chance,” Ms. Mertes, 51, said. The goal is for Ms. Mertes eventually to take over rent payments.
Without the help, she said, “I’d probably be back in my old life of drinking and drugging. … I could be dead or I could be couch-surfing still.”
Criminal justice officials increasingly are spending money on programs and services outside of jail and prison walls because offenders — especially those with mental illness — are likely to get into trouble again if left to fend for themselves as soon as they are released. Housing is a key component of so-called “re-entry” programs because it provides stability, enabling offenders to focus on other challenges.
Ms. Mertes now has her sobriety, control of her depression and a housekeeping job at a local hotel. “Things are coming together,” she said.
But available funding doesn’t come close to covering all of those who might benefit from the assistance.
“We have a waiting list right now for people to get in. I think we have two or three people on it,” said Jeff Wilson, forensic re-entry specialist for the county.
Uncooperative landlords
Even with money in hand, caseworkers say, they have to beat the bushes to find landlords willing to take in clients who often have bad credit histories and limited income on top of criminal records.
Norman Grayson’s second chance sputtered at first because of housing.
In 2013, after a four-year stint in state prisons for robbery, he was eager to leave a Downtown halfway house for life on his own. But he spent nearly a year looking for a place to live because his criminal record, poverty and mental illness left him with few options.
Mr. Grayson first found communal housing in the Hill District. When Mr. Grayson decided he wanted a place of his own, the East Liberty-based Adaptive Behavioral Services helped him win over a city Housing Authority that balked at admitting him.
Today, Mr. Grayson has an apartment at the housing authority’s Northview Heights complex. He has a commercial driver’s license. He’s a deacon at Solid Rock Church in Knoxville.
“Now, I got Christian people in my life instead of just negative people all the time,” said Mr. Grayson, 53, whose rent is based on the Supplemental Security Income he receives. The housing, he said, boosted his self-esteem.
Sex offenders are the most difficult to place in housing, but Karen Florence, executive director of TRAILS Ministries, said she’s struggled to house men convicted of a range of offenses. Ms. Florence, whose agency has been tasked with placing about 45 offenders in state-subsidized housing on behalf of the Department of Corrections, said she has clients who “lost everything” and no longer pose a danger.
Greene County has less housing stock than more populated parts of the state, and in recent years, landlords there preferred to rent to an influx of Marcellus shale workers. With gas-field business down, the housing market has loosened, and county human services director Karen Bennett said she is building rapport with some owners by providing funds for property rehabilitation.
As Mr. Grayson learned, public housing authorities can be far from welcoming. More than once, Kevin Jordan, a founder of Adaptive Behavioral, has squared off against housing officials on behalf of clients who are worth a gamble.
Though criticized for its tough stance, the authority is partnering with Duquesne University School of Law to explore the possibility of helping residents expunge juvenile records that can bar, or get them evicted, from authority complexes. The authority and the law school’s new Juvenile Defender Clinic have applied for a $100,000 federal grant to fund the service.
Tiffany Sizemore-Thompson, assistant clinical professor, said a family can be precluded from public housing regardless of which member has the juvenile record. While Pennsylvania law allows many juvenile offenses to be expunged, people may not know that, understand the implications or be able to afford for it to be expunged.
“Something as simple as a misdemeanor can really derail someone’s life in a really profound way,” she said. The clinic provides more than ”bare-bones legal representation,” she said, noting that social work students are available to connect clients with employment resources, mental health assistance or other services.
Customized care
An offender’s determination is key to managing mental health, avoiding substance abuse and returning to prison.
“Fear is a big thing,” Ms. DeNome said. “Fear leaves you stuck. I’m trying to overcome my fears.”
To boost the odds of success, caseworkers tailor treatment and services to individual circumstances.
Mr. Jordan said his agency matches black offenders with black therapists to avoid cultural barriers to treatment. Mr. Wilson said a previous re-entry program in his county wasn’t as successful as hoped because housing wasn’t paired with the right mix of other services. Ms. Florence recently turned down an apartment in the McKees Rocks area because she feared the neighborhood would be too tough for her meek client.
“I think she would have gotten eaten up there,” Ms. Florence said.
Ms. Florence is trying to help Ms. DeNome get home to Lawrence County.
Ms. DeNome’s 25 months in the penal system interrupted payments on a line of credit that was paying for an Ellwood City house that has been in her family for four generations. She’s trying to save enough money to get the payments back on track.
In the meantime, her job at McDonald’s has started an income stream, and TRAILS Ministries is covering her rent at a place a friend owns in New Brighton. She’s enjoying time alone after living with other women for 25 months.
“I want to be joyous, happy and free,” she said.
Rich Lord: rlord@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1542. Joe Smydo: jsmydo@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1548.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.