Shouting erupted after Heather Seidel told her endocrinologist about a new diet that resulted in normal blood-glucose levels. Her doctor wasn’t happy. She said the diet could cause sugar levels too low for safety.
“You’re going to fry your brain,” the doctor shouted at her, according to the 33-year-old critical care nurse from McCandless who has type 1 diabetes. “She was very hostile. I was trying to explain it to her, and she was screaming over me.”
Welcome to modern-day medicine, where patients are taking active control of their health based on the Internet, Facebook and other available medical sources, including some not confirmed by science. Physicians now are being asked to embrace “patient-centered” medicine with “shared decision-making” to help avoid patient anxiety and improve outcomes.
Numerous studies say this team approach is beneficial through improved communication with patients. But it also means doctors must spend more time with patients while ceding some control over what drugs and treatments they prescribe.
Ms. Seidel said her low-carbohydrate/high-fat diet resulted in normal blood-sugar levels for the first time since her diagnosis 21 years ago, with fewer low blood sugar episodes. Her diet is officially accepted in Sweden.
“I switched endocrinologists,” she said. “At first, the new doctor was leery when I told her what I eat. But she was open to it.”
Read More
Pace and persistence
The Penn State College of Medicine in Hershey announced last week that its medical students now are receiving training in patient-centered medicine, as one of 11 schools updating physician training with American Medical Association support.
First-year medical students will function as “patient navigators” to help patients better understand their health problems, medical procedures and the health-care system. The goal is to transform traditional physician-centered medicine, with the doctor doing all the talking and decision-making, to a patient-centered system that fully involves the patient in each decision, at each stage of care.
Such training is necessary because patient activism in the doctor’s office “is more a function of a doctor’s personality than anything else,” said Donald J. Cegala, communications professor emeritus at Ohio State University, whose research focuses on improved communication between doctor and patient.
He recommends that patients follow his PACE program, an acronym for (P)roviding full information about your health problems to the doctor, (A)sking questions, (C)hecking or repeating a doctor’s instructions to make sure you understand them correctly, and (E)xpressing full concern about health problems you are experiencing.
PACE, he said, especially is pertinent to cancer, menopause, pediatrics and heart failure, among others.
“The tendency for physicians is that they want to control the interview, and that’s understandable for reasons of time and educational differences,” said Mr. Cegala, who has a Ph.D. in communications. “But if a physician invests just a couple minutes not talking and listening to what the patient is saying, it is good for the patient and the physician.”
That way, he said, a doctor can pick up hints of what the patient is reluctant to discuss. While that’s the ideal, “the medical establishment is pretty hard to change.”
“Patients need to be persistent and as well-informed as they can be,” he said. “Unfortunately, there is a lot of junk as well as a lot of good stuff on the Internet.”
People in their 80s and 20s are more deferential to doctors. Baby boomers typically are more active patients, leading to the new dynamic in the doctor’s office. “It’s really important for patients to take responsibility for their own health care and be as informed as they can be and express their concerns to the physician,” Mr. Cegala said.
Ginger and spice
Diana Karlinsey, 48, of Camp Hill, Cumberland County, started having pain and swelling in her wrist, then in her hips and knees.
Based on blood work, her physician diagnosed inflammatory arthritis and prescribed voltaren. A rheumatologist, she said, confirmed the diagnosis.
By then, however, she’d already read books that advised using ginger or ginger supplements to treat joint pain — an anti-inflammatory the Arthritis Foundation also recommends. With other dietary changes, Ms. Karlinsey no longer has pain and quit taking the medication. Her rheumatologist, however, would not acknowledge the success of her self-treatment.
“I told the doctor I was not taking the drug and was using natural substances to treat the pain, and he was skeptical and said, ‘I suspect you just had a virus that was causing your symptoms, and you are over the virus now.’ ”
Informed and assertive
Scott Shapiro, a Montgomery County cardiologist who’s the new president of the Pennsylvania Medical Society, said he follows the new protocol, recommending a healthy diet and exercise to improve heart function along with fish oil, calcium and vitamin D supplements. He also refers patients to nutritionists.
As long as the patient isn’t using supplements potentially dangerous to health, he said, he’s open minded. Doctor-patient interaction succeeds, he said, when a patient better understands the treatment and its potential impact on health.
“Many things have changed in the past 10 to 15 years, and the Internet more than anything has engaged the patient in learning about and discussing health care,” Dr. Shapiro said. “It gives them a way to research their conditions and interact with physicians.”
Douglas Post, professor of family and internal medicine in the division of cancer prevention and control at Ohio State, continues developing methods to teach breast-cancer patients how to discuss their pain, depression and fatigue with physicians.
“There is good data out there that says when you are engaged and involved with your care, you do better when you are sick,” he said. “Part of our work involves teaching patients to be more assertive and open to talking to doctors. A lot of times doctors are antagonistic and not open. Patients are changing to some degree, but are still reticent, and there are barriers because they know how busy doctors are.”
But shared decision-making is “a hot topic that cuts across many areas of medicine, especially in cancer screening,” said Kenneth L. Kehl, a fellow in hematology and oncology at M.D. Anderson Cancer Center in Houston. “We’ve established that shared decision-making is what we should do for patients so they are as satisfied as possible with their care and translate that to the delivery of science-based care to optimize outcomes.”
Ready for battle
Both 29, Stephanie Joyce Winter of Fort Riley, Kan., and her twin sister, Alisa Craft, of Salem, Westmoreland County, were diagnosed with type 1 diabetes four years ago. Each has faced an ordeal with endocrinologists who, they say, have refused to adjust their insulin doses or change treatment regimens despite their constant battles with low blood sugar.
Ms. Winter was eating Pop-Tarts continuously while Ms. Craft was chowing down candy bars.
“When I would go there and state my opinion, the doctor would say ‘No. This is normal. This is what diabetes is’ ” and command her to remain on the same insulin dose and high-carb diet, Ms. Craft said.
Finally, Ms. Winter, who is studying nutrition, adopted the high-protein, low-carb diet from the book “Diabetes Solutions” recommended on the Typeonegrit Facebook page. She schooled her sister on the diet once her own blood sugars reached the normal range, with only rare episodes of low blood sugar. Ms. Craft said her levels now are moving ever closer to normal, also with fewer blood-sugar problems.
“I told my endocrinologist about my diet, and he told me I was being radical and that I had an obsession, but actually I’m motivated and dedicated,” Ms. Craft said. “They don’t want to hear what I have to say. So I listen to my sister. She’s my ‘endocrinologist.’ ”
Because Ms. Winter expects confrontations with her doctor, she said she’s seeking a new one.
“We want to work with doctors and want to be in good health, and want to learn from them what is best for us,” she said. “We have a long road ahead for us with our health. If you don’t have a doctor on your team, it’s not going to work.”
David Templeton: dtempleton@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1578.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.