Federal lawmakers and families of victims of the Legionnaires’ disease outbreak at the Veterans Affairs Pittsburgh Healthcare System in 2011 and 2012 say they have significant questions about a federal investigation that found few problems with the testing for Legionella bacteria in patients and water at the hospital.

“It looks like they looked for the information they wanted, to get the results they wanted to get,” said Judy Nicklas, daughter-in-law of William Nicklas, 87, of Hampton, the last of six veterans who died after contracting Legionnaires’ at the hospital during the outbreak.

Reps. Tim Murphy, R-Upper St. Clair, and Keith Rothfus, R-Sewickley, as well as Sen. Bob Casey, D-Pa., all said they had problems with the way the VA Office of Inspector General conducted the investigation and believe it should have been more thorough.

“If everything was done great, why did people die and people get sick?” Mr. Murphy said. “This looks like a very brief report that could have been written in a few minutes after a cursory review of a few records.”

Advertise with us

The outbreak in 2011 and 2012 led to at least 22 veterans contracting the water-borne Legionnaires’ disease.

The report, released Tuesday by the inspector general, examined an allegation by a former Pittsburgh VA employee that there were delays in getting test results back on patients suspected of having Legionnaires’ disease that may have affected their treatment.

The probe also looked into an allegation that VA employees had tried after the outbreak to manipulate tests on water by letting it run before testing it for Legionella, in the hope of getting more negative results.

The report found little fault on the first allegation — saying only three of the 31 patient cases reviewed had delays in reporting the test results and that nothing delayed treatment — and none with the water-testing allegation.

The Pittsburgh VA, which has been pilloried over the outbreak since it was revealed in November 2012, was pleased with the findings.

Advertise with us

“This report is — by and large — a positive reminder that we are moving in the right direction,” Barbara Forsha, the Pittsburgh VA’s interim director, said Tuesday.

But the families, their attorneys and lawmakers pointed out what they said were several obvious flaws in the investigation:

• The investigators, who refer in the report to the “2012 outbreak,” only looked at the data on the six patients who died and all other patients from 2012 through 2014 who tested positive for Legionnaire’s — even though the outbreak began in 2011 and at least 12 additional people tested positive that year.

• The conclusion that there was “no evidence of delays in treatment for patients” is disputed by two of the families that have their loved ones’ medical records.

• While finding that three of 31 patient test results were delayed, the report makes no mention of the “batch” system of testing that the Pittsburgh VA itself said caused multiple delays in reporting those results during the outbreak. The system required five or more urine antigen samples to be collected before the samples were tested, frequently causing delays of two or three days. The VA said in February 2013 that after it discovered the role the batch system played in the outbreak, it was no longer used.

Advertise with us

• The inspector general did not include any data on the patients referred to in the report, or the water records, making it impossible to review and compare them to what is known about the cases from 2012.

“Why not share all the data they have now, if they have nothing to hide?” Mr. Murphy said, adding that he also was upset because he met with Ms. Forsha last week and she did not mention the report was going to be released. “I guess we’ll continue to have to view VA Pittsburgh as we did before: That they operate under a veil of secrecy and cannot be trusted to be transparent.”

Pittsburgh VA spokesman Michael Marcus said Ms. Forsha did not tell Mr. Murphy about the report because only the inspector general’s office could release it.

Not reviewing the 2011 data on other patients also stood out to Maureen Ciarolla, daughter of the first victim of the outbreak, John Ciarolla, 83, of North Versailles.

“Why would they just go back to 2012? We know all that went back to 2011 and earlier. My father’s death was in July 2011 and there were other patients that year, too, and Legionella levels were high even before 2010,” Ms. Ciarolla said. “It’s a joke. It’s truly a joke.”

Advertise with us

Mr. Casey also was struck by that omission.

“While I appreciate the IG’s continued attention into this issue, the report does raise additional questions,” Mr. Casey said. “It’s important for any review to track closely to the time when concerns were first raised, which would be 2011.”

Attorneys for the Ciarolla and Nicklas families said delays in getting treatment were part of lawsuits they filed against the VA and later settled out of court.

Douglas Price, the Nicklas family attorney, said there was a two-day delay in getting Mr. Nicklas’ urine antigen test because the test was lost and had to be retaken. Medical records showed he had been on a general, oral antibiotic, but when his doctor found out the urine antigen test came back positive for Legionella on Nov. 21, 2012, he was put on another antibiotic more effective against Legionella. He died two days later.

The delay “played a role in his death,” Mr. Price said.

Advertise with us

John Zervanos, who represented the Ciarollas, said medical records showed that Mr. Ciarolla had antibiotics administered before he was given the urine antigen test, but they were stopped after a day. The test was taken a day later, but results took three days to come back because of the batch system. Only then were antibiotics restarted. He was placed on a ventilator two days later and died July 18, 2011.

“Had they addressed the problem immediately and had they not delayed his treatment, I think you can make the argument he would not have passed away,” Mr. Zervanos said.

Mr. Rothfus said in an emailed statement that he was upset to learn from the Nicklas family that investigators never contacted the families because “they might have information and evidence that would further the investigation. The failure to do so raises questions about the completeness of the report.”

Sean D. Hamill: shamill@post-gazette.com or 412-263-2579.