For at least 20 years it had been the gold standard.

The copper-silver ionization water disinfection system, when properly maintained, had proven time and time again that it could prevent the spread of Legionella bacteria in systems serving hospitals and other institutions.

That was until two years ago, when Veterans Affairs Pittsburgh Healthcare System blamed its copper-silver system for the Legionnaires’ disease outbreak there that sickened at least 22 veterans, six of whom died.

“Our existing copper-silver ionization system — which reduces the presence of Legionella in water — may not be as effective as previously thought, as is the case in other health systems using this method,” the VA wrote in a press release on Nov, 16, 2012. “Consequently, we are shifting to a chlorination system to ensure better control.”

Advertise with us

But two internal reports and two VA Inspector General reports later found that the outbreak was due to poor management generally and poor maintenance of the copper-silver system specifically — not that the copper-silver system itself had failed.

That meant concerns over the copper-silver system were over, right?

Not so fast.

Despite those investigations, over the past two years the VA has continued to try to peg the outbreak to the disinfection system, leading the Allegheny County Health Department, Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection, the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency and the VA’s own Legionella Expert Work Group — all which have a role in determining what disinfectants private or public building operators can use in their water systems — to take actions to diminish, question or throw suspicion on copper-silver systems.

The drumbeat of questions from these agencies has had a noticeable impact on the two companies that sell the bulk of copper-silver systems in use in the United States, including one in the Pittsburgh area.

Advertise with us

“We’re looking at a loss of at least $2 million in business over the last two years,” said Tory Schira, chief operating officer of Liquitech Environmental Solutions of Lombard, Ill.

Neil Silverberg, owner of Enrich Products of Wilkinsburg, said at least four Pennsylvania institutions that were considering using copper-silver backed off after the various government agencies began raising questions, causing him at least a six-figure loss.

Unfounded doubts?

Copper-silver — which uses electrical charges to spur copper and silver ions into water, killing Legionella — is considered by experts as the most effective of the water disinfectant technologies because it is less corrosive to pipes than other systems such as those using chlorine, and has the ability to get into the biofilm, or sludge, in pipes where Legionella can hide.

Despite that, there are signs that governmental agencies and institutions are backing away from copper-silver:

Advertise with us

• The Allegheny County Health Department — which used to encourage the use of copper-silver — last month wrote up new Legionella control guidelines that say that copper-silver does not have all the necessary registration and gave it a less-than-enthusiastic review compared to other technologies.

• The Pennsylvania DEP declared in the last year that it would not issue permits for installation of copper-silver until it met the state’s own still-undecided-level of efficacy.

• The U.S. EPA said it needed to spend a year creating a “guidance” document on Legionella technologies to help states oversee their use — a document that now has Pennsylvania waiting to see what it says before it OKs copper-silver.

• And the VA came out with new Legionella guidelines for its hospitals that does not even mention copper-silver, even though copper-silver is the most widely used technology in place in VA medical centers across the nation for the treatment of Legionella and has glowing reviews from them.

The VA even trumpeted its changeover from copper-silver to chlorine at the Pittsburgh VA just last week in a statement supporting its appointment of a former Pittsburgh VA official to the top post at the Erie VA — a fact that angered U.S. Rep. Jeff Miller, R-Fla., the chairman of the House Committee on Veterans’ Affairs.

Advertise with us

“From initially covering up the outbreak, to repeatedly misleading the public and Congress about its root cause, the VA’s efforts in this matter have been designed to deflect responsibility for a tragedy created and facilitated by VA’s own inaction, mismanagement and incompetence,” he said in a statement. “It’s well past time for VA to admit what numerous department reviews and independent examinations have already found: that the outbreak was caused by human error — not the failure of any water treatment system.”

In other developments, UPMC recently decided to pull its copper-silver systems from four of its buildings — Montefiore, Presbyterian, Shadyside and Hillman Cancer Center — and replace them with monochloramine systems, but said it was not because of any government action.

Enrich’s Mr. Silverberg, whose company works with UPMC on maintaining its copper and silver flow cells, worries other hospitals will see UPMC’s switch as responding to the state’s actions.

Liquitech and Enrich are also still dealing with the fallout from that first VA press release in 2012.

“Our chemical competitors have taken that statement and trumpeted it way beyond Pennsylvania,” Mr. Schira said.

Advertise with us

The competitors include companies that sell not just chlorine — like the system the Pittsburgh VA installed — but also chlorine-dioxide and monochloramine systems that are also used to kill Legionella in water. There are other methods – including ultraviolet light and ozone – but copper-silver, chlorine, chlorine-dioxide and monochloramine continue to be the most popular, particularly in hospital buildings where the threat of a Legionnaires’ outbreak is most serious because of patients with weaker immune systems.

Regulations increase

While copper-silver systems had been widely used since the mid-1990s, and regularly proven effective in peer-reviewed scientific journals, it had not gone through full federal review because it was considered to be a “device” that did not need EPA approval.

But in 2007 the EPA decided to reclassify copper-silver systems as a “pesticide” that needed federal registration.

Enrich and Liquitech began the federal registration process in 2008 and 2009, and both were allowed to continue selling their systems while EPA reviewed their application. Both were approved last year as a pesticide that was safe to use and effective against Legionella.

Advertise with us

In the aftermath of the Pittsburgh VA outbreak, however, the EPA also decided to change the working definition of large buildings, like hospitals, from a “secondary” drinking water source that required less oversight, to a “primary” drinking water source, like municipal water authorities that require much more oversight.

What that meant in practice was that any large building that decided it was going to install copper-silver now fell under the federal Safe Drinking Water Act, which is overseen primarily by state administrators in departments like the Pennsylvania DEP.

That might sound like technical minutiae. But it meant that the copper-silver companies now had to deal with potentially 50 different interpretations of the Safe Drinking Water Act, because it allows states to impose its own laws, as long as they are at least as stringent as the federal law.

Both Enrich and Liquitech have been undergoing the tedious work to get approval in all but two states: Nevada and Pennsylvania, and the administrator in Nevada said she would work with them, Mr. Silverberg said.

“Pennsylvania has been something else altogether,” he said.

Advertise with us

Since at least the first quarter of this year, Pennsylvania’s Safe Drinking Water Act administrator Lisa Daniels, who works for the state DEP, has been telling building administrators, infection control people and others that her office would not issue permits for copper-silver until the companies reached an undetermined efficacy standard set by a third-party.

But the companies quickly found that there was no third-party with an efficacy standard they could even apply for. More recently, Ms. Daniels has told both companies she wants to wait until EPA completes its guidance document for Legionella technologies, which could be completed next summer or even later.

Mr. Silverberg said that recently he called Ms. Daniels to complain that her action was harming his business.

Asked about this stance, DEP said in emailed answers to questions that it has not received any application for installation of copper-silver systems, but: “Drinking water systems have the freedom to choose what treatment technology they wish to pursue, so long as it meets all state and federal standards.”

Steve Schira, owner of Liquitech and Tory Schira’s father, said having one state as a roadblock is not the sole concern.

Advertise with us

Like the original VA press release, he said, what he is worries about is “this could spread to other states who might wonder why Pennsylvania is not allowing us in.”

Sean D. Hamill: shamill@post-gazette.com or 412-263-2579