It’s not suicide.

That’s the stance of two Pennsylvanian legislators who recently entered bills into the state House and Senate (explore below) proposing a law similar to Oregon’s Death with Dignity Act, which permits terminally ill adult Oregonians to obtain from their doctor and self-administer a lethal dose of medication.

It allowed Brittany Maynard — a vibrant, outspoken 29-year-old with terminal brain cancer — to die Nov. 1 in her home.

“This is someone who is dying,” said Pennsylvania Sen. Daylin Leach, D-Montgomery. “Do they want to die in their home with their family, or do they want to die connected to tubes, at 3 o'clock in the morning, alone in a hospital?”

Advertise with us

Mr. Leach first introduced Death With Dignity legislation in 2008, when he was a member of the state House. Since 2009, he has introduced it every Senate session. Senate Bill 1032 was introduced June 24, 2013, and state Rep. Mark Rozzi, D-Berks, introduced House Bill 2548 on Oct. 15.

The bills won’t come up for a vote before the two-year legislative session ends in December, but the legislators plan to introduce them again next year. Both bills have built-in safeguards, such as requiring that two doctors certify the patient has fewer than 6 months to live, and the patient must request the medication.

Read More

But the legislators know opponents such as the Pennsylvania Catholic Conference, the public affairs arm of state’s Catholic bishops and dioceses, are out there. Amy Hill, spokesperson for the conference, said it has expressed opposition in the past.

“Assisted-suicide, or whatever they would call it, is intentionally killing yourself or helping someone else and is immoral,” she said. “Life is worth something at every stage.”

Such laws diminish the important end-of-life considerations of palliative care and pain management, she said.

Advertise with us

“We should give people the chance to have … fond farewells in a way that respects the natural order,” Ms. Hill said.

Robert Arnold, assistant medical director of palliative care for the Institute for Quality Improvement at UPMC, said if legislators are trying to make Pennsylvania a place where people can spend their last days comfortably, Death With Dignity legislation won’t have the biggest impact. He hopes for legislation of Physician Orders for Life-Sustaining Treatment, commonly referred to as POLST.

Marian Kemp, a nurse and the POLST coordinator for Pennsylvania, said a POLST form is a way for patients to express their end-of-life decisions. More important than that form, though, is the conversation about treatment options, she said. The goal is for the bright pink POLST form to accompany patients between care settings, Ms. Kemp said.

Since 2000, it has been used as a standard of care and respected here, but in other states, POLST is legislated and must be followed, she said.

Dr. Arnold said he hopes families and patients making end-of-life decisions will talk frankly with their doctors about what the future may bring.

Advertise with us

A Gallup poll earlier this year showed support of end-of-life choices is connected to religious beliefs: 48 percent of Americans who attend weekly religious services favor Death With Dignity laws, compared with 82 percent support among those who go to religious services less often.

The poll showed that about 7 of 10 Americans believe physicians should be able to legally “end [a] patient's life by some painless means.” But words matter: when it’s called doctor-assisted suicide, only 58 percent of Americans favor it.

Barbara Mancini, 58, of Philadelphia was arrested and charged with assisting suicide after handing her 93-year-old terminally ill father his morphine, and he drank the partly filled bottle in February 2013. He died four days later of pneumonia. A Schuylkill County judge dismissed the case against her early this year.

Ms.Mancini now works for the nonprofit Compassion & Choices, which supports aid-in-dying options. A Death With Dignity law would have helped her family, she said.

“People who are dying should have a right to choose how they go out,” she said. “It's a matter of freedom and liberty.”

Advertise with us

Vermont and Washington also have Death With Dignity laws, and in Montana, there is no law against physician-assisted suicide, according to the Death With Dignity National Center. Bills also have been introduced in at least six other states.

“Inevitably, it will happen in Pennsylvania,” Mr. Leach said. Mr. Rozzi recommends constituents talk to their local legislators if they want a Death With Dignity option.

Oregon’s act is the nation’s oldest and was enacted in 1997. Since then, 1,173 Oregonians were prescribed a life-ending medication, such as Secobarbital or Pentobarbital, and 752 died after taking it, according to Oregon Health Authority records. Not all patients who seek the medication take it.

“They get the medication in case their dying process becomes too unbearable. But if it doesn't, they don't take it,” Compassion & Choices spokesman Sean Crowley said. “It’s proof positive that they’re not suicidal.”

The number of people who received a prescription has typically increased each year, from 24 in 1998 to 122 in 2013, when 71 people ingested the medicine, down from the highest number, 85, the year before.

Advertise with us

Most of the 71 people who died from the medication in 2013 were older than 65, enrolled in hospice, had at least a baccalaureate degree and had cancer, the state said. Their three most-cited, end-of-life concerns were a loss of autonomy, decreasing ability to participate in activities that made life enjoyable and a loss of dignity. Most died at home.

Among 11 people whose doctors were present when they took the medicine, they became unconscious within 25 minutes and died between 5 minutes and more than 5 hours after ingestion.

Six patients since 1997 have regained consciousness after ingesting the medicine.

According to the Oregon Health Authority, that happened once in 2012, when “the patient regained consciousness two days following ingestion but remained minimally responsive and died six days following ingestion” of underlying illness. That death — and the one in 2005 and two each in 2010 and 2011 — isn’t included in the 752 people who died after ingesting the medicine.

Possible medication tolerance, incomplete ingestion and regurgitation were cited as causes for the 2010 and 2011 instances.

Lexi Belculfine: lbelculfine@ post-gazette.com, 412-263-1878 or on Twitter @LexiBelc.