Hundreds gathered at St. Paul Cathedral in Oakland Monday night for a Mass celebrating the selection of Pope Leo XIV as the new head of the Catholic Church.

Diocese of Pittsburgh Bishop David Zubik led the service dressed in white and light blue vestments and began the Mass with a procession to the altar with about two dozen clergy members.

The service comes after Chicago-born Cardinal Robert Prevost, now known as Pope Leo XIV, was selected by the conclave on Thursday to be the 267th pope in the history of the Catholic Church, becoming the first American-born cardinal to do so.

“So last Thursday, what a day,” Bishop Zubik said in his homily. “It ended up becoming much more than we even hoped it would be. Where were you when you got the news? The white smoke billowing from the Sistine Chapel, the bells of St. Peter’s Basilica, beginning to ring, confirmed that a vote had been taken and successfully chosen a new Holy Father.”

Advertise with us

Bishop Zubik said that in the nearly 90 minutes it took between the confirmation that the conclave had selected a pope and the moment in which his identity was revealed, he recounted the papacies of the eight popes he had witnessed through his lifetime, beginning with Pope Pius XII and ending with Pope Francis, who died on April 21.

He went on to recount the moment Pope Leo XIV was selected.

“Then in that hour and fifteen minutes [after the announcement a pope had been selected] our eyes were focused on the loggia. … We have a pope and history was made again. There Leo XIV came on that loggia as an American, as a Chicagoan, as a Peruvian, as a missionary, as an Augustinian, and certainly in the baseball season, we best not forget, a White Sox fan.”

With the mention of Pope Leo XIV’s White Sox fandom, the audience broke out into laughter.

“I think, our sisters and brothers, we spend a heck of a lot of time in our day-to-day lives sizing people up and defining them by their various characteristics as I’ve just done about the eight popes in my lifetime, but it seems to me that tonight we need to focus on the ‘who’ our Holy Father is, the ‘who’ of Leo XIV,” he said.

Advertise with us

Bishop Zubik went on to urge those in attendance to refrain from labeling others, particularly Pope Leo.

“Isn’t it so true that we make so many judgments about each other and so many judgments about public figures that we sometimes miss the forest for the trees about what their role in the world and their role in our lives is said to be,” he said. “Our dear Pope Leo very clearly shows how he is embracing the role that has been given to him by none other than the Holy Spirit because his election was, in fact, the call of God.”

Bishop Zubik also highlighted Pope Leo XIV’s episcopal motto: “In Illo uno unum,” meaning “In the One, we are one.”

“May what his motto speaks to us reside in our hearts so that you and I, members of our church and beyond, can tear down walls, build bridges and pave the way that ultimately leads to God’s kingdom in heaven,” he said.

Following the Mass, Bernice Dumitru, 83, of Brookline, said she was feeling hopeful about the papacy of Pope Leo and approved of his selection by the conclave.

Advertise with us

“I get the sense that he is a holy man,” she said. “He has served the church a lot as a missionary, in Peru, and his community and I just sense that there’s an openness to God’s guidance. … I’m thanking God for giving us the Holy Father.”

It was not just Catholics in attendance. A handful of interfaith leaders, including those from Pittsburgh’s Jewish community, were also in attendance, as they were at the service celebrating the life of Pope Francis.

“This is a day of celebration for my Catholic friends,” Rabbi Daniel Fellman, senior rabbi from Temple Sinai said. “Just as we were together to mourn the loss of Pope Francis, it’s important to be together when we celebrate Pope Leo…The pope talked about building bridges in Pittsburgh, we know something about building bridges and we know something about the importance of bridges and I’m part of the rabbi and priest dialogue that I find very powerful. I think it's essential.”