The election of the first American pope in the 2,000-year history of the Roman Catholic Church brought worldwide celebration last week, joyfulness that could be felt in Western Pennsylvania.
At Holy Rosary Church in near Southpointe, Washington County, the news that Chicago-born Cardinal Robert Prevost, now known as Pope Leo XIV, would lead a global Catholic population brought more than excitement. It ushered in hope.
“I would say that there’s definitely going to be an uptick in people coming back to church and people getting fascinated,” said the Rev. Jay Donahue of Holy Rosary’s St. Oscar Romero Parish.
As the church enters its next chapter, some believe Catholic communities throughout the region are poised for a resurgence under the 267th pope. The idea of a White Sox fan from the South Side of Chicago leading the 1.4 billion Catholics across the globe feels relatable.
“He’s one of ours,” Rev. Donahue said.
The Catholic Diocese of Pittsburgh has struggled with a declining membership for years. With Catholics comprising nearly 45% of the Greater Pittsburgh population in the 1980s, the diocese is now made up of about 628,000 Catholics across six counties in southwestern Pennsylvania.
Read More
Pope Francis, who died of a stroke and heart failure April 21, had a mindset of embracing marginalized communities and welcoming those into the church who previously may have felt left on the sidelines. His progressive views and humble manner appealed to many, and Rev. Donahue said he saw church attendance in his parish rise 5% to 6% annually in the final years of Francis’ papacy — a trend he believes will continue under Pope Leo XIV.
“I think there was a ‘Francis effect,’ an effect of a guy who’s trying to be simple and trying to take away some of the pageantry that sometimes gets in the way … and I think that’s the type of thing people will really connect with,” he said. “I think it is just going to get stronger because, toward the end, Pope Francis was getting sick and couldn’t speak as much. There’s going to be a new energy and new enthusiasm. Enthusiasm is so crucial to continue the wave I think Francis began.”
Pope Leo XIV, a Villanova University graduate who spent decades ministering in Peru, is not only relatable to American Catholics. His papacy also resonates with congregations such as St. Oscar Romero Parish, which has a sizable Latin American population.
Rosa Huaman, a 29-year-old Peruvian-American who obtained U.S. citizenship last year, said the announcement of the new pope was an emotional one for her family.
“It is a reason to celebrate … my family is very excited,” she said. “My mom was tearing up when she found out he was in Peru. We just feel honored.”
In his first speech minutes after walking onto the balcony of St. Peter’s Basilica in Rome on Thursday, Pope Leo XIV, who is also a Peruvian citizen, didn’t speak in English. He began in Italian, then switched to Spanish — an important signal to non-English speakers across the world, Ms. Huaman said.
“That is my situation, only backwards,” she said. “I was born in Peru and came to the U.S. I feel like he’s the best of both worlds. He speaks English and speaks Spanish and he’s going to be able to reach so many people.”
‘Knows our language’
As William Neu, 71, left Mass at St. Paul Cathedral in Oakland on Friday, carrying a worn leather Bible, he said he hoped the new pontiff’s election would inspire an increase in commitment from American Catholics.
“This pope being American, he certainly has a better understanding of the church in the U.S., but Catholic means universal and he’s the pope of the entire church throughout the world, he’s for all of humanity,” he said. “He may continue the calling of the church to be more faithful to the gospel in terms of loving everyone, welcoming everyone, and especially looking at the poor and marginalized, so I think his papacy will be a call for the Catholic Church in the U.S. to be more faithful to the gospel.”

If that is the case, Mr. Neu said he believes Catholic communities could be strengthened.
“It may be that people will see that the church is more faithful to the gospel, and they’re more attracted to it,” he said.
Apart from the potential to revitalize Catholic communities, Pope Leo XIV may also be in a position to directly impact the future of the Pittsburgh diocese.
“Because Bishop (David) Zubik is now at retirement age, and this new Holy Father will be responsible for appointing the next bishop of Pittsburgh, that will significantly impact us,” said Andrew Kurzawski, who teaches theology at Aquinas Academy of Pittsburgh while working toward ordination as a deacon in the Byzantine Catholic Church. “That’s going to be extremely important.”
Mr. Kurzawski said Pope Leo XIV, who is 69, will likely have an easier time making public appearances throughout the world, something Pope Francis, who was 88 at the time of his death, struggled with as his health declined.
“He’s going to be a little more able to travel and meet young people,” Mr. Kurzawski said. “Asking my students if they actually felt a connection to (Pope Francis), almost unanimously none of them did. I think a lot of that has to do with them not having been in the presence of the pope at a World Youth Day or an event like that. [Pope Leo XIV] is definitely going to be able to offer that.”
While Pope Leo XIV being a native English speaker may make him feel more familiar than past pontiffs, it’s his cultural ties to America that may make more of a difference, said the Rev. Dave Pivonka, president of Franciscan University of Steubenville.
“I do think it animates people’s imagination,” Rev. Pivonka said. “...a pope who not just speaks English, but knows our language. We have a pope that’s probably ordered a Big Mac, so there’s something about his knowing us and knowing our history and story as Americans that I think will engage people and bring about conversion.”
Rev. Pivonka said the excitement was immediately felt on the Franciscan University campus following the announcement the world was awaiting.
“It was electric,” he said. “Our kids would have been excited no matter what, but the fact that he was American, nobody knew what to make of it.”
Others have also taken solace in the fact that Pope Leo XIV is the first pontiff to be a member of the Augustinian Order — a Catholic religious order founded in 1244 whose members pledge to live a life of humility and poverty.
“Knowing how staunch they are in their traditional Catholic beliefs gave me a little more peace,” said Maria Shemer, of Brookline. “He seems like a middle-of-the-road sort of pope, which I think is great for the church at this point, someone who truly values its traditions and reverence, but who’s also willing to lead us courageously into the modern era.”
Staff writer Laura Esposito contributed.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.