The pastor wept.

In an office chair at his small North Braddock church, the Rev. Glenn Germany wept at the loss of the person he was before May 5, 2024.

He wept because his analytical mind can’t reason its way out of the panic attacks that still come after a man with a gun walked into his Sunday sermon.

He wept for an uncertain future in which Pittsburgh no longer feels like home, and the prospect of the man with the gun leaving prison looms frighteningly large.

Advertise with us

And he wept for the past but also for the present.

“It’s now who I am, it’s how I’m identified,” Rev. Germany, pastor of Jesus’ Dwelling Place, said Friday. “I don’t think a day goes by where it’s not mentioned, it’s not brought up, or I walk down the street and, ‘Hey, you’re the pastor who ...’”

The pastor whom the voices told Bernard Polite to kill last year. The pastor who believes the grace of God jammed the young man’s gun. The pastor who can’t stop looking over his shoulder.

“You can’t forget it,” he said. “Just yesterday, I’m coming out of Auto Zone— ‘Hey, you’re the pastor who the guy tried to shoot.’”

It’s a label that he didn’t ask for, certainly didn’t want. But he said he doesn’t run from it.

Advertise with us

“I try to use it as an opportunity to testify,” he said. “But it’s just — that’s who I am now.”

The entire incident played out on a livestream of the Sunday service.

In the video, Bernard Polite can be seen standing up as Rev. Germany preaches from the pulpit. Mr. Polite, now 27, points the gun directly at the pastor, who is just a few feet away. For some reason, the gun jams, and Rev. Germany puts his hands over his face and ducks behind a lectern. Deacon Clarence McCallister grabbed the man as he tried to climb into the pulpit. He took him to the ground, and the pastor wrested the gun from him.

Now, the pastor said, he’s stuck in a strange limbo. He spent 15 years incarcerated on drug charges — prison is where he found God, he said — and so he knows what the corrections system can do to a young man. He said he doesn’t want to see the shooter lost to the system, but he also fears for his own family: Mr. Polite, he said, told him when he visited the defendant in jail that he wished he’d killed him that day — and still wanted to kill him.

Pastor Glenn Germany talks about a gunman tried to shoot him in the middle of Sunday services year ago at Jesus' Dwelling Place Church in North Braddock on Friday, May 9, 2025. (Justin Guido / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

A plea hearing in both of Mr. Polite’s cases — the attempted homicide of Rev. Germany and the homicide of his cousin, Derek Polite, found dead in the home they shared the same day — is scheduled for Aug. 4.

Advertise with us

“It feels some of the time like … do I have a 10-year sentence? Do I have 10 years to pack my bag and move out of town?” Rev. Germany said. “It gets real now — it gets more than just dealing with it. Now it’s like, this is a whole other issue that I’m not ready for.”

The lingering question of whether Mr. Polite will get mental health services, combined with the prospect of there being a hard end-date for his time in prison, is overwhelming for the pastor. A year later, he’s still grappling with the moment itself.

“It hasn’t set in yet. I’m still dealing with it, trying to understand it,” he said. “And then like, the more it goes on, I’m experiencing things I never experienced before.”

Rev. Germany believes he’s a strong person, and that’s what made it difficult to accept let alone deal with some of the post-traumatic stress responses he’s experienced since May 2024.

He couldn’t wrap his mind around the fact that, despite his strength and his relationship with and understanding of God, something like a panic attack could overcome him and bring him to his knees. It’s made him a more compassionate man, he said.

Advertise with us

“A lot of times, when you have strength, you just think other people are weak,” he said. “Then you start learning it’s not that they’re weak, it’s just that this thing is really serious. And it’s not about how much strength a person has, it’s about recognizing that they need help.”

He said he believes that what happened to him and to his church was for a reason, though it’s one that’s still unclear to him.

Rev. Germany is grateful to be alive — to be able to tell his story, and he is grateful that the incident has given him more compassion and helped him better relate to others.

Is he grateful that his happened to him?

He weeps.

Advertise with us

“I give thanks to the Lord in everything, not for everything, and I believe that he’ll protect me and keep me in everything,” he said. “But it gets hard a lot for me.”

He said he wouldn’t wish the past year — and the uncertain future — on an enemy.

The worry, the doubt, the judgments, the fear of saying the wrong thing to the wrong person and bringing harm on his family — no, he’s not thankful for this experience. He has a platform to tell his story now, but he didn’t want to get it like this, he said.

“But do I run from it? I don’t run from it,” he said. “Lord, you chose me. I’ll man up. But no, it’s not easy at all. At all.”