Behind the gray stone and stained-glass facade of St. Maximilian Kolbe Church in Homestead, there is a culinary operation that rivals some of the area’s busiest restaurants. 

Each Friday during the 40 days of Lent, volunteers serve up more than 1,000 pounds of cod, either baked or deep-fried to a golden crisp.

Dozens of apron- and rubber glove-clad parishioners work each week to ready the food in three separate prep areas at the church on 11th Avenue.

In the main kitchen, volunteers work around a long stainless steel table as they run a half dozen fryers for the fish and french fries — about 400 pounds of which will be sold each week. 

Advertise with us

Volunteers also prepare about 100 servings of their weekly soup special, including broccoli cheddar and cheesy potato. 

Across from the main kitchen is a second prep kitchen, where pierogis are fried and potato pancakes are made before being put into warmers. They don’t stay for long, especially during peak hours. 

“It’s not like stuff is sitting around,” said Ray Fonos, business manager for St. Thomas the Apostle Parish, which includes St. Maximilian. “We know what we need to have prepared and it's kind of like we’re making it to order, but at the same time getting it ready to be delivered.”

The fish fries run from 11 a.m. to 6:30 p.m. with the busiest time being the dinner rush. 

Diane Holomshek, of West Mifflin, left, Claudia Stipetic, center, of Baldwin, and Debbie Gaydos, right, of West Mifflin, share a laugh as they eat their fried fish at St. Maximilian Kolbe Church on Friday, March 14, 2025, in Homestead. The fish fry event is part of Lent. (Benjamin B. Braun / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Customers pack long tables lining the 250-seat church hall, which can get so crowded that some people are directed to a smaller overflow dining room. 

Advertise with us

To streamline the operation, there are three separate lines — one for dine-in, another for takeout and a third for phone-in orders. The church also has three drivers dropping off delivery orders. 

“One of the compliments we get from people on a consistent basis is how organized this is, and if you get that kind of reputation, you get people coming back,” Mr. Fonos said. 

The menu at St. Maximilian sets it apart from many of the more than 80 other fish fries in the region, he said.

Customers can choose from creamy pasta, shrimp, crab cakes, pizza, pierogis and homemade haluski. Prices range from $12.50 for a fried fish sandwich, to $7 for a pair of crab cakes, to $12 for shrimp dinner. A combo platter featuring all three with a side of fries and coleslaw runs $20.

“People get tired of fish so they’re looking for other options,” Mr. Fonos said. 

Advertise with us

In addition to the large operation at St. Maximilian, the parish operates a smaller fish fry at St. Agnes in West Mifflin. The two combined can bring up to $300,000 in revenue through the six-week season, according to Mr. Fonos. 

Preparing the feast is an event itself, as the church gets deliveries each week for the fish fry ahead. Readying the fish normally begins on Wednesday.

Fish sisters 

A group of six parishioners who call themselves the “fish sisters” gather over a series of large metal bowls to bread the fish, which is then stacked on sheet pans. The women refer to the pans – which weigh about 50 pounds each once the breaded cod filets are piled on – as “lugs.”  

“I wouldn’t know these ladies if it wasn’t for fish,” said Sarah Lucas, 79.

Cecilia Wyzykowski of Squirrel Hill, 69, and Dan Rodgers of Lincoln Place, 69, work on making soup for the Friday Lenten Fish Fry at St. Maximilian Kolbe Church on Thursday, March 20. (Samuel Long / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

The prep kitchen is lined with refrigerators and tables stacked with supplies. There’s also a washer and dryer for aprons, which inevitably get coated in bread crumbs. 

Advertise with us

They were not alone in the expansive kitchen, which was brimming with action a day before the third fish fry of the Lenten season. 

Around a stove, a small group of parishioners labored over a roux for a potato cheddar soup, which simmered in two tall pots, filling the kitchen with the aroma of cream and melted cheese. 

Elsewhere, parishioners filled plastic boxes with salad and divided out portions of coleslaw. 

In a back room off the main kitchen, which is lined by a pair of walk-in freezers, a couple folded pizza boxes. 

Amid it all, 44-year-old Jason Beven, who keeps the operation running like clockwork, bounced from room to room, checking on volunteers and taking note of how much food had been readied and stocked in one of the church’s numerous fridges. 

Advertise with us

Mr. Bevan, a church maintenance worker, runs the kitchen with a precise organization akin to a seasoned chef. 

“He’s the brains behind this,” Mr. Fonos said. “He’s the one making sure things are cooked right. He takes care of that kitchen like it's his home kitchen. He takes it very personally.” 

At St. Maximilian Kolbe, prep for fish fries begins months ahead, but the six weeks of Lent are Mr. Bevan’s personal Super Bowl. 

“You wake up and get excited about it,” he said. “I always tell my wife, ‘It’s fish Friday.’ She’s not as excited as I am.” 

Organizers said the busiest fish fry is usually the Friday after Ash Wednesday. The halls of of St. Maximilian were packed that day, March 7. 

Advertise with us

“It’s traditionally the biggest fish fry of the whole Lenten season,” Mr. Fonos said. “Over the next few weeks it levels off.”

While many of the parishioners credit Mr. Bevan with keeping St. Maximilian Kolbe’s fish fries running, he said the volunteers are what make it all possible. 

“Every year people get older, some step down, we always seem to find people to step in,” he said. “We don’t go looking. They show up. It’s a small army down here every year.” 

Bernie Stoebe, 94, remembers when the fish fries first began at St. Therese of Lisieux in Munhall in 1980 before many of the volunteers moved over to St. Maximilian Kolbe.

“Just a few of us breaded fish for a while, then they got the fish ladies together,” she said. 

Advertise with us

Former St. Therese teacher Donna Tomasic, who began volunteering two years ago, is the newest fish fry sister. 

“When I first came down, they just put me right in line and I started working, doing the fish,” she said. 

The women have forged a bond that extends beyond the church. 

“We’re a support group,” Ms. Lucas said. “We’ve had people with serious medical problems. We’ve had births. We’ve had deaths. We’ve had weddings and graduations. We’ve had different problems but we’re there for each other.”