As Lent approaches, many Pittsburghers are thinking about fish fries and battered, fried cod sandwiches. But there’s literally a whole ocean of possibilities out there, and now is a great time to explore them.

Ben D’Amico, Giant Eagle and Market District executive development chef, points out that seafood will be offered at a discount during the 40-day Lenten season, so — whether or not you go meatless on Fridays — it’s a nice long runway to test out your wings.

“If you’re someone who doesn’t often eat fish, this is probably a great time to do it,” he said. “You could say, ‘I haven’t tried that fish before, but hey, it’s on sale. It’s a great opportunity for me to try it.’”

Still, tradition holds sway, even among people who are buying fish to cook at home. That means cod is king, local fishmongers say.

Advertise with us

“Cod is our top-selling fish for Lent,” said John McNally, buyer and seafood manager for Wholey’s Market in the Strip District. “Most people know how to prepare cod.”

D’Amico agrees. Cod and haddock, a similar, less expensive white fish with large flakes and a mild taste, are “not going to be something outside of the average person’s comfort zone.”

These are the fish for people who don’t really like fish because they don’t have a strong fishy taste and are not oily.

Henry Dewey cuts bluefin tuna at Penn Avenue Fish Company. (Benjamin B. Braun / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Salmon for health

Salmon, on the other hand, is a fish many people buy exactly because of its plentiful, healthy omega-3 fatty acids.

Henry Dewey, an owner of Penn Avenue Fish Company, brings in several types of salmon, based on availability.

Advertise with us

“Everybody’s buying salmon,” he said. “That’s for health reasons.”

At his the fish market and restaurant, he sells sushi-grade salmon and tuna, and says that many customers make sushi at home. If that sounds intimidating, Dewey assures that you can buy a piece of salmon, take it home and slice it as sashimi — no rolling necessary.

Or you can simply go to Penn Avenue’s sushi bar, even though sushi may not exactly be a classic Lenten dish.

“Our sushi bar is crushed for Lent,” Dewey said.

He also suggested a Japanese twist on cod: miso-glazed black cod. Technically, though, black cod is not in the cod family but is a sablefish.

Advertise with us

“We’ll sell the black cod and the miso glaze and people will take it home and replicate the Nobu black cod,” made famous by Japanese chef Nobu Matsuhisa.

Dewey sells Penn Avenue marinades and sauces in a variety of styles, with the miso glaze being among the most popular.

Pan-seared Fundy Bay salmon garnished with fresh thyme. (John Colombo / For the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

‘Look, ma, no recipe!’

Wholey’s also offers a number of sauces and marinades to make cooking fish easy, as well as a display rack of free recipe cards that people can take home.

But Wholey’s marketing coordinator, Muriel Maze, tells inexperienced poissoniers that a recipe is not even necessary. You can throw most fish on a pan and stick it in the oven, or under the broiler, topped with just a little olive oil or butter.

For example, dress cod with lemon juice and butter, place it on a greased sheet pan and bake it in the oven at 375 degrees “until it’s flaky,” she said, about 20-30 minutes.

Advertise with us

A salmon fillet can be cooked similarly, though it requires less time, maybe 15-20 minutes. She advises topping salmon before cooking it with Wholey’s Savory Salmon Seasoning, a popular store item.

The U.S. Food and Drug Administration recommends cooking seafood to an internal temperature of 145 degrees.

If you are cooking thick cuts of fish, like tuna, swordfish or salmon steaks — or a whole fish — you may want to use a meat thermometer, especially if you are unfamiliar with cooking seafood.

If you want to cook a whole fish, local fish sellers propose red snapper, branzino, salmon or trout. Ask your fishmonger what is in season and for guidance amid the seas’ multitudes. Wholey’s, for one, has 320 seafood items on hand.

Wholey's head cutter Yum Duong, left, buyer John McNally and marketing coordinator Muriel Maze. (Sono Motoyama / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

It also helps to do a little advance preparation before seafood shopping, particularly if you are concerned about sustainability. Many species have been overfished. The Monterey Bay Aquarium Seafood Watch site is a useful guide, and don’t be afraid to quiz your provider about the source of any seafood item.

Advertise with us

If you decide to stay within your comfort zone, there will be a plentiful supply of fried cod sandwiches around town, including in Giant Eagle’s prepared food sections and at Penn Avenue Fish Company, which offers it as a special in addition to its usual baked English-style sandwich.

“When you think of Lent, especially in the Pittsburgh area, it’s the classic, deep-fried fish sandwich,” D’Amico said. “Fish fries are going to be every Friday on every block that has a fryer, and we offer one as well.”