The Jewish holiday of Simchat Torah celebrates the reading of the final section of the Torah and beginning of a new cycle — starting the Torah from the beginning with the first section of Genesis.

In essence, the story starts over.

The holiday this year fell on Oct. 24 and 25, days before Pittsburgh and its Jewish community marked six years since the deadly attack on the Squirrel Hill synagogue that housed the congregations Tree of Life, Dor Hadash and New Light.

As the community came together Sunday to honor the 11 killed in the attack on the synagogue, Noah Schoen, of the Holocaust Center of Pittsburgh, invited those gathered to think about the Torah and the oscillating narratives from oppression to freedom — and to think about the stories born out of Oct. 27, 2018.

Advertise with us

“We know how to tell a story that builds our resilience,” he said. “Our people have been doing this for thousands of years.”

For years, Mr. Schoen collected the oral narratives of hundreds of people in Pittsburgh, listening as they spoke about their lives and their reflections of Oct. 27, 2018. Through those oral narratives, he said, he got the chance to know the 11 killed that day.

“I learned that we get to choose the story that we tell about what happens to us,” he said.

He spoke about Alan Mallinger’s memories of his mother, Rose, including how when she wanted to get off the phone, she would say, “All right, we’ll talk to you soon.”

And Mr. Schoen spoke of Dan Leger, who was wounded in the shooting and nearly died. He said Mr. Leger talked about all of the people he was grateful for throughout his life and how he applied that lens of gratitude to his own experience that day.

Advertise with us

“Let’s keep telling stories about that day, about the people who we lost, and the people who touched us — about what we can’t yet seem to get over, and what we never expected to learn,” he said. “We know what a difference the story that we tell can make, and we get to decide what story we will tell.”

Hundreds crowded into the Jewish Community Center of Greater Pittsburgh for what has become an annual commemoration event. Family members of each of the 11 slain congregants quietly came forward and lit a candle for their loved one.

Joyce Fienberg, Richard Gottfried, Rose Mallinger, Jerry Rabinowitz, Cecil and David Rosenthal, Bernice and Sylvan Simon, Dan Stein, Melvin Wax, and Irving Younger.

Michelle Weis, daughter of Bernice and Sylvan, kissed her fingertips and touched them to the vase holding her mother’s candle. Rose Mallinger’s grandchildren read “A Prayer for Peace,” a prayer that she read at every Shabbat service: “May we see the day when war and bloodshed cease, when a great peace will embrace the world.”

Asher Goodwin and Ilan Gordon, two University of Pittsburgh students who were assaulted on their way to Shabbat dinner in late August, also spoke to those gathered.

Advertise with us

“There are many things that we cannot control in life,” Mr. Gordon said. “You cannot live constantly looking over your shoulder in fear of being attack on the street for being visibly Jewish.”

Mr. Goodwin picked up where his friend left off: “You can, however, be proud of who you are. You can wear your kippah, wear your Magen David [Star of David], and go to shul. Embrace the warmth and love of your community and hold hands with your neighbors who are different from you.”

The commemoration took on a different look in its sixth year, something that Ron Wedner, whose mother-in-law was killed and whose wife was wounded in the shooting, said was meant to try to meet members of the community where they are in the ever-evolving grieving and healing process.

Tree of Life Rabbi Jeffrey Myers, who survived the shooting by hiding in a choir loft bathroom on the phone with a 911 dispatcher, said Oct. 27 itself can be a difficult day.

“For me, it’s painful, because I recall the day and the recording of it — it’s seared in my brain,” he said. “It starts to play and it, for me, doesn’t stop. The 56-minute call to 911 just doesn’t stop until it plays out. I just have to sometimes let it play out.”

Advertise with us

It is a difficult day, he said, but a necessary one.

“Because we must remember, because it’s important for the community,” Rabbi Myers said. “So we will remember. We will not forget.”