The arrest of a Diocese of Greensburg employee now charged with sexual assault and the forced resignation of a popular pastor that followed has left a rift between the diocese and parishioners of a pair of Norwin churches.
North Huntingdon police arrested Shon Harrity, a 47-year-old employee at the cemetery of Immaculate Conception Parish in Irwin, on charges that include sexual assault of a minor, threat of rape and aggravated indecent assault on May 8.
In the wake of the arrest came revelations that Harrity had a criminal record that included convictions for indecent exposure, lewdness, and obscene disorderly conduct that date back two decades.
Those charges would have disqualified him from employment, but were not flagged by administrators and the Rev. John Moineau, the pastor of both Immaculate Conception and St. Elizabeth Ann Seton, whose resignation was announced on May 28.
While the news of the arrest and subsequent resignation shocked some parishioners — especially after multiple sex abuse accusations have been leveled at diocese priests over the past decade — Greensburg Bishop Larry Kulik’s quick and decisive handling of the situation has sent reverberations through the small pair of churches.
Criticism mounts
Katie Burkett, 41, of North Huntingdon, said her family has attended Immaculate Conception Parish for four generations and helped build the church, She was shocked and saddened by Rev. Moineau’s resignation, which came after his years long struggle with pancreatic cancer.
Read More
Ms. Burkett, a mother of two, said she is unsure of what the shakeup within the diocese will ultimately mean for them down the line.
“We’ve always had that faith and will not change that,” she said. “I just think we need to take a breath and see if we’re going to continue being as involved as we were or just pull back and see how things play out.”
The sudden resignation struck her as a harsh response, especially considering Rev. Moineau’s continued dedication to the parishes amid his struggle with cancer.
“He has done it happily and has come to Mass with the pack that was delivering chemo[therapy] and has done all of these things without complaining,” Ms. Burkett said. “To demand immediate resignation seemed severe. I think there should have been an investigation first.”
Rev. Moineau, who has been asked by the bishop not to speak with the media, declined comment.
Mary Lou Rothwell, 77, of Irwin, also strongly disapproved Rev. Moineau’s resignation coming before a probe had been completed.
“It would seem the right thing to do would be to have the investigation, if you choose to have one, and then make those decisions,” she said. “[Bishop Kulick] acted instead of reacted.”
Ms. Rothwell has since written letters to the archbishop of Philadelphia, Nelson Pérez, and Pope Francis. She said the bishop’s handling of the situation will impact her donations to the diocese, which she’d rather send to Rev. Moineau, who is no longer living in the diocese-provided home near St. Elizabeth Ann Seton and is now staying with a friend in the area.
“’I’ll give something weekly, but it’s going to be minimal and the rest is going to Father John.”
A bishop’s call to investigators
The diocese maintains that it's working to handle this with care — continuing to pay the priest and even offering him housing — while it moves quickly to understand the allegations and how its internal processes may have not worked.
A part of that response has been a call by Bishop Kulick for Westmoreland County detectives to investigate a potential conspiracy to conceal Harrity’s record after several clearance documents were found to be missing from his file.
Harrity’s background, including an FBI fingerprint check that would have disqualified him from employment, was also never flagged by the safe environment coordinator at Immaculate Conception Parish, who is paid to manage employee and volunteer clearances.
An attorney representing Harrity did not respond to requests for comment.
Melanie Jones, a spokeswoman for the Westmoreland County district attorney, said the investigation into the claims by the diocese is ongoing and did not comment further.
Clifford Gorski, a spokesman for the Diocese of Greensburg, said Rev. Moineau was offered diocesan accommodations for the duration of the investigation, but he chose to not to take it.
Mr. Gorski said Rev. Moineau’s salary and benefits, including health care coverage, remain intact and he could be restored to some form of priestly ministry depending on the outcome of the investigation. Once that investigation is completed, the Canonical, or church law investigation, will begin into possible culpable negligence.
In the meantime, Bishop Kulik’s office has been flooded with approximately 100 calls and emails, many from parishioners who do not understand that Rev. Moineau may eventually be reinstated, Mr. Gorski said.
Comments on Immaculate Conception Parish’s Facebook page have also been disabled, which Mr. Gorski said has been done to prevent the spread of misinformation.
He added that many of the calls and messages the bishop has received have been in support of the way the diocese has handled the situation.
“About 40% of the communications have been messages of support from individuals who believe bishop made the right decision,” Mr. Gorski said. “These individuals support swift action and transparency, particularly in light of the past practices of the church. At least two individuals who support the decision are survivors of child sexual abuse. They send their prayers for the victim in this case who was sexually assaulted for two years.”
Following the revelations regarding Harrity’s criminal record, Bishop Kulik ordered all priests and administrators to review all employee and volunteer files within the week.
Those reviews turned up no more employees or volunteers whose backgrounds would have disqualified them from employment with the diocese, Mr. Gorski said.
‘The final straw for me’
Bishop Kulik said Rev. Moineau’s resignation was ultimately for the “good of the parishes,” but the timing of the priest’s departure before the investigation has been completed is seen by a number of parishioners as too hasty and as laying the blame on him.
“I just think he was railroaded and scapegoated and two big parishes are going to suffer for it,” Kelly Gambetta, 41, of North Huntingdon, said. “And It’s a shame. It’s not like the Catholic church is doing that great to begin with.”
Ms. Gambetta said her husband stopped attending Mass in 2018 after a report from the Pennsylvania attorney general outlined sexual abuse by priests in the Greensburg Diocese, as well as in other dioceses across the state.
“After the attorney general report came out, my husband has refused to go to church,” she said. “I’ve just been kind of holding on by a thread here and I think that’s probably the final straw for me. I want my children to receive the sacraments, but that’s as far as it goes if Father John’s not there.”
The diocese has dealt with multiple abuse scandals in recent years.
This includes the arrest of Andrew Kawecki, a priest at St. John the Baptist Church in Scottdale and St. Joseph Church in Everson, in August 2020 on charges of sexually assaulting an altar boy multiple times between 2004 and 2007.
Kawecki, who was placed on leave more than a year before he was charged, pleaded no contest to the charges in October 2021 and was sentenced to five years in state prison the following March.
In December 2018, another priest with the Greensburg diocese was sentenced to over a decade in prison for sexually assaulting a 10-year-old boy.
John T. Sweeney, a former reverend, was sentenced to 11½ years behind bars after admitting to abusing the boy during the 1991-92 school year while he was the pastor at St. Margaret Mary Parish in Lower Burrell.
Sweeney was the first priest convicted as the result of a the statewide grand jury investigation into sexual abuse by priests in Pennsylvania and the cover-ups by the dioceses they were a part of.
That report said 20 priests in the Greensburg diocese had been accused since its creation in 1951 and specifically criticized previous bishops of the diocese for allowing known predators to remain in the ministry.
This time, the diocese has highlighted its quick response,
“I may live the rest of my life as the Bishop of the Diocese of Greensburg who asked one of our most popular and beloved priests to resign,” Bishop Kulik said in the announcement of Rev. Moineau’s resignation. “But I have a responsibility to the people of this diocese. I will not hide our mistakes. And I will root out any and all potential risks to the safety of children.”
Bishop Kulik expressed confidence in his decision.
“Someday, in front of our maker, like each of us, I will be judged by the actions I take on this earth. I have no doubt this is the right decision,” he said.
Rev. Moineau has offered full cooperation and assistance with the investigation. Both Immaculate Conception parish and St. Elizabeth Ann Seton Parish are currently being administered by the Rev. Lawrence Manchas, although the Rev. Michael Crookston, the former pastor of St. Elizabeth Seton, will become pastor of both parishes on June 17, according to the diocese.
Bishop Kulik said the diocesan human resource office will also conduct its own audit of employee and volunteer clearances in all 78 parishes and 12 schools over the summer.
“We have so many wonderful things happening in our parishes and schools, and in our Diocesan offices,” Bishop Kulik wrote. “I will not let this one incident define us. But I will do everything I can to make sure it never happens again.”
Harrity, who has been released on bail, is due back in court to be arraigned on June 19.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.