Across the country last week, students disrupted college campuses to protest the ongoing war between Israel and Hamas.
It was the latest spark in escalating tension playing out again and again in almost every sphere, from government, to neighborhood streets, and now to higher education.
At the University of Southern California, the presence of pro-Palestinian demonstrators prompted the university, fearing conflict, to cancel its main graduation ceremony. At Columbia University in New York, students reached an impasse with administrators and planned to continue their pro-Palestine encampment indefinitely. Students at the University of Pennsylvania and Northeastern University in Boston were ordered to abandon their encampments, raising free speech and free assembly questions.
The protests even came against the backdrop of Tuesday’s primary election in Pennsylvania, with pro-Palestinian groups encouraging Democrats to write in “No Joe” to oppose President Joe Biden’s support for Israel.
The appearance of an encampment by University of Pittsburgh and Carnegie Mellon University students coincided with Passover, the major Jewish holy day marking the ancient Hebrews’ exodus from slavery in Egypt. That timing prompted concern that pro-Palestinian rhetoric had devolved into blatant antisemitism.
“This was placed during finals at Pitt. This was placed during Passover,” Julius Arolovich, a Jewish CMU student, said of the encampment that popped up in Oakland. “The timing is dubious.”
Read More
Christine Mohamed, executive director of the Pittsburgh Council on American Islamic Relations, countered that criticism of the Israeli government is not antisemitism.
“Speaking out against the violations of international law … the loss of innocent life, how does that make you a Hamas supporter?” she said. “I’m tired of that question and that rhetoric being pushed out there.
“What is more American than standing up for what is right, or free speech, or our right to free assembly?”
Those rights only go so far, said Steven D. Irwin, a Pittsburgh attorney and a member of the Pennsylvania, Ohio and Kentucky Regional Board of the Anti-Defamation League.
“We’re talking about people’s windows being broken, their houses being painted, swastikas being put on people’s cars,” he said. “This is what’s happened.”
A call for solidarity
The Pittsburgh students’ actions started early last week, with scores of protesters taking to the lawn of the Cathedral of Learning. They called on Pitt officials to give a full rundown of the university’s investments in Israel and to issue a statement of solidarity with the Palestinian people.
The protest moved to Schenley Plaza on Tuesday, and on Thursday, about 40 pro-Israel protesters encircled that encampment, many holding signs portraying the Israelis taken hostage by Hamas on Oct. 7.

Among them was Misha Trosman, a Pitt junior who said he is a descendant of Holocaust survivors and he has family members who are fighting with Israeli Defense Forces.
He said he believes it is hypocritical for pro-Palestinian protesters to call for a cease-fire of the war without calling for the release of Israeli hostages.
“I believe the people of Gaza deserve just as many human rights as every single Jewish person in the world,” he said. “But if you're going to advocate for human rights, you cannot do so without calling for the release of hostages.”
Mr. Arolovich, the CMU student, said he doesn’t think the protests have done anything to further the conversation.
“These protests have not done much to actually reach any political goal,” he said. “From my perspective, the goal has been to disrupt and to be quite inflammatory against those who disagree.”
While clashes between protesters and counter-protesters remained relatively peaceful — yelling between the two groups in Oakland Thursday night prompted police to ask the pro-Israel crowd to call it a night — that’s not been the case elsewhere.
At Columbia, a rabbi urged Jewish students to stay home for their safety. Jewish students at the Upper Manhattan campus claimed protesters told them to “go back to Poland” and “stop killing children.” More than 100 people were arrested when police cleared a pro-Palestinian encampment there earlier this month.
Mr. Arolovich said his parents fled the Soviet Union due to antisemitism. When his mother saw the occurrences at schools such as Columbia, he said, she told him that antisemitism is “so much worse here than it ever was there.”
Gov. Josh Shapiro, who is Jewish, called the scenes “like 1930s Germany stuff.”
“I do feel a somewhat unique responsibility to speak out when I see this level of antisemitism on our campuses and in our communities,” the governor told Politico recently. “We’ve seen a rise in antisemitism and Islamophobia. I think it is incumbent upon anyone — a governor or anyone else — to speak and act with moral clarity when they see these issues.”

Democratic politics have been tossed into turmoil by the war in Gaza as the party struggles to remain cohesive despite competing camps ahead of what will likely be a heated presidential election.
Though the presidential race between Mr. Biden and former President Donald Trump was set months ago, groups like Abandon Biden Pennsylvania urged primary voters to do just that — write in “No Joe” or “uncommitted” — to take a stand against the president’s support of Israel.
While the breakdown of write-in votes in Pennsylvania isn’t yet clear, some 60,000 write-in votes for president were cast by Democrats last week. That was three times more than the last time an incumbent Democrat was on the ballot for president — Barack Obama in 2012, when only 19,000 write-ins were recorded.
An explosion of antisemitism
Antisemitic incidents have grown in recent years but exploded after the Oct. 7 attack on Israel by Hamas, which the U.S. has designated as a terrorist group by the U.S.
The Anti-Defamation League reported 8,873 incidents nationwide in 2023 — more than double the previous high of 3,698 the year prior. The numbers painted a particularly grim picture in Pennsylvania, which ranked the eighth-highest among all states in terms of antisemitic incidents last year.
In 2023, there were 394 reported incidents, an increase of nearly 246% over the year prior.
“Assaults, vandalism, harassment and swatting are visible, and it’s becoming almost commonplace in Pittsburgh,” Mr. Irwin said.

Since Oct. 7, he said, it’s become even more dramatic.
Most recently, Pittsburgh police investigated a series of incidents at a home on the city’s North Side. The woman who lives in the home, who asked that she be identified only by the initials D.B. out of fear of escalating attacks, said her house was targeted because of a small Israeli flag she’d placed in her flower bed.
Security cameras captured a man spray painting the words “for blood and soil” on the walkway in front of her home. The time stamp on the video, which the woman shared with the Post-Gazette, showed the vandalism occurred about 4 a.m. April 21.
The term “blood and soil” is a Nazi slogan intended to evoke the idea of a “pure race,” according to the U.S. Holocaust Memorial Museum. “Blood” refers to the concept of a pure “Aryan” race. “Soil,” according to the museum, “invoked a mystical vision of the special relationship between the Germanic people and their land.”
“It’s unfathomable that we’re experiencing this kind of hate and extremism,” Mr. Irwin said. “There’s no question that what's happening in Israel right now has exacerbated or unveiled or given permission to folks to express whatever sentiments they have or prejudices or biases they have against Jews.”
Police sought the public’s assistance in identifying two people caught on camera vandalizing the North Side home. Officials announced they’d identified one of them but, as of Friday, no arrests or charges had been announced.
The rise in antisemitism led more than six in 10 American Jews to say the status of Jews in the U.S. was less secure than in 2022, according to the American Jewish Committee’s annual Survey of Antisemitism in America.
“What we’re seeing in society is very troubling,” said Marcia Bronstein, the AJC regional director.
The survey also found that 44% of American Jews with connections to college campuses, either because they were a current or recent student or a parent of a student, said they felt excluded or uncomfortable because of their religion, including not wearing clothing or jewelry that identified them as Jews or discussing Israel.
In New York last week, Columbia students were given the option to take classes remotely.
“It’s very disturbing that people are saying, ‘We can’t protect you, so stay home, don’t go to school,” Ms. Bronstein said. “That’s the most disturbing thing, that we can’t protect our Jewish population. What's going on today is very scary. People are getting hurt. It's just crazy.”
According to the Associated Press, the president of Massachusetts Institute of Technology put out a statement Saturday saying the encampment there had become a “potential magnet for disruptive outside protesters” and was taking hundreds of staff hours to keep safe.
“We have a responsibility to the entire MIT community — and it is not possible to safely sustain this level of effort,” MIT President Sally Kornbluth said. “We are open to further discussion about the means of ending the encampment. But this particular form of expression needs to end soon.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.