As a pivotal swing state in the presidential election, all eyes were on Pennsylvania on Tuesday.
But voter turnout appeared to be low across the Pittsburgh region as voters came out to voice their support – or displeasure – for the two presidential candidates, while weighing in on other heated issues, including the contested 12th Congressional District race and the Israel-Hamas war.
Both the presidential and U.S. senate races were not suspenseful; President Joe Biden and former President Donald Trump locked up their nominations more than a month ago and neither Sen. Bob Casey nor Republican David McCormick faced a challenger in their primaries.
Still, voters expressed strong opinions of candidates, from the very top of the ballot down to local races. And their votes mattered in key races for the state's top prosecutor, treasurer and auditor.
The county reported no major issues with voting, the vast majority of mail ballots were counted before polls closed at 8 p.m., and polling places were adequately staffed with election judges. Some feared the low turnout Tuesday was a result of Mr. Biden and Mr. Trump essentially having their nominations locked in already. They both won enough delegates from primary elections last month to be chosen as their party’s candidate at this summer’s national political conventions.
Tom Tompkins who has overseen 84 elections in a four-decade stint as constable for Bethel Park suggested a lack of interest, based on an absence of candidate options and presidential nominees that are predestined to face off in November, was to blame.
Read More
“There’s just nobody to vote for,” Mr. Tompkins said. “It’s only one page so it's just a lack of interest I think … It seems like [Mr. Trump and Mr. Biden] are the foregone conclusion.”
In Upper St. Clair, Judge of Elections Sam Berenthal at the Fort Couch Middle School, said Tuesday was the lowest voter turnout he’s seen since 2020.
“This is maybe 20% of the turnout we'd have for a presidential election," Mr. Berenthal said about six hours before polls closed Tuesday afternoon. "If this is any indication, I doubt we'll get a lot more people.”
Shortly after 5 p.m. about 230 people had voted at the Adamsburg Fire Hall, just outside Adamsburg, Westmoreland County – the lowest turnout since the 2008 primary according to Robert Hand, chief elections judge.
When voters went to the polls, national — and even international — issues sometimes figured into their decisions of which candidates to support.
In the heated contest for the 12th Congressional District, the Israel-Gaza war has been a hot topic between sitting U.S. Rep Summer Lee and her challenger Edgewood Borough Council member Bhavani Patel.
Catherine Flamenbaum, a 71-year old Jewish resident of Swisshelm, said she voted for Ms. Lee, who condemned Hamas for the Oct. 7 attack on Israel and has since co-sponsored a ceasefire resolution, but she also voted against a congressional resolution condemning Hamas.
“I believe in a two-state solution, and I think Patel has used that issue against Lee,” she said. “I particularly wanted to vote for Summer Lee as a Jew.”
In Swisshelm, first time voter, 18-year old Brandon Friez said he registered as a Democrat specifically to support Ms. Patel.
He said he has Jewish friends who support Israel who feel that Ms. Lee has been too antagonistic.
“Summer Lee’s progressive policies are not geared toward mine,” he said.
The Israel-Hamas war came up in the presidential race, too.
Rather than voting for Mr. Biden or Democrat Dean Phillips – the U.S. House Representative for Minnesota’s third congressional district who ended his Democratic primary bid and endorsed Mr. Biden early last month – some people joined a wave of voters across the state writing “uncommitted” on their ballots as a protest to the president’s handling of the Israel-Hamas war.
“I just did a write in and I wrote in ‘Free Palestine,’” said Katelynn Herrera, a sophomore at the University of Pittsburgh. “I was going to do uncommitted, but I felt like doing ‘Free Palestine.’”
Others like Ben Steiner in McCandless voted for Mr. Biden, but wished there were better options. Mr. Steiner considered writing “uncommitted,” but said “it would be a wasted effort.”
“Biden already has the nomination,” he said.
Other Democrats were content to vote for Mr. Biden for another term.
“He’s a decent man,” said Karon Hammond. “I trust him. And I think he’s surrounded himself with good people.”
Some voters in the region cast their ballots for Republican Nikki Haley as a way to signal their displeasure with Mr. Trump, even though she withdrew from the race in early March.
In Ross, one voter chose Ms. Haley, saying, “I was excited about being able to vote for somebody other than Biden or Trump. There was a lot of damage done in the last election. I would like to see someone from a younger generation get in.”
Other voters though continued to embrace Mr. Trump.
"If MAGA means I like his policies, then I'm MAGA," said Greg Bellotti, a 57-year old dentist from Hempfield Township.
Maddie Aiken, Jordan Anderson, Steve Bohnel, Sydney Carruth, Jacob Geanous, Ciara McEneany, Jonathan D. Salant, and Hanna Webster contributed to this report.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.