A Catholic Mass that was to be held this weekend in solidarity with LGBTQ+ parishioners was canceled amid pressure from the Catholic Diocese of Pittsburgh.
The Mass was organized by Pittsburgh-based Catholics for Change in Our Church, which advocates for positive transformation within the diocese. It was scheduled to take place Sunday at Duquesne University’s Chapel of the Holy Spirit.
But in the weeks leading up to the event, hundreds of emails and phone calls, some of which were threatening, were received by the diocese, causing Bishop David Zubik to ask the university to cancel the Mass. The university obliged, Kevin Hayes, president of CCOC, said.
“They’ve been very sad, disappointed and upset,” Mr. Hayes said of LGBTQ+ Catholics. “People that have reached out and said it’s really unfortunate. Some of them said that there’s just no words to express how we feel. This is just so disappointing.”
The diocese was not involved with the mass and Bishop Zubik said in a letter to the diocese's priests that he and Duquesne University President Ken Gormley did not know about the Mass.
Both the Diocese of Pittsburgh and Duquesne University sent Bishop Zubik’s letter when asked for comment.
The Mass, which was being organized with the help of the LGBTQ outreach ministries at St. Joseph the Workers Parish and at St. Mary Magdalene would have followed Catholic doctrine, Mr. Hayes said. The goal, he said, was to “just have LGBTQ Catholics feel welcomed as beloved sons and daughters of a loving God and just be affirmed for who they are within the context of the Eucharist, which we feel is appropriate.”
A similar Mass was held last year in Duquesne’s chapel that “was well publicized, it was well attended and it went off without any issues. It was really a joy filled mass,” Mr. Hayes said. The organization hosts monthly masses at Duquesne, some of which are in solidarity with marginalized Catholic groups such as Latino and Black members.
But pushback for Sunday’s event started after a sister parish posted a flyer with the phrase “Pride Mass,” Deacon Herb Riley with St. Joseph the Workers, said. The word “pride just touched a nerve with so many organizations and people” that it led to the mass being canceled, he said.
“The mere fact the word pride causes so many people to be angry and think it’s anti-Catholic just because these people are proud of who they are,” Deacon Riley said. “Pride as we know is one of the seven deadly sins in our faith but this is not that type of proud. … This is just about celebrating the dignity of a group of people who have been mistreated forever.”
Bishop Zubik in his letter said the flyer “confused some and enraged others,” leading to “hateful” responses that did not keep with Christian charity.
While he condemned the responses to the Mass, Bishop Zubik added, “The Church has invested much energy in welcoming people who are dealing with sensitive issues in their lives. As Church, we all have the responsibility to love those who have same sex attraction. But at the same time, the Church cannot support behavior that goes against God’s law.”
According to Mr. Hayes, Catholics for Change were not involved in conversations about the mass being canceled.
Mr. Hayes is hoping to reschedule the LGBTQ mass, but organizers would have to “make sure we don’t get that hateful reaction,” he said. In his letter, Bishop Zubik said that it was his hope that Catholics, “inclusive of the LGBTQ community” still gather on Sunday to celebrate Corpus Christi.
But for Mr. Hayes, the incident has made him more aware of “ignorance and fear” within the Catholic community, he said.
“We hope that can be addressed through the love of Christ, frankly, and help people get beyond their fear, whatever it is, with LGBTQ+ members and get beyond the ignorance as well too and try to move toward some reconciliation,” he said. “We hope that we can keep moving forward and really be a church where we can be welcoming.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.