Pastors Heather Schoenewolf and Patrice Fowler-Searcy are used to addressing their congregation from high in the pulpit of the East Liberty Presbyterian Church, their voices echoing off the stones of the historic cathedral.

But on Thursday, a little less than two weeks after the Supreme Court overturned Roe v. Wade, the pastors stood silent on the sidewalk of Penn Avenue during busy traffic.

Car horns cut through the silence, blaring in support of the abortion-rights signs held high by members of Revs. Schoenewolf and Fowler-Searcy’s church who were galvanized to hold a vigil on behalf of women’s rights that evening.

“It’s scary,” said Rev. Schoenewolf, addressing the court’s decision. “I preach on it. We talk about it. We act on it.”

Advertise with us

Around 20 people joined the pastors outside of the church, a Presbyterian denomination Rev. Schoenewolf said supports a woman’s right to an abortion, as well as marriage for the LGBT community — another right the pastor fears is under threat in future decisions from the conservative-leaning court.

“Our church has always stood for racial, gender, ethnic justice — justice for all of God’s people, ” Rev. Fowler-Searcy said. “We were just really saddened by the decision of the Supreme Court to abolish Roe vs. Wade, because we felt like it was a decision made for women that really didn’t speak to us having authority and sovereignty over our own body.”

Rev. Fowler-Searcy remembers thinking, “let’s bring people together in silence, because we feel like the voices of women are being silenced in this country.”

While some faith groups have lauded the decision to overturn Roe as a win for anti-abortion policy decades in the making, Rev. Schoenewolf explained that the Presbyterian denomination has affirmed the Roe vs. Wade decision since 1983.

“Our denomination is also a denomination that believes that the Holy Spirit can guide individuals to make choices on their own, and that decisions that are medical or moral or political or complex are for the individual to discern,” Rev. Schoenewolf said, although she added that not all Presbyterians support abortion rights.

Advertise with us

“There are other churches that also support a women’s right to make decisions about their bodies,” Rev. Fowler-Searcy explained. “I don’t think that we’re an outlier. We might be one of the few churches — and there are others — that are willing to publicly acknowledge [it].”

Rev. Schoenewolf was born in 1973, the same year Roe. vs. Wade passed in the Supreme Court in a landmark decision that radically advanced women’s rights.

But the pastor said she remains aware of tremendous gender disparities seen in her lifetime, including that women weren’t able to own a credit card in their own name until the Fair Credit Opportunity act passed in 1974.

The pastor said she now worries not just about abortion rights, but the rights for LGBT people to marry and for interracial marriage, which some civil rights advocates worry could be overturned if the Supreme Court reverses the decisions of Obergefell v. Hodges and Loving vs. Virginia.

“I’m worried for a lot,” Rev. Schoenefeld said. “It’s a scary time for democracy.”

Advertise with us

Standing defiantly among the vigil-attendees that evening was Mary Barr, 69, of Highland Park, who said the Supreme Court decision “radicalized” her. She said she is already in shock from its fallout.

One story in particular stood out to her, of a 10-year-old rape victim in Ohio who was denied an abortion under the state’s post-Roe ban and had to travel to neighboring Indiana for the procedure.

“To me, that’s a horror,” Ms. Barr said. “For anybody to be forced to give birth to a child against their will.”

Ms. Barr began attending the East Liberty Presbyterian Church last fall, which she lauded for its progressive values.

“The sermon that [Rev. Schoenewolf] gave last Sunday — I went back and listened to it again on YouTube again, it was so good, “Ms. Barr said. “I had tears in my eyes. She spoke about how we have to think about the people who aren’t being taken care of — especially women.”

Jesse Bunch: jbunch@post-gazette.com