While some parishioners gathered inside the Immaculate Conception Church in Bloomfield for its final Mass on Sunday evening, a small group of women congregated outside the church, collecting signatures to appeal the closure.
Inside the church, the pews were filled, but Nina Sacco, one of the women collecting signatures, said the majority of people there didn’t live in Bloomfield.
“And that’s to make a statement,” she said, noting that the people inside were mostly older members who had returned for one more Mass.
Bishop David Zubik of the Diocese of Pittsburgh announced at the end of March that the diocese will be closing the church on Edmond Street and keeping open St. Joseph Church on Liberty Avenue, just a stone’s throw away.
Parishioners filed an appeal with Bishop Zubik over the closure and during the last Mass on Sunday continued to collect signatures in support of their efforts.
“We just want to show how many we can get, because of how many people are really upset about this decision,” said Linda Vacca, a lifelong parishioner at Immaculate Conception who has helped lead the appeals process. “It’ll support the appeal, but it’s not necessary.”
Read More
Bishop Zubik has until Wednesday to reply to the appeal. If he doesn’t, the group then has 15 days to mail an appeal to the ambassador of the Holy See in Washington, D.C.
In January, the diocese hired an outside group to put together a report on the conditions of both churches. Inspection reports said they both were in “bad shape” and “needed a lot of repairs,” diocese spokesperson Jennifer Antkowiak previously said.
Some of the members expressed confusion at the decision to close Immaculate Conception over St. Joseph Church.
“It’s sad that they’re closing our church building, because it’s the one that should be kept open,” Ms. Vacca said, noting that Immaculate Conception is only about 60 years old, while St. Joseph is about 130.
St. Joseph will be renovated but still hold Mass during the process. Some in the congregation have voiced concerns about structural integrity and air-quality issues in the building.
However the diocese said parishioners were “assured” that there is “no health or safety threat,” according to Ms. Antkowiak.
“It’s always sad when you have to have the closing of a church,” the Rev. John Harvey said at the beginning of the final Mass at Immaculate Conception. “We gathered to recognize that grief and sadness, but also to raise up a sense of gratitude for all the graces we’ve received in this building.”
Near the altar, the books containing a list of all the weddings, baptisms and funerals that have been held in the church were placed.
A special procession was planned for the end of the Mass so everyone could exit together, one last time.
During his homily, Rev. Harvey compared the closure to a death in the family but encouraged the parishioners to “not just dwell on the sadness of death and grief” but celebrate the memories instead.
“The Mass today was emotional for all of us. Nobody likes to see a church building close,” Ms. Antkowiak said. “Today’s Mass was a celebration, and a huge expression of gratitude for all of the important moments that families experienced together at the church. We look forward to hands and hearts coming together as the faithful work to strengthen the Catholic community in Bloomfield.”
For many, the closure announcement was emotional because those memories stretch through multiple generations of families.
“There’s a lot of memories there,” Ms. Vacca said. “Weddings, funeral luncheons, Holy Communion, high school graduation. We used to rent the hall out … every weekend. It was constantly in use.”
Ms. Sacco didn’t attend the last Mass. She sat outside for the duration collecting signatures. Her grandparents helped build the church, and the space holds a lot of memories for her family.
“I walked in there one last time just to walk around with my grandfather; he’s 93,” she said. “He asked me not to give anything up and to keep fighting. That’s a big reason why I’m still doing it.”
Ms. Sacco, her children and various aunts, uncles and cousins all attended school at Immaculate Conception and have been members her entire life.
Aside from the church itself, there is a social hall in the basement that anyone in the community was able to rent out, not just members of the church, according to Ms. Sacco.
With that gone, Ms. Sacco is concerned that there isn’t anywhere else for the community to gather.
“I think what’s really difficult for a lot of people is Bloomfield is Little Italy, right? Well, you just closed the Italian church. What’s left in Little Italy?” Ms. Sacco asked.
Hallie Lauer: hlauer@post-gazette.com







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.