On other days, Audrey Kauffman has sat in court galleries as part of a silent show of support for victims of sexual assault, including children in Amish and Mennonite communities such as those she grew up in.

On Tuesday, afternoon, others showed up in person and via Zoom in a silent show of support for her and her children.

They watched as her ex-husband pleaded no contest in Cumberland County Court of Common Pleas in Carlisle to sexual offenses against their three daughters, all when they were younger than 13.

“It felt different to be on the receiving end of [the support] this time,” said Ms. Kauffman, of Newburg. “It was overwhelming to realize we’re not alone.”

Advertise with us

While not a guilty plea, the no-contest plea has the same result in effecting a conviction.

Michael A. Kauffman, of Lititz, had been originally charged in 2019 with 32 charges, including rape of a child. Most of those charges were not part of the plea Tuesday.

The 40-year-old pleaded no contest to statutory sexual assault, unlawful contact with a minor (sexual offenses), indecent assault and endangering the welfare of children.

“He acknowledges that the government can prove this based on all the evidence that’s been provided, though he doesn't admit that he did it,” said Michael Kauffman’s attorney, Allan Sodomsky.

Chief Deputy District Attorney Courtney Hair LaRue said the offenses occurred between 2011 and 2019 in multiple Cumberland County residences. She said the “defendant committed multiple acts of sexual and physical abuse against his three daughters,” when each were younger than 13. She then read into the court record in graphic detail the nature of those assaults.

Advertise with us

Ms. Kauffman said she and her ex-husband had been members of a New Order Amish group until late in their marriage. She said they were still in that movement when the assaults began.

They had later left that church, and eventually the couple divorced. She said when she learned about her ex-husband’s abuses from her children in 2019, she reported it to law enforcement. She said people affiliated with their former church harassed and pressured her after learning she had filed the report.

In its 2019 series, “Coverings,” the Post-Gazette reported on multiple stories about survivors of child sexual abuse in Plain church communities. These churches include Amish and conservative Mennonite groups marked by plain dress, male leadership, separation from the wider culture and a strong emphasis on piety and forgiveness.

Survivors of abuse and their advocates said church leaders frequently shamed victims and dealt with sexual offenses as sins, to be dealt with in church discipline, rather than reporting them as crimes to legal authorities. Victims said that given their churches’ emphasis on forgiveness, they were often pressured victims to reconcile with abusers, leaving children vulnerable to further abuse.

Church officials have said they have improved their responses to abuse in recent years, reporting perpetrators under state laws mandating such reports and educating members about abuse and prevention.

Advertise with us

Michael Kauffman faces an Aug. 17 sentencing hearing. The prosecutor and defense attorney agreed to a prison sentence of five to 10 years, plus 10 years’ probation, as part of the plea agreement. But Judge Christylee Peck noted that she is not bound by that agreement and could impose a different sentence.

Ms. Kauffman said she and the children were angered that he didn’t enter a guilty plea and admit to the charges, although he did admit to the strength of the evidence against him. “They took it really hard,” she said.

Among those accompanying them to court were members of the Guardians of the Children, a biker group that provides shows of support to victims who might feel intimidated going to court hearings.

“Having the Guardians there was awesome,” Ms. Kauffman said.

She has been outspoken in recent years in advocating for victims within Plain communities, and a documentary filmmaking team was outside the courthouse today as part of a larger production on abuse in the Plain churches.

Advertise with us

Ms. Kauffman said law-enforcement officials in Central Pennsylvania, home to large populations of Plain church members, have increasingly become aware of abuse cases and are taking them seriously. But she said more work needs to be done to address the issue.

“I feel like there’s definitely been progress the last two years, especially within the local system,” she said. “But as a whole, we’re still miles behind.”

Peter Smith: petersmith@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1416; Twitter @PG_PeterSmith.