WARREN, Ohio —The wood-paneled courtroom had a typical morning crowd Tuesday — defendants in jail jumpsuits or civilian clothing, lawyers conferring with their clients and each other.
Daniel Ray Kurtz might not have attracted much attention in such a crowd, even though he arrived in the dark jacket and straw hat that are signatures of his membership in the substantial Amish community of northeastern Ohio.
Except that more than a half-dozen people had come to observe his day in Trumbull County Common Pleas Court, most of them women from a widening movement of advocacy for victims of child sexual abuse among the Amish, Mennonites and other self-described Plain People.
Two were women who had grown up in the local Amish community, while others had traveled as much as 200 miles to be here on a wintry morning on behalf of the unseen victim.
Kurtz, 54, with white, thinning hair and a wispy white beard, walked forward when his case was called. He stood between his lawyers, his head bowed, as the judge questioned him to make sure he wanted to waive his right to a trial. Then came the time for his plea.
“Guilty, your honor,” Kurtz said, admitting to two counts of unlawful sexual conduct with a minor for engaging a 14-year-old boy in oral sex this summer at his rural home in Trumbull County. He now awaits a sentencing that could range as high as five years for each count.
Read More
The advocates in the gallery, and others like them, have been showing up at these kinds of hearings in rural courthouses across Pennsylvania and eastern Ohio in recent weeks.
Several of them came to the November sentencing in Millersburg, Ohio, of a confessed serial abuser and ex-missionary for a Plain-affiliated ministry. Others came to the December no-contest plea of an Amish man in Lancaster, Pa., convicted of abusing four girls. A similar group came to a December court hearing in Cumberland County for a defendant charged with rape and other sexual offenses against three girls.
Although Kurtz arrived alone to his court hearing, defendants in some cases are accompanied by supportive relatives and Plain church members.
Joanna Yoder of Mifflinburg, Pa., said that’s why she and others show up on behalf of victims.
“I don’t know what (supporters of the suspects) think, but what I hope they see is we won’t be intimidated by them any longer,” said Ms. Yoder, who helped establish the grassroots group Never Stand Alone to organize such support. She has attended recent court hearings in Ohio, Pennsylvania and Minnesota.
Barbara Miller of nearby Orwell, Ohio, added after the Kurtz hearing: “I would say it's the first time in Trumbull County that a group came for the victims.”
This has been a year of reckoning for survivors of child sexual abuse in the separatist Plain communities, many of whose stories were told in the Post-Gazette’s series, “Coverings,” earlier this year
“I feel like the whole world changed in a year,” said survivor and advocate Trudy Metzger of Ontario, Canada.
The six-part “Coverings” series, which ran in May and June, chronicled the ordeals of survivors of child sexual abuse in the insular Plain communities and their families.
In the series, survivors said they were often instructed by church leaders to reconcile with their abusers if the latter professed repentance — risking excommunication or shunning if they refused.
For members of a separatist culture, this would mean isolation from the only community they know.
Such situations left victims and other children vulnerable to further abuse, said survivors, who have criticized church officials for treating abuse as a sin but not reporting it as a crime, and for being naively willing to believe abusers who claimed to have repented and reformed.
Church leaders acknowledge past mistakes and say they’ve made great strides in recent years — reporting abuse to the law, allowing victims to seek justice and understanding the serious compulsions of predators to attack again.
The Plain People are from a network of churches organized around small, tightly disciplined conservative Christian congregations, committed to non-violence and cultural separatism. They wear simple, conservative clothing that includes head coverings and long dresses for women and work clothes or dark suits for men.
The Plain churches are in many states and Canada but are especially concentrated in Pennsylvania, Ohio and Indiana, notably around Lancaster County, Pa., and the Holmes-Wayne and the Geauga-Trumbull county areas of Ohio.
Plain communities now have committees that serve as liaisons with law enforcement and child-welfare officials.
Some advocates for victims are still skeptical of such committees, given such things as churches’ history of handling cases in-house rather than as criminal matters, although some of the most notorious cases of the past year in Lancaster and Clearfield counties were reported by Plain church leaders.
In the Holmes-Wayne county area of Ohio, the Amish committee known as the Restoration Team has been on a learning curve, said member Mark Hochstetler.
A few years ago in Wayne County, he said, law enforcement and family-services officials “had meetings with the church leaders and said, ‘You need to do something about this problem,’” Mr. Hochstetler recalled in an interview.
“The church leadership was like, ‘We're not really sure there is a problem,’” he said.
“But then, in one year's time, we had a couple of high-profile cases,” he said. “And then the church leadership was like, ‘Well, you know what? We need to do something about it.’"
When a case comes to the committee’s attention, he said, it is important to ensure it’s reported to law enforcement. “I am not comfortable hiding abuse, not only from a legal standpoint but from a moral standpoint.”
He added: “I'll admit we made a lot of mistakes. Hopefully we learned some things along the way.”
Many cases of abuse from years ago are only now coming to light.
One of the most egregious cases involved Jeriah Mast, a former missionary in Haiti for the Plain-affiliated Christian Aid Ministries, who was sentenced in November to nine years in prison for abusing two boys in Ohio and confessed to abusing 30 more in Haiti. His supervisors allowed had him to remain in Haiti for years after he confessed to “sexual activity with young men.”
These and other cases have galvanized not only survivors of abuse but people in the churches “who were not victims, who would have been quiet,” said Hope Anne Dueck of Zanesville, Ohio, founder of the educational group A Better Way.
She said Plain churches still have a long way to go in understanding how to prevent and respond to abuse.
“Is it fixed? No,” she said. “But the climate is better.”
Ms. Metzger’s organization, Generations Unleashed, held a November conference on abuse in Plain communities in Lancaster that included an open-microphone segment for those who wanted to tell their stories of recovering from abuse. The session went far longer than planned.
“I have never in my living days seen anything like that, with that many people wanting to share,” Ms. Metzger said.
Audrey Kauffman of Cumberland County said she was deeply moved that a large group of advocates accompanied her to court when she observed a preliminary hearing at which her ex-husband, Michael Kauffman, faced 32 counts alleging sexual assault of their daughters. He has pleaded not guilty in the pending case.
“I told them I have never in my life had someone to stand with me like this, ever,” Ms. Kauffman said.
Kurtz’s hearing drew not only advocates from the Plain churches but also two from Akron who had been active in seeking justice for another group of survivors of abuse in a religious setting — children of Protestant missionaries who had been sexually assaulted overseas.
“These kinds of connections with other advocates,” Ms. Dueck said, are “critically important.”
Peter Smith: petersmith@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1416; Twitter @PG_PeterSmith.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.