They are among a new American majority, those who don’t belong to any religious congregation.

Only 47% percent of Americans surveyed in 2020 said they belonged to a church, synagogue or mosque, according to Gallup.

That’s down from 70% in 1999. In fact, the figure had hovered at around 70% ever since the opinion-research company began asking the question on surveys in 1937 — until the 21st century.

Guitarist Derek Zanetti poses for a portrait in his home sound room Thursday, April 29, 2021, in Hazelwood. (Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Beyond each statistic is a story.

Advertise with us

Derek Zanetti of Hazelwood grew up attending a conservative evangelical church. As a teenager he began clandestinely recording radio broadcasts of punk and other forbidden music over sermon tapes (keeping the labels on as disguise).

For a time as a young adult, he attended a progressive church that did regular outreach to the homeless and other misfits. It was good transition for him, but eventually he found inspiration and community entirely outside of organized religion — amid the “radical inclusion” of the punk rock shows he attends and performs.

“If church is done right, if church is truly a place for the broken, where the last, the least and the lost are supposed to find wholeness, what better place than a punk show?’ said Mr. Zanetti, 38. Even the name of his act, the Homeless Gospel Choir, was based on this ideal of “what it looks like to bring joy and peace.”

Wilkinsburg author Deesha Philyaw has won the Story Prize for her collection of short stories, “The Secret Lives of Church Ladies.” (Vanessa German)

Deesha Philyaw of Wilkinsburg was immersed in church life from childhood into her adult years, enough to provide ample material for her award-winning fiction. But she hasn’t been a church member for several years, with the turning point coming when she lost her mother, father and a grandparent within a year.

“I felt empty, and the church didn’t fill that, and Christianity didn’t fill that for me,” said Ms. Philyaw, 49. “There’s no anger. It’s just, ‘What am I doing? I’m doing this out of habit.’ I consider myself spiritually to be in a place of learning, but the kind of comfort and solace that I needed but didn’t find in church, I found in my friends and my family.”

Advertise with us

Karl Osterhout of Oakmont spent years of his adult life involved in church, but he always struggled to believe in God.

“I tried to explain this to people,” he said, and they tried to convince him that he should believe. They never quite accepted “that I was actually telling the truth, that I might know myself better” than they did, recalled Mr. Osterhout, 62. “I decided at some point, all right, I’m just going to start with the truth of the thing and see where it takes me.”

Ashley Taylor grew up Catholic and was an altar server from age 9 into her college years. (Beck Mullen)

Ashley Taylor grew up Catholic and was an altar server from age 9 into her college years. But as she studied literature and music in college, “I got the opportunity to learn other perspectives. I started having lots of questions,” said Ms. Taylor, 30, of Wilkinsburg.

For a time she played in the worship band at the Presbyterian church of a colleague, but eventually she embraced a secular, non-religious outlook. “I got a lot more out of poetry or even the novels I was studying than I was out of the Bible at that point,” she said. She’s now president of Sunday Assembly Pittsburgh, which provides some of the things a congregation does, gathering for upbeat music, inspirational talks and social outings, but from an entirely secular perspective.

To be sure, there are plenty of caveats behind the downward statistics:

Advertise with us
  • Belonging to a house of worship is not the same as attending one. Some places of worship — newer megachurches, immigrant mosques and temples, senior-home chapels — may not have the same tradition of formal membership as do establishment congregations, even for people who show up every week.
  • Nor is belonging the same as believing. Some of the decline in membership is among Catholics, Protestants and others who do profess a religious faith — but aren’t signing membership cards.

“People still have beliefs, even superstitions,” said Arthur Farnsley, professor of religious studies at Indiana University-Purdue University Indianapolis, who focused on unchurched believers in his book “Flea Market Jesus.” “But religion as a set of organizations with authority and the ability to shape our lives through ethics, rituals, public shaming, etc., etc., has unquestionably declined,” he said via email. “The real winner in this is individualism.”

Caveats aside, the “major factor” in lower congregational membership is rising secularism, said Gallup Senior Editor Jeffrey Jones.

“The increase in people who don’t have a religion accounts for a majority of the change,” he said.

Americans who don’t identify with any religion grew to 21% from 8% of the total population in the past two decades, according to Gallup. (The Pew Research Center puts it at 26%.) Perhaps surprisingly, some of them still belong to a religious congregation, but almost all don’t.

Moreover, the decline in congregational membership is happening with virtually every major demographic group.

Advertise with us

There are differences in rates of decline.

Black congregational membership declined at a faster pace than white membership while remaining higher overall.

Membership is slowly ebbing among older adults, but it’s plunging among younger adults. Only half of Generation X (born between 1965 and 1980) and just over a third of millennials (1981-1996) belong to a congregation.

Most millennials were too young to be polled as adults two decades ago, but even looking back one decade, their membership dropped 15 percentage points. Ten years ago, many of them may have considered themselves members of their parents’ congregations, Mr. Jones said. “Now they’re probably on their own, not aligned with their parents.”

In Eastern states, including Pennsylvania, membership dropped by a quarter of the population, to 44%. Mr. Jones attributed this partly to the region’s high numbers of Catholics, whose membership has dropped more sharply than Protestants’. Membership is even lower in the West, at 38%. (There wasn’t a breakdown by individual state.)

Advertise with us

More than half of adults are still congregational members in the South and Midwest, though that was nearly three-quarters at the turn of the century.

For many religious leaders, the Gallup report was the latest in a long line of reports showing declines in religious belief, behavior and belonging.

“In previous generations, church membership was what everybody did,” said the Rev. Liddy Barlow, executive minister of Christian Associates of Southwest Pennsylvania, an organization of several Catholic, Orthodox and Protestant denominations. “People affiliated sometimes to gain social advantage” or because that’s what their peers expected.

“Now, church membership is more elective,” she said. The challenge is to “make our churches places where people actually want to be and have authentic relations with each other and with God.”

She added: “I wouldn’t want anybody to join a congregation out of social pressure or fear of hellfire. If you take those two out of the way, then those of us who are encouraging church membership have to say why that matters. For me, choosing to be a church member is about discovering the people I want to be on a spiritual journey with.”

Advertise with us

Many follow that journey outside the lines of congregational membership.

The Jewish Community Center of Greater Pittsburgh offers spiritually themed dialogues and other programs without organized-religious formality, said Rabbi Ron Symons of the JCC’s Center for Loving Kindness.

The programs draw a mix of people — Jews and non-Jews with little or no ties to congregations, as well as synagogue members. Its afternoon programming on Yom Kippur, a Jewish holy day marked by fasting and worship, draws some people who spent the morning at synagogue and others who spent it at work, he said.

“The issue with religion in America is not about the product,” he said. “The product of connectivity to each other, to generations past and yet to be, the product of connectivity to the world of the spirit, to the divine — all of that is good and of value in our world. Our challenge is about the delivery” of those connections and values.

The Pittsburgh Buddhist Center in Harrison doesn’t have a formal membership process for participants, many of whom are drawn to the center’s meditation programs and teaching sessions, said Bhante Pemaratana, its abbot.

Advertise with us

Participants often share that they left the church they grew up in. He doesn’t bring the subject up, he said, but often they do, saying they felt their church was too political, or it failed to resonate with them spiritually.

“One thing I realized in people who have some distance from their religious tradition, it is mainly due to the lack of personal touch,” he said. The rituals seem “very mechanical for them.”

Kate Mackin, board president for the Himalayan Institute of Pittsburgh, poses for a portrait at the Himalayan Institute of Pittsburgh Yoga Studio on Friday, April 30, 2021, in Mt Lebanon. (Andrew Rush / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Kate Mackin, board president for the Himalayan Institute of Pittsburgh, grew up Catholic, but she has found more spiritual nurture and community in her practices of yoga and meditation. The institute, in Mt. Lebanon, offers classes, retreats and other programs aiming to incorporate the principles of yoga into everyday life.

She still draws on Catholic prayers at times, and she encourages fellow yoga practitioners who remain strongly involved with their faith and congregations. She noted that the Yoga Sutras, which form the basis of the practice, emerged in an ancient, multi-religious context in Asia.

She herself no longer belongs to a church. “It wasn’t that I was mad about anything, but it wasn’t doing it for me anymore,” she said. “I wanted to be inspired, I wanted to be thinking about bigger things. It was limited to me, even though there’s a lot of beauty in it, and I have a lot of respect for the things that were passed down over time.”

Advertise with us

Kentucky Pentecostal pastor Paul Prather, in a widely circulated column for the Lexington Herald-Leader, offered numerous possible explanations for the drop in membership: relentless news of scandals in the Catholic and other churches; the spread of religious skepticism on the internet and in the books of prominent atheists; the competition for time on Sundays with youth sports and other activities; and the alliances between churches and politicians, particularly on the right.

He wrote that after the pandemic-related shutdowns, “significant numbers of those who’ve had to sit out for the past year may never return.” Christianity, he wrote, “will have to adjust to becoming an ever-smaller slice of the spiritual pie. That’s not necessarily a bad thing,” given that those who remain will be more committed.

The declining church membership among African Americans is particularly striking given the historically central role played in the civil rights movement by churches and clergy such as the Rev. Martin Luther King Jr.

Ms. Philyaw — who drew on her observations growing up in a variety of Black churches in writing her award-winning short story collection, “The Secret Lives of Church Ladies” — sees multiple factors. Mass incarceration disrupted the steady ties that many Black men would have developed with churches. And even amid some denominations’ notable advances in ordaining women pastors and bishops, other churches maintained and even “exalted” male pastors.

“In my generation, Generation X, the church had less of a hold on us,” she said. “As Black women began to find our way in academia and arts and in every arena, the church was an institution where we were secondary. We did all the work, but the leaders were predominately male, and some of us began to look more askance of that.”

Advertise with us

And the current Black Lives Matter leadership emerged in large part from outside the church.

“The church is trying to figure out how to play a role,” she said. “You can’t be part of a movement that’s led by Black women and queer people and still preaching they are secondary.”

The Rev. Leeann Younger, pastor of Cityview Church in Spring Garden, said she sees many people suspicious about church. Her small congregation puts a premium on outreach to the needy and seeks to be “a little bit of a refuge for folks who have been uncertain about what they think about the church,” particularly after seeing many church leaders backing former President Donald Trump.

“Ultimately when it comes down to the practice of church — Black, white, whatever — the question is, what does this have to do with my daily life?” she said.

Many are finding sources of meaning and inspiration elsewhere.

Advertise with us

Mr. Osterhout recalled having a nominal church upbringing in New York State. Things changed when he enrolled in Geneva College, a conservative Reformed Presbyterian school in Beaver Falls, where his girlfriend had also enrolled. “It was a good place for me at the time, but I sure as heck didn’t know what I was getting into,” he said.

He became a born-again Christian in 1976 (on the day Americans voted in the born-again Jimmy Carter as president). He said Geneva and church involvement provided much-needed stability, but over time he found he couldn’t ignore his inability to believe in God or in doctrines such as substitutionary atonement, that God required the blood sacrifice of Jesus to save sinners. Going through a divorce and family tragedy, he found religion fostered more guilt than comfort.

He helped found an informal “Quaker-y” church but eventually left that, too.

He’s still fascinated by religion and its rituals. After a cancer diagnosis a few years ago, he invited his friends, including some with church connections, to a gathering in his yard. As an amateur musician, he arranged a program that included songs like Monty Python’s iconoclastic, “Always Look on the Bright Side of Life.”

“I wasn’t sure I wasn’t saying goodbye,” he said. “It was a way of gathering a bunch of people I cared about in one place. In my head, it was almost liturgical.”

Advertise with us

Ms. Taylor said she finds similar inspiration — the community that a congregation offers, without the religion — at Sunday Assembly: “You get to be in community while thinking about something bigger than yourself, usually with the idea of doing something meaningful in the world.”

Twitter: PG_PeterSmith