The formats may be different this year, but many churches will hold in-person services for Christmas Eve and Christmas Day.
Most Catholic parishes and many Protestant churches will be holding in-person worship of some sort — although many others, particularly Protestant churches in Episcopal, Presbyterian and other traditions, will be worshipping only through online services or through outdoor processions or live nativity scenes.
A spot check of churches open for services finds that virtually all of them are limiting attendance through distanced seating arrangements and requiring or urging measures such as mask-wearing and temperature checks.
Houses of worship are exempt from Pennsylvania’s current limits of 10 people for indoor gatherings and 50 for outdoor gatherings, though the website of the state’s official coronavirus policies says religious “institutions are strongly encouraged to find alternative methods for worship, as in person gatherings pose a significant risk to participants at this time. While this an incredibly difficult recommendation to make, particularly at this time of year, faith leaders must carefully weigh the health risks to their congregants given the immense amount of community spread of COVID-19.”
Even with all the precautions against COVID-19, another factor may further lower attendance: bad weather. Falling snow and falling temperatures are predicted.
The Catholic Diocese of Pittsburgh has a listing of all Christmas Eve and Christmas Day services on its website. Bishop David Zubik authorized parishes to begin worship as soon as 2 p.m. Thursday, sooner than usual, so that parishes could add services and space out attendance, enabling social distancing.
The diocese’s pandemic-era policies limit attendance to 50% of capacity, with pastors allowed to restrict it further.
Bishop Zubik will be presiding at a livestreamed Mass at 10 p.m. Christmas Eve from St. Paul Cathedral Parish. The parish is having nine services in total across the two days at the Oakland cathedral and its other church sites.
Many parishes are taking reservations.
For the Rev. Nicholas Vaskov, the goal is not to limit crowds but to give parishes an idea of how many people to expect.
“If we turn people away at Christmas, we’ve lost. That was the experience of Jesus, Mary and Joseph being turned away at the inn,” said Father Vaskov, pastor of Christ the Savior Parish in the North Side and director of the Shrines of Pittsburgh, a cluster of historic churches.
Several of the region’s largest Protestant churches are having in-person Christmas services. Amplify Church, North Way Christian Community, Orchard Hill Church, Victory Family Church and others are having multiple in-person services, typically with protocols such as taking reservations to enable distanced seating and encouraging or requiring mask wearing.
The Bible Chapel has been holding two Christmas Eve-themed services each night from Monday through Thursday at its large South Hills campus in Peters, and it plans services Thursday at its campuses around the region.
Several Orthodox churches that observe Christmas this Friday are planning some in-person worship. (Other Orthodox traditions use a different liturgical calendar and will observe Christmas later.)
St. Nicholas Greek Orthodox Cathedral has remained open for worship with limited attendance throughout the pandemic, as many worshipers have participated online only, said the Rev. Christopher Bender of St. Nicholas. In a typical year, the Christmas Day service is well attended.
“It’s so hard to predict” this year, he said. In addition to COVID, “I think the weather will play a big role.”
The Rev. Liddy Barlow, executive minister of Christian Associates of Southwest Pennsylvania, said many churches in that ecumenical organization had resumed in-person worship over the summer.
“With our increasing case count, a lot of our churches have moved back to all-digital, right in the middle of one of the busiest worship seasons of the year,” she said. “There’s a sense of loss and sadness. At the same time, there’s a sense of creative possibility, of what is possible in this new form.”
Among the varied approaches being taken is one by Emmanuel Lutheran Church of Eastmont, which plans an outdoor procession based on the Latin American tradition of Posadas, which re-enacts the Christmas journey of the Holy Family in seeking shelter.
A majority of area United Methodist churches are worshipping online-only for Christmas, with some meeting either indoors or outside.
Where in-person worship is canceled, “People are disappointed,” said Bishop Cynthia Moore-Koikoi of the denomination’s Western Pennsylvania Conference. “Most folks are understanding it’s something we have to do. There are a few people who are very upset by it.” She encouraged everyone to recognize “our churches are not closed; we’re just doing church in a different way.”
Most area churches in the Presbyterian Church (U.S.A.) are having Christmas worship online-only or with outdoor activities, said the Rev. Sheldon Sorge, general minister of the Pittsburgh Presbytery.
Episcopal Bishop Dorsey McConnell, who asked churches in the Pittsburgh diocese to cancel in-person worship through Christmas and until there’s improvement in the pandemic, took heart from efforts such as Christian Associates’ call for people to sing “Silent Night” outside their homes at 6:30 p.m. on Christmas Eve.
He pre-recorded himself for parts of a video Christmas service at Trinity Episcopal Cathedral in Downtown, dressing in full liturgical garb — and “giving my blessing to a camera. It’s a very strange world right now, but we trust it’s going to be a blessing to folks.”
Peter Smith: petersmith@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1416; Twitter @PG_PeterSmith.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.