Pennsylvania Supreme Court justices on Tuesday heard oral arguments in a potentially precedent-setting case involving sexual abuse by Catholic clergy — and put the bulk of their skeptical questions to the attorney of a woman suing decades after her alleged abuse.
At issue is the claim by plaintiff Renee Rice, of Altoona, that the Diocese of Altoona-Johnstown conspired to cover up abuse by priests including that of her own alleged assailant — the Rev. Charles Bodziak — in the 1970s and 1980s. She sued the diocese for alleged fraud and concealment, saying it was not until a 2016 statewide grand jury report that she learned of “a massive, systemic conspiracy of cover-up to allow … children to be abused repeatedly,” attorney Alan Perer said.
But in repeated questioning, some of the justices echoed the argument of the diocese’s own attorney — that a plaintiff has an obligation within the statute of limitations to investigate the source of her injury and those who may have been responsible for it. Under the two-year statute, she would have had two years after turning 18 to sue over the abuse itself.
“We know, at the time of the abuse, that the plaintiff was aware of the fact that she was injured and that someone else was potentially responsible for that,” said Justice Christine Donohue. “… We don't have a rule where you get an endless period of time to discover all of your causes of action.”
Mr. Perer said until the grand jury report, nobody, including local law enforcement and child welfare officials, knew the extent of the alleged conspiracy. He reiterated this lawsuit is not over the abuse directly but the alleged conspiracy on the part of the diocese, noting it kept Father Bodziak in ministry long after she corresponded with the diocese about her abuse in 2006, and even then, the diocese never told her it knew years earlier of other alleged abuse by Father Bodziak, information revealed by the grand jury.
“They didn't say, ‘Oh, we know about this guy,’ and nothing was ever done … until 2016 when he retired or left the ministry,” Mr. Perer said.
He said it should be up to a jury to decide whether she should have pursued her lawsuit earlier based on the facts in the case.
Father Bodziak, now 79, was removed from ministry early in 2016 by Bishop Mark Bartchak shortly before the release of the grand jury report. There is no court record of his being charged with any criminal offense on Pennsylvania's online court docket. He remains on the diocese's list of priests removed from ministry due to an abuse allegation pending a final resolution of the allegation.
The outcome of this case has large implications for Catholic dioceses throughout the state.
Ms. Rice’s lawsuit, filed in 2016, was dismissed by a Blair County judge who said the statute of limitations precluded suing over long-ago abuse.
But the state Superior Court ruled in 2019 that she could pursue her claim, reversing its own precedent in past cases that had made it difficult for Pennsylvania victims to sue over abuse that had happened long ago. In similar cases in the early 2000s, the Superior Court had ruled in favor of the church, but it based its latest ruling on a new Supreme Court precedent in a medical malpractice case, which said a patient with Lyme disease could sue long after a misdiagnosis because it took years for the disease to manifest itself.
The 2016 grand jury reported that in Altoona-Johnstown, the state’s smallest Roman Catholic diocese, hundreds of children were abused by at least 50 priests and others associated with the church across nearly half a century.
Numerous plaintiffs have used the same legal theory of alleged fraud and conspiracy as the basis for lawsuits against the Pittsburgh, Greensburg and other dioceses that were subjects of a similar and larger grand jury report in 2018 into alleged abuse by priests across much of the state. Those still-pending lawsuits hinge on the precedent in the Altoona-Johnstown case. The Diocese of Harrisburg already filed for bankruptcy protection in part out of concern that this legal theory could prevail.
These cases proceeded even as legislation that would extend the statute of limitations, as other states have done, has not yet passed in Pennsylvania.
Justice Donohue, in questioning Mr. Perer, used the same analogy used by the diocese’s attorney, Eric Anderson: That someone who is injured in a car accident has the obligation to begin suing the other driver within the statute of limitations. That lawsuit could reveal information that, say, the other car’s manufacturer had installed faulty brakes, just as an abuse lawsuit could reveal alleged complicity by a diocese.
She and Mr. Anderson both cited extensive publicity over decades of news coverage of sexual abuse by priests and cover-ups by Catholic authorities. Mr. Anderson noted that in addition to national and international coverage, the diocese itself was subject to extensive, highly publicized litigation years ago over an abusive priest, Francis Luddy.
Justice Max Baer asked Mr. Anderson if this is a matter that should go to a jury to determine whether the diocese in fact took Ms. Rice off guard by sending her a letter in 2006 that indicated it was taking her claim seriously, “arguably … obfuscating that there was this conspiracy on behalf of the diocese.”
But he also questioned Mr. Perer skeptically: “It seems to me that what the plaintiff arguably did wrong here was she didn't seek counsel,” because any competent lawyer would have researched right away the question of “what did the church know.”
Chief Justice Thomas Saylor echoed the question. He noted that in his own court’s recent decision in the Lyme disease case, “the woman … didn't know that she had Lyme disease, so she couldn't sue the physician. This woman knew she'd been abused, so she could have sued the priest. And if you sue the priest, typically you sue the employer.”
But Mr. Perer said that’s a matter for a jury to decide. “We're talking about the diocese here and being a cause,” he said. “That is a factual question before anything.”




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.