Hundreds gathered at Rodef Shalom Congregation in Shadyside on Sunday afternoon to read the Torah passage that three Squirrel Hill congregations were about to read one year ago when a gunman halted their Sabbath observance and killed 11 members.
This Oct. 27, the Jewish community open its doors for Torah study “to finish the work that we started a year ago and could not finish because we were interrupted. It’s a way of being together again and moving onward,” said Rabbi Doris Dyen, spiritual leader of an independent worship group called Makom HaLev.
Rabbi Dyen also is a longtime member of Congregation Dor Hadash, one of the three congregations that were meeting in the Tree of Life synagogue when the attack occurred.
The gunman attacked when Dor Hadash was just about to have a scheduled Torah study last year on the 18th to 22nd chapters of Genesis, and Tree of Life/Or L’Simcha and New Light congregations were starting services where that passage was scheduled to be read.
The selection meditates on the theme of “what happens when we encounter strangers,” Rabbi Dyen said. In it, the patriarch Abraham encounters three strangers and welcomes them into his tent.
Rabbi Dyen and longtime Dor Hadash member Daniel Leger took turns reading the passage Sunday and called on members of the crowd to discuss the passage. Rabbi Yitzhak Husbands-Hankin, of Eugene, Ore., as well as several other rabbis, joined them as well.
Read More
Mr. Leger was scheduled to read the passage last year when he was severely wounded in the attack. He has largely recovered from his injuries.
Just a week before last year’s attack, Dor Hadash had participated in the National Refugee Shabbat program, where the congregation studied issues of displaced people around the world.
Rabbi Dyen said they prepared “to explore with people what kind of character traits are being manifested by the characters in the story. And also, what does the idea of righteousness mean … in dealing with how we approach that encounter of strangers who come into our midst?”
There is no right answer, Rabbi Dyen said, but plenty of questions are raised.
“I think that the questions, oddly enough, are more interesting than any one answer,” she said “That’s what Torah study is about.”
The study leaders and attendees discussed Abraham’s generosity and what giving and welcoming mean in our communities today.
“What was really wonderful about the discussion is that it stepped up to what we’re all feeling in terms of hospitality and fear,” said Heather Aronson, 57, of Shadyside.
She remarked that during the study a couple water bottles fell, and “each time, I saw ourselves sort of jump, and that’s going to carry with us now.”
“... the idea of inviting in a stranger, it made me immediately think of the Charleston shooter,” said Ms. Aronson’s 20-year-old daughter Samantha Schattan, referring to the 2015 attack in Charleston, S.C. when a gunman killed nine worshippers. “He was invited in to do Bible study, much like we were doing Torah study today. It’s hard to know who you can invite in, and who you can’t. ... [but] it’s important to remember our ideals, that we should invite strangers, but to also be cautious.”
The two-hour Torah study was just one event among several Sunday to commemorate the lives of those killed. Five separate sessions were held each hour, with a break in between for refreshments and fellowship.
Rabbi Amy Bardack, director of Jewish life and learning at the Jewish Federation of Greater Pittsburgh, said there’s a more general reason for both the Torah study and the social outreaches.
“Two ways to honor the deceased are through Torah study and acts of lovingkindness,” she said. “Both of those things are classically Jewish.”
Another session focused on later verses in Genesis when Abraham tries to bargain with God to save two cities from destruction. Though he fails, Abraham does not give up.
“I think that’s what the community [is] saying: ‘We’re not done being Jewish … we’re going to engage and maybe even in a stronger fashion,’” said Daniel Seigel, 57, of Mt. Lebanon. “I’m glad the community had this day to give an opportunity to have not just commemoration but also to do something that was specifically exercising our Judaism. We’re very much about studying. That’s a very Jewish thing to do.”
Ashley Murray: amurray@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1750; Andrew Goldstein: agoldstein@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1352; Peter Smith: petersmith@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1416





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.